- Jan 10, 2018
- 8,091
- 16,692
Maybe because NTR is not about being unfaithful cause the woman wants to be unfaithful that is just plain old cheating if there is a relation which already has enough people not liking it in itself, but about the female being physically, enotionally and or sexually abused by an asshole, also known as rape whether you call it blackmail, drugging or direct forced or whatever? That in itself is already one of the most divisive tags and loads of people simply hate to come in contact with, together with loli, heavy dom and vore to give a few other examples beyond the obvious incest tag and yeah I have also seen game threads derail when there was suddenly a sister added in update 10 in past.I love that people still complain about NTR.
There are games on this site where you fuck children and yet people can't shut up about a woman being unfaithful.
I'd put comedy first, then porn, and story isn't on the list because the game is built as a satire of mindless fuck 'em all games. There are narrative elements to keep the game moving and on the rails, but it couldn't be a satire if I implemented anything more. I'll never understand people thinking this was my attempt at a story and seriously critiquing it. It's like if I made a parody of Bazooka Joe comics and people kept giving me one star for story.
Lydia in What if as long as she does it out of own free will is not even truly NTR, others will feel differently though and site rules would name it so and well due to fact that in almost any game any other male is an abusive asshole it is not so weird that every other dick has gotten mixed up with the three letter tag even if it is just other dick if not abusive and not taking away. (Edit: To be just as clear the Brenna what if scene was full on rape with her being drugged on purpose for that, whether she liked it and made an ahegao face or not, but not NTR if he did not take her way from Mc after and she went back to MC. Would only be NTR if she suddeny was addicted to be raped by Hunter and the Hunter dick).
If you add the cuck element as well from point of MC that not everyone likes either, well there you have it and why people hate that tag so much. Just like many people decided not to go see a movie like The Accused cause of a certain scene even if it is a great movie with deep story, some things really fuck with peoples emotions while something like anal might not be to your liking, but will not.
Another thing is that games with a NTR setup somehow even when there is a more romantic or corruption route almost invariable lead to an incompetent MC and one dimensional females with no brains that act completely different to that MC as to the overpowered NTR NPC's that also acts like a cockblock (a certain Eric for example) might be a factor.
Loads of people will not like it or even hate it even when is not shown but strong part of the story, while others like or even love it or just do not care as long as there are hot scenes. People talking about content of what if in this thread does not help that even if I get they are excited to get content they love, that is why I wished they had gotten their own separate thread with link to the game, since that discussion will never go away when NTR mixes with other genres. Now you did quite great job in your game and came closer to have people accept it in a game that do not like it as almost any dev I have seen make it work until now, but you never will get rid of it completely. Not understanding or down playing why that particular fetish is so disliked by some, does not help either even if you feel different yourself.
Last edited: