So a couple things i want to tackle here.
In regards to the vanilla vs ntr complaints coming from the vanilla side. I can understand their frustration because though the ntr scenes are in the minority the sheer size of the ntr scene continues to grow. If you look at the chapter 10 bad end with Ophelia, Hunter gets head, goes down on her, does multiple positions and finally creampies. That's much longer than most of the Sterling vanilla scenes. It can leave the pro vanilla feeling cheated because though numerous the scenes feel much shorter.
When you look at the more recent what ifs what used to be shorter mini scenes continue to grow in length and to be fair in quality. Look at everything from 4 on which are all ntr scenes.
4- you get a full length Hunter Brenna scene, plus the guide and Catherine also fucking and Ophelia sucking dick.
5- you get an Aliza solo scene, an Amber solo scene and a threesome.
6- escalating scenes with Hunter and Breanna that end with a fully in-depth scene to close it out.
7- you get a nobody that gets multiple scenes with Catherine, Ophelia, Brenna and a full blown orgy at the end.
8- Ophelia literally fucks every fuckable character in game (minus Rebecca if memory is correct) then moved on to characters from 3 other VNs. So that's 13 different females she gets.
The divide between ntr and vanilla content which used to be 90-10 is no longer that. So for the vanilla players to feel cheated isn't that unfair considering they have to wait 6 months in-between getting anything.
My suggestion to help improve on this is for WWG to tweak his rules on What Ifs. Based on the scale that they have grown to why can't we have scenarios to cater to both. Would it hurt there was one less ntr scene and a vanilla scene. Look at the most recent what if. He could have given the vanilla crowd the Aliza scene without interruption and the vanilla fans would have gotten something for them to help with the development time wait. Make the what ifs like the bad end scenes in game where a simple choice gives either the vanilla or the ntr and keep everyone happy.
I'm not trying to pick sides here based on liking both types on content. Just trying to make a rational explanation for the vanilla players feelings without being overly confrontational.