I haven't taken Nat or V, but both Jasmine and Allison did great at the ball based on their own expertise in whatever. When first playing the game I thought it was super important who you took and I thought Allie would be the best overall choice, so I took her even on my Jasmine playthrough. Now, months later and with a bit more experience in AVN porn logic I realize that no, it just comes down to which lewd scene you wanted like
jadepaladin said. The scene was written for each one you take so that it was a great success regardless of who it was.
I wonder how soon there'll be any interactions between MC, Maggie, and
Jasmine any of the other main LIs? She seems like a parallel story with only tangental interactions with the main one, but at some point its all gonna come crashing together.