Ok i finally got to play(hey I'm a busy guy usually, oh who am i kidding i fell asleep).
First off yikes Nicole. I take back what i said, after seeing the context behind the scene it somewhat makes sense in a twisted I'm going to rape you from now on since you want to play hard to get kind of way. MC reaction to it was actually what i imagine it would be so my bad for jumping the gun. The bad route is definitely the best route in my eyes.
I also like that the Dev has some of the girls soft locked behind different routes. It's a good penalty and actually makes your choice matter/more consistent with the MC personality on both routes.
To quote the MC- Reedley is so fucking hot. She's definitely on my list for the next girl im catching. I'm kinda sad chloe isn't getting as much of the spotlight though atleast on the Bad route, I'm still playing the good route so she's probably there.
Jess is still best girl. Carol is still as cute as ever. Ashley on the other hand was handled well on the punishment choice but she just can't help herself until it's too late.
Now back to Nicole. After replaying through. You see the MC forgive her somewhat over time which is something i wanted because his change over time seemed more real well until that ending lol. Let me say this, i don't hate Nicole, in fact i want to bone her as much as everyone else but i don't enjoy the Good route because it feels repetitive from a storytelling POV for me. So i go bad route to gradually see the MC warm up to her over time.
Now The bad route in general is great because it gets out of the old Mom worship cliche( you know the whole the mom was wronged and hurt/ the dad(usually) is the bad one so you as her son should forgive and forget every single thing she did because she's your Mom). The only other game that treats it the same is Waifu Academy with the MC mom there. Anyway Here we see the mom isn't so good but is actually bad.
Looking at her, she cheated on MC dad, got pregnant, she left when the Dad didn't want to be involved with a child born from her cheating and then practically begged the MC to stay with her years later. Now she's willing to cheat on her Husband who she's been with for years now with her son and if he so happen to not partake in Incest, she shows her true color wow. If you would instantly forgive your mom after all of that or even think that she wouldn't do the same to the MC when someone else pops up then i don't know what to tell you.
Also because i keep seeing it. Nicole asked the MC to come to her house not the other way around as he wasn't going to her house in the first place. He doesn't have to instantly like her just because he said yes. He's there for School and if he manages to fix the problems between him and nicole then it'll happen over time, if not oh well. She's the one pushing for this incest stuff on him out of the blue when he's just trying to enjoy all the girls his age which any normal teen would do realistically.
Me and The MC face at that Nicole scene