Why not just make this a kinetic novel? I tried playing two routes, no relationship route and lesbian route. My first route was no relationship route. My character goes into a relationship with Timothy, the opposite of what I wanted. I get it, it was dumb of me to expect a route like that in a porn game.
So I tried to go for a lesbian route and found myself very disappointed, because it is one of those "lesbian" routes. Mary constantly regrets not getting into sexual situation with a guy, like refusing the old man wanting to take her to the spa or not showing her mothers boyfriend her tits. Mary becomes a cuckold and spotting Ingrid, who you are forced into a relationship with in this route, fucking some guy makes her feel joy because forced open relationship. Lastly, it seems I am going to be forced into a relationship with Timothy again. This feels like there is no lesbian route. Mary will regret her choices and will still possibly end up with Timothy.
The character you play as should reflect the decisions the player made. You shouldn't feel like your getting reprimanded for your decisions. Mary should be glad that she didn't go to a spa with a creepy old man or show her tits to a man fucking her mom. Treat the player character and the player as one entity.
I used the word "forced" a couple or so times for a reason. I feel like I am forced into decisions that I should've been able to make, but was forced into. Relationships, scenarios, and even choices were predetermined for me. like I said about my no relationship route and my "lesbian" route, I'm forced into a relationship with either Ingrid or Timothy. Timothy clearly being a favorite of this dev, considering I'm always ending up with this guy even in my supposed "lesbian" route. I realize in my three playthroughs that some options appear or disappear depending on previous choices. I would be okay with it if the reason for it made sense, but it didn't. for example in my no relationship route where Mary is very shy, what is preventing me from refusing the old man to the spa? In the lesbian route, why did Mary invite Jon to just tease him then get upset that he was looking through her stuff to find tissues after making him cum. I don't want choices taken from me to have a single prompt presented to me. Have the same prompts but have react differently depending on her shyness.