- Apr 24, 2020
- 6,706
- 10,972
Now I have the twisted idea of doing a traditional/historical harem game--but from the perspective of one of the women in the harem, or even a "unique" perspective (i.e. a palace eunuch). Perhaps giving the player a choice of male or female protagonist.I think simplifying the "story-first" criteria in the OP more or less leads to characters behaving believably and a certain level of groundedness to the world.
By groundedness, I mean we are not really considering extremely wacky world building like "only man alive" or some other contrived situation that is only there to enable a fetish.
I've wracked my brain over this, as have others, but it seems like the typical harem that the harem enthusiasts want are fundamentally going to break one or both of those conditions.
Just recently, I've played through 2 well written harem games, but I couldn't really be sure if it will go over well over here.
Seriously, I can see it now. The MC is the daughter of a neighboring warlord, and is given over to the prince as tribute/a peace offering. She is brought in totally ignorant of the rules of the harem, and must be taught. She learns of the pecking order. She sees wives and higher concubines leaving for a night. Perhaps the goal of the game is to rise in the hierarchy and become one of the actual wives....
Perhaps it is a factor of my age. I've never felt the need or desire to fap to any of these games (especially loli/shota). I may get a little excited in a game, but then I'd turn to actual porn to continue.TBH loli/shota games, where the story is actually good/immersive/etc. shouldn't ever be and probably couldn't ever be fap material. It's similar to the incest discussion we had some time ago, where some of us concluded that fetishized incest fulfills a fundamentally different role to incest as a pure plot device.
The only thing creepier than a loli/shota game, is a loli/shota game you're supposed to play with a raised pinky.
Definitely doesn't sound like self-indulgence for me. I'd stay away from such a game.From the very first scene it was clear that the PC has the thickest chad-armor, which gets extended to every single MC really. Unnamed characters can get gruesomely gored and/or raped, though. It's pure self-indulgence.
This!I couldn't disagree more. Because I'm not the MC. I'm the player who gets to experience everything the game has to offer, whether MC is involved in it or not. There is beauty in that, and it's why insisting on self-inserts one can live vicariously through is a very limiting constraint to put on VNs. I'm not saying you should develop all of your NPCs to the level of detail as your LIs, but just because a character isn't attracted to the MC doesn't mean they can't be vital to a story.
One hundred times this!
Some of us live in a country where in at least one state, two under 18 teenagers exchanging racy pics with each other could be charged with distributing cp. If memory serves, one case was that of the girl's parents using their community standing to pressure law enforcement to charge the 14 year old boy.About loli and shota, I think the last few mentions implied a story of an adult getting with and, let's be blunt, fucking someone under 16, and that's clear noncey territory. But what do you feel about two teens under 18 with an age difference of 3 or 4 years? That could also get that tag. In theory an adult woman dressing like a loli could maybe get the loli tag too, not sure how an adult man should dress to qualify as a shota though.
In a few Scandinavian countries, where, like most of Europe, the age of consent is below 18, teens under 18 can have consensual pictures of each other, but it is still illegal to sell such images. By that standard, it may be perfectly fine for too young teens to have relations with each other, but not fine for us to see it.
It used to be legal for them to feature 16 and 17 year old actors, but international agreements changed the legal limit to 18. I expect a big reason Seventeen is trying to rebrand themselves as Sweethearts.
I wonder how much of the US pressure for those agreements was fueled by the Traci Lords fiasco.
The only woman I knew who was into Loli cosplay was 35 years old at the time.