VN Ren'Py STWA: Unbroken [Book 1 Steam] [STWAdev]

[Elduriel]

Look man, I'm not saying you're wrong.
But hear me out here: LET ME HAVE SOME FUCKING HOPE AND GET OUT WITH YOUR LOGIC!

But seriously though, I'm just hoping she will have ending because, other than Els, she's best pick for MC.
Her content is cute (excluding start, where it was just sex), she cares about MC, and they're a good fit.
I'll keep dreaming until the game ends.

EDIT: And yeah, I'm serious about having hope due to her content. Side girls such as side-fucks (ring girl, cookies woman etc.) are obviously just side fuck.
Serena has quite a lot of content that's much deeper than just "quick fuck".

EDIT 2: Dev might also be pulling good old "No points because person doesn't live to see end of game", but that would be a proper terrible thing to happen to her.

fine, I'll keep my thoughts to myself on this topic. I could keep digging holes into your argument but I'll refrain

 

[nitkonikic]

fine, I'll keep my thoughts to myself on this topic. I could keep digging holes into your argument but I'll refrain

Glad to see you agree with me. Knew you'd understand.

Vi and French girl (forgot the damn name) are my least favorite picks for MC.
Amrit also seems like a poor pick, though there's at least some common ground there.

Kana would be nice though.

 

[Elduriel]

Glad to see you agree with me. Knew you'd understand.

oh I disagree hard, don't get me wrong

 

[jadepaladin]

I can't fathom how, in a story with Ines, Els, Kana, Amrit, and Vi, how someone looks at Serena and her lack of screen time, and goes "Yup, I pick this." She spends most of her scenes complaining about the cat or with a cock in some part of her despite the fact she's probably one of the smartest people in the entire cast.

We barely get Serena flexing as a lawyer. Els doesn't suffer stupidity, so she wouldn't be as close to her as she is if Serena wasn't capable of challenging her intellectually. Instead Serena is basically treated like one of the ring girls.

 

[Elduriel]

I can't fathom how, in a story with Ines, Els, Kana, Amrit, and Vi, how someone looks at Serena and her lack of screen time, and goes "Yup, I pick this." She spends most of her scenes complaining about the cat or with a cock in some part of her despite the fact she's probably one of the smartest people in the entire cast.

We barely get Serena flexing as a lawyer. Els doesn't suffer stupidity, so she wouldn't be as close to her as she is if Serena wasn't capable of challenging her intellectually. Instead Serena is basically treated like one of the ring girls.

she is/was thrown in for sex scenes until the MC can bed the main cast (of which only Ines is left, likely happening next update)

 

[nitkonikic]

oh I disagree hard, don't get me wrong

I know, I'm just refusing to acknowledge it, same as Serena argument.
On unrelated note, Serena/Elena (close names wise), both bring me nothing but sadness at how dev skips them

I can't fathom how, in a story with Ines, Els, Kana, Amrit, and Vi, how someone looks at Serena and her lack of screen time, and goes "Yup, I pick this." She spends most of her scenes complaining about the cat or with a cock in some part of her despite the fact she's probably one of the smartest people in the entire cast.

We barely get Serena flexing as a lawyer. Els doesn't suffer stupidity, so she wouldn't be as close to her as she is if Serena wasn't capable of challenging her intellectually. Instead Serena is basically treated like one of the ring girls.

Ines = Too young and immature (fun though)
Vi = Could be attached to MC for wrong reasons, she's terrible pick in my opinion. Hot as all hells though.
Kana = Decent pick for MC, same as MC, she has her own baggage and they'd be good moral help to one another.
Els = Like I mentioned, Serena and Els are my favorites because they'd be great pick for MC. If Serena really is not available for end game, Els takes win by a significant margin. She's amazing for MC and someone who truly understand him.
Amrit = They share their love for MMA, but what else? Oh, don't get me wrong, I love her character and if I was living in that world, I'd go after her, but she's not what MC needs to mentally heal.

I'm not discounting other girls because they're not good looking or such, but rather thinking of how good of a match they're with MC suffering from some severe PTSD. And in that scenario, only Serena and Els are mature enough to stick around.

Vi and Ines are both too young and lacking life experience.
Amrit might be a bit too used to her mentor and wanting him for "wrong" reasons.
Both of those are too young to be saddled with person that needs to heal himself before he can develop healthy long-term relationship.

I haven't played this in like a year + ( I skipped the last update maybe 2 not sure ) waiting for the next one to replay this. But yeah I always thought the side girls were nothing more than sex tools unlike some other games where some of the side girls come across as something in between Main and Side

Author had similar start, to a point. Some girls definitely gave side-girl vibes, but ended up being full LI by the end.
That's kind of why I'm hoping for Serena relationship, dev already did it in previous game.

 

[Dessolos]

I haven't played this in like a year + ( I skipped the last update maybe 2 not sure ) waiting for the next one to replay this. But yeah I always thought the side girls were nothing more than sex tools unlike some other games where some of the side girls come across as something in between Main and Side

 

[jadepaladin]

I know, I'm just refusing to acknowledge it, same as Serena argument.
On unrelated note, Serena/Elena (close names wise), both bring me nothing but sadness at how dev skips them



Ines = Too young and immature (fun though)
Vi = Could be attached to MC for wrong reasons, she's terrible pick in my opinion. Hot as all hells though.
Kana = Decent pick for MC, same as MC, she has her own baggage and they'd be good moral help to one another.
Els = Like I mentioned, Serena and Els are my favorites because they'd be great pick for MC. If Serena really is not available for end game, Els takes win by a significant margin. She's amazing for MC and someone who truly understand him.
Amrit = They share their love for MMA, but what else? Oh, don't get me wrong, I love her character and if I was living in that world, I'd go after her, but she's not what MC needs to mentally heal.

I'm not discounting other girls because they're not good looking or such, but rather thinking of how good of a match they're with MC suffering from some severe PTSD. And in that scenario, only Serena and Els are mature enough to stick around.

Vi and Ines are both too young and lacking life experience.
Amrit might be a bit too used to her mentor and wanting him for "wrong" reasons.
Both of those are too young to be saddled with person that needs to heal himself before he can develop healthy long-term relationship.

Writing off the rest of the cast doesn't change the fact that Serena is a sex doll with less than 1% of the dialogue in the story. If that's what you're into, go for it. There's a major disconnect for me between the potential Serena could have had as a character and how she was actually established and presented.

 

[Maviarab]

I know, I'm just refusing to acknowledge it, same as Serena argument.
On unrelated note, Serena/Elena (close names wise), both bring me nothing but sadness at how dev skips them



Ines = Too young and immature (fun though)
Vi = Could be attached to MC for wrong reasons, she's terrible pick in my opinion. Hot as all hells though.
Kana = Decent pick for MC, same as MC, she has her own baggage and they'd be good moral help to one another.
Els = Like I mentioned, Serena and Els are my favorites because they'd be great pick for MC. If Serena really is not available for end game, Els takes win by a significant margin. She's amazing for MC and someone who truly understand him.
Amrit = They share their love for MMA, but what else? Oh, don't get me wrong, I love her character and if I was living in that world, I'd go after her, but she's not what MC needs to mentally heal.

I'm not discounting other girls because they're not good looking or such, but rather thinking of how good of a match they're with MC suffering from some severe PTSD. And in that scenario, only Serena and Els are mature enough to stick around.

Vi and Ines are both too young and lacking life experience.
Amrit might be a bit too used to her mentor and wanting him for "wrong" reasons.
Both of those are too young to be saddled with person that needs to heal himself before he can develop healthy long-term relationship.



Author had similar start, to a point. Some girls definitely gave side-girl vibes, but ended up being full LI by the end.
That's kind of why I'm hoping for Serena relationship, dev already did it in previous game.

You write an awful lot of drivel to just say I'm a red head simp.

 

[nitkonikic]

Writing off the rest of the cast doesn't change the fact that Serena is a sex doll with less than 1% of the dialogue in the story. If that's what you're into, go for it. There's a major disconnect for me between the potential Serena could have had as a character and how she was actually established and presented.

That's fair, and that's approach I understand.
But it's exactly that potential that I value in her. I see her as potentially great LI, if she had more time.

For other girls, like I said, I don't see them as good match for MC and that's it.
I'm running saves (or did, before game got Steam release and now need to re-do all of them) for all girls, so I'll see all content, but they're just not doing it for me relationship wise.

 

[Dessolos]

Author had similar start, to a point. Some girls definitely gave side-girl vibes, but ended up being full LI by the end.
That's kind of why I'm hoping for Serena relationship, dev already did it in previous game.

ah didn't know that I can barley remember that AVN as I didn't like it at all. I had to force myself to finish it. I remember feeling that I wish even the main girls had more to them I barley felt like I had enough time to even really get to know most of the main girls well enough. I think there was only 1 or 2 I thought had enough deveolopment but none of those were my favorites.

This game however is a major improvement compared to the Author.

 

[Dr.TSoni]

She's amazing for MC and someone who truly understand him.

The legal system calls this "understanding" stalking XD

You write an awful lot of drivel to just say I'm a red head simp.

 

[jadepaladin]

ah didn't know that I can barley remember that AVN as I didn't like it at all. I had to force myself to finish it. I remember feeling that I wish even the main girls had more to them I barley felt like I had enough time to even really get to know most of the main girls well enough. I think there was only 1 or 2 I thought had enough deveolopment but none of those were my favorites.

This game however is a major improvement compared to the Author.

Author didn't even have side girls that I can remember. It was all main girls and you could fuck around with most, if not, all of them until the end, where you just picked an ending, everyone got over it, and you sailed off into the sunset with whoever (or the throuple). The only real limitations were how some scenes were exclusive choices, and doing things that Aoife, Beatrix, and Lyndie liked tended to be things that hurt you with Chris and Kim. Aoife probably got the biggest arc, and Kim the wildest twist.
Everyone else was pretty standard.

Still, dev had to start somewhere and I'd put Author up against a lot of other VNs.

 

[nitkonikic]

You write an awful lot of drivel to just say I'm a red head simp.

No I'm not, as certain redhead from VN in my signature can attest. (name starts with K, but let's avoid OT)
But I do absolutely simp for Serena, guilty there.

 

[Dessolos]

Author didn't even have side girls that I can remember. It was all main girls and you could fuck around with most, if not, all of them until the end, where you just picked an ending, everyone got over it, and you sailed off into the sunset with whoever (or the throuple). The only real limitations were how some scenes were exclusive choices, and doing things that Aoife, Beatrix, and Lyndie liked tended to be things that hurt you with Chris and Kim. Aoife probably got the biggest arc, and Kim the wildest twist.
Everyone else was pretty standard.

Still, dev had to start somewhere and I'd put Author up against a lot of other VNs.

I should probably replay someday to see if I can get into it. As I really only liked Aoife and 1 other forget who. But I always felt I was wanting more deveolopment but I wonder now if that was because I wasn't enjoying the game I missed some things. Cause I know a few times I did play it was pretty tired struggling to even stay awake.

 

[jadepaladin]

I should probably replay someday to see if I can get into it. As I really only liked Aoife and 1 other forget who. But I always felt I was wanting more deveolopment but I wonder now if that was because I wasn't enjoying the game I missed some things. Cause I know a few times I did play it was pretty tired struggling to even stay awake.

I imagine if you liked Aoife the other one was Lyndie since that was the possible throuple. That said, if you say Kim, I'm gonna tell Ethan to go all in on Erynn and make you watch.

Back to Unbroken though, it's structured differently to Author so it's hard to even compare the two.

 

[nitkonikic]

I should probably replay someday to see if I can get into it. As I really only liked Aoife and 1 other forget who. But I always felt I was wanting more deveolopment but I wonder now if that was because I wasn't enjoying the game I missed some things. Cause I know a few times I did play it was pretty tired struggling to even stay awake.

If I could suggest, do the Kim route, as Jade says, that one has ... fun development.
Beatrix was kind of harder to get if I remember correctly, since it clashed with Lyndie/Aoife.
Need to replay it myself at some point.

Do find it surprising you didn't enjoy Author, it was reason why I supported this dev for a while, absolutely loved it.
Discussing devs earlier game is not OT, right? Just checking

That said, if you say Kim, I'm gonna tell Ethan to go all in on Erynn and make you watch.

I see that, same as Dessolos, you're going on my "Never agrees with on woman" list. Good to know.

 

[jadepaladin]

If I could suggest, do the Kim route, as Jade says, that one has ... fun development.
Beatrix was kind of harder to get if I remember correctly, since it clashed with Lyndie/Aoife.
Need to replay it myself at some point.

Do find it surprising you didn't enjoy Author, it was reason why I supported this dev for a while, absolutely loved it.
Discussing devs earlier game is not OT, right? Just checking



I see that, same as Dessolos, you're going on my "Never agrees with on woman" list. Good to know.

I actually like the whole cast in Author. Kim can't be his pick because that twist is memorable and he doesn't remember. As for it being OT, I have no idea. I can't explain the mods.

I do think the writing improved between Author and Unbroken but that's to be expected. I'd be interested to see how a Kim like twist would get handled given the dev's current level of experience.

 

[Dessolos]

I imagine if you liked Aoife the other one was Lyndie since that was the possible throuple. That said, if you say Kim, I'm gonna tell Ethan to go all in on Erynn and make you watch.

Back to Unbroken though, it's structured differently to Author so it's hard to even compare the two.

just looked it up thanks to MiltonPowers thread it was Dru who was my 2nd favorite because of her eyes if I recall and im sure a few other reason been to long to remember why now. Funny enough in this game I ended up liking Kana as my 2nd favorite because she somewhat reminded me of Dru not because their characters are similar. But her eyes reminded me of her because how beautiful and pretty they were. ( This was when I used to care about looks of a LI when I was new to AVN's.)

 

[MagicMan753]

Not to give false hope, but if you played The Author (same dev), all girls had ending option in it. So there's still some small hope for us Serena fans. Why else would she have content that clashes with other girls?
(Just let me dream, ok...)

Yeah, I feel like she will probably get an ending too. It may not be as deep or as long as the main girls, but I think she will get one at least.

I do wish she was a MG though, cause 1 more wouldn't have hurt and she would of been my number 3 probably, behind Els and Vi if she was.

But at least my dream throuple is likely with my top 2, so that is what I am looking forward to, their threesome will be legendary.