Things go badly, you have left your partner behind, traveled a long way, discover you've been lied to, found out you aren't getting paid, so you turn to your partner of 5 years for advice and that is clingy? Interesting.The MC does seem to have an annoying tendency to call Nicole to cry on her shoulder every time he hits a bump in the road. She seems very used to handling his whining. To me he definitely comes across as clingy in all of the unscheduled calls and it is the thing I most dislike about his behavior.
In contrast, Nicole seems to avoid telling him about her issues. She will talk with her sister about relationship doubts but rather than discussing with the MC she jumps into the open relationship and here are my rules speech.
The MC is a jerk for missing the nightly calls (can't remember how many) especially after repeatedly bothering her at work. She probably should be having doubts about the relationship given what she knows. He didn't even bother to call her the first night!
As for Nicole not telling him about her issues, he never asks. Everything is about him. He never calls to see how she is. The times he does call are right when she is at work too so she doesn't have time for long calls. Maybe if he bothered to stay in touch she wouldn't even have suggested an open relationship. Remember the scene where he can fantasies about a girl. You get a long list of girls to choose from. Who isn't on the list? You are right, he is a jerk. So, explain again, how he is clingy when he is pretty much ignoring her.
Jeff's idea that was shut down was the cuckqueen idea. The open relationship is actually in the game right now, so obviously wasn't shut down. It is only due to feedback that they are changing course.Well the only thing I know is that the open relation thing was a proposal of Jeff that was already shot down before this update was released. So it was always the break up option that would come, they might agree more with you they thought an immediate breakup at call was bit cold. The story was never about staying with Nicole though I suspect but always about breaking up with Nicole, remember devs are making a sex game from the very start around the MC with as main dame in game the Sis and another 6-10 LI's around that are all as important and need as much time as Nicole and possibly a loyal path, while MC is far away from Nicole. The story and game was never about Nicole as such. She was just used as an early blocker of affairs, a role Brody has as well and rest of her importance as a LI is the same of all other various LI's opportunities MC will have with likely exception of Sis.
"The story was never about staying with Nicole though"
Unless you are on the dev team, you don't know that. The fact there is a path to stay faithful would tend to disagree though. That path will still be active in v4.
"remember devs are making a sex game from the very start around the MC with as main dame in game the Sis and another 6-10 LI's around"
True. However, just like in Melody and DMD, you can stay faithful to one girl. The sister might indeed be the main "dame" as you put it, but they put in a route to stay with Nicole.
"while MC is far away from Nicole"
He is far away, for now. We don't know what developments could arise. For all we know she will be coming down to Sunshine Bay to work on a case. Maybe her divorce client is from SB and came to her company because of its reputation. Or, we know the MCs old boss is going to be trying to take over the hotel, right? Maybe they need legal advice from someone who is not currently jobless and Nicole is the one they call. These are just ideas. They probably won't happen. But, they could.
"The story and game was never about Nicole as such."
Again, you don't know that. You are making assumptions.