Finally got to playing this and really enjoyed it. Sophia's my top choice right now but there are others in the running. Vanessa could be fun but she could also be frustrating, I see her more as a fun diversion than a serious love interest (for now.) I liked the outcome of the game we played with her (I won the final round with the phone texts and got her to send me a picture.) I'm interested in Jennifer. And possibly Nina. And Emma. The only one I don't find myself much attracted to is Rebecca. I know I'll have to choose. Right now I'm going with Sophia, but I plan to return to old saves and explore the others, or maybe switch later (it was hinted this will be allowed.)
The stupid prank they played on the MC - I think he did overreact a little by refusing to talk to them for so long, but taking into account how Dave spoke to him when he first objected to what they'd done, he wasn't completely in the wrong. They could all have apologised. Instead, Dave insulted him for daring to think what they'd done was stupid and call them on it. Dave's exact words: "Stop being such a fucking over-sensitive prick, man." And then when the MC storms off Dave says "Good riddance." That's not how friends behave. Tease and joke, fine. But if a so-called friend treated me that way and refused to apologise, it's unlikely we'd remain friends. For the sake of Jennifer and Rebecca, who seemed like they might actually be sorry, I could tolerate him. But we would not be friends unless he owned up to being an asshole and apologised. He further shows himself to be a fairly typical asshole with the basketball scene. Right now, I don't like him. I'm neutral on Nathan.
I don't agree with the couple of people who've said it seemed too fast with Sophia. They've been hanging out getting to know each other for over a month (they met on, I think, on Sept 12, and had sex on Oct 19th, which is about 5 1/2 weeks) and very obviously felt something from early on. Is that short? Yes. Is it unreasonably short? No. Don't get stuck on the first date thing -even though that was their first official date, they were friends with a definite physical and emotional attraction before that night.
Seconding the recommendation for some rough sex with Vanessa. Seems like the kind of girl who'd be into it.