CREATE YOUR AI CUM SLUT ON CANDY.AI TRY FOR FREE
x

Agul

Member
Jun 19, 2017
336
1,539
Well, while English does not distinguish between inclusive and exclusive "we", a sentence with "we" where people apart from the author are not known or introduced is generally understood to mean "everybody". That may be semantics but it is how the language works. And I don't see where I am backpedalling here. Yes, I did not like what you said but here it wasn't the content but the way you said it. If you'd've said "I want X" I wouldn't have commented on this. But I really dislike this way of trying to sound impactful when you are just stating your personal opinion which obviously is not shared by everybody. .
You're making the assumption, there's absolutely no reason to come to this conclusion. There are plenty of people agreeing with you and plenty agreeing with me, so why be pedantic? If I qualified the use of "we" as though I'd said, "we, every last person in this thread", I could understand - but you're literally arguing over nothing with no basis in the use of English language. I invite now as the time for you to provide evidence from a recognized authority on English to prove what you're saying. You can't. Please don't lecture people on a language you don't understand.

You "dislike the way of trying to sound impactful"? Aren't you familiar with the ways language is used to express ideas? I don't understand why this would upset you so much.

And whether that creates an engaging narrative, well, it can be argued that that is precisely what he is going for - and as much as I like the fucky-fucky part of games, that does not create a narrative at all. And if you do not like this way of doing an AVN that is of course perfectly fine, but when somebody tell you "I will do things this way" complaining later that they do exactly that is a bit off. And "supplying people with quality spank material" wasn't the main intention, at least not in the way you seem to use it. So we can discuss how good this update (or the game in general) is, but trying to judge it on something it doesn't want to be is just a moot point in a discussion, and discussions also include that others will point out you making a moot point.
I never said or implied "fucky-fucky" creates a narrative. It's a porn game, so to some extent the sexual content and narrative must intertwine. In my opinion (if that wasn't clear enough), and I can express my opinion as can anyone else in this DISCUSSION thread: the wheels are coming off and this story is racing into boredom and irrelevance because it doesn't reconcile fucking with story. Fucking is part of the story. I don't have Hopes' words written on the inside of my eyelids so I don't know what he said and I don't care. I can complain all I like and so can anybody else, nothing about that is moot because this is the exact place for that kind of dialogue. If you want to worship devs and not have reasonable discussions, Discord is the place for you, not this pirate forum. Since you're just going to assume what I think and start talking about implications that don't exist, why don't you tell me why porn is in this narrative-focused game at all? Because now you're talking like the game isn't meant to be titillating and that makes no sense whatsoever. Don't you understand that pay-off for characters in the game is about having a narrative that makes sense of the sex scenes? Not just going on and on forever? Who apart from you is calling that a moot point? In fact, there seems to be enough people concerned about it if you'd just read the thread.
 

kcaldw

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2021
1,629
3,831
Oh hell's no! I know that someone just did not shoot our beloved Gracie. Someone is in deep deep :poop: now. WTF were they thinking. Now all hell is going to come down on everyone involved in that messed up :poop:. Can't wait for season 2.
 

Cartageno

Devoted Member
Dec 1, 2019
8,766
14,877
You're making the assumption, there's absolutely no reason to come to this conclusion. There are plenty of people agreeing with you and plenty agreeing with me, so why be pedantic? If I qualified the use of "we" as though I'd said, "we, every last person in this thread", I could understand - but you're literally arguing over nothing with no basis in the use of English language. I invite now as the time for you to provide evidence from a recognized authority on English to prove what you're saying. You can't. Please don't lecture people on a language you don't understand.

You "dislike the way of trying to sound impactful"? Aren't you familiar with the ways language is used to express ideas? I don't understand why this would upset you so much.
to be enough people concerned about it if you'd just read the thread.
Oh, I am not upset. I may be pedantic - gotta admit that - but not upset as such.

Any pronoun needs something to refer to somebody/a group of people by definition, that is why it is a pronoun. "He is hungry" is useless if you don't know who "he" is. Same with "we". There is no "I and some others" unless you specify it. If you use it without context it falls back to default which here is everybody who could be in it, i. e. all.

I never said or implied "fucky-fucky" creates a narrative. It's a porn game
I am gonna stop you right there because it has been said multiple times that it isn't. It is an adult game. Which means it contains porn but it isn't about porn as the main driving factor.

In my opinion (if that wasn't clear enough), and I can express my opinion as can anyone else in this DISCUSSION thread: the wheels are coming off and this story is racing into boredom and irrelevance because it doesn't reconcile fucking with story.
Firstly, this includes my opinion as well as yours, so I am just as much allowed to voice it as you are. Secondly, your opinion that the game is boring is perfectly fine, as already said, but you are judging the game on some metrics it does not want to meet. Sure, you can consider the music of Beyoncé boring because it is just generic pop without impact, and I would be with you all the way, however, she isn't going for the music we like, so we would only be allowed to judge actual quality aspects. We can say we consider it boring but it would be pointless because what we want is not what she is going for.

I can complain all I like and so can anybody else, nothing about that is moot because this is the exact place for that kind of dialogue. If you want to worship devs and not have reasonable discussions, Discord is the place for you, not this pirate forum.
Again, you are complaining that you do not like the cake because you wanted a steak. Which would be perfectly reasonable if you had been promised a steak but you haven't. If you don't want to have the promises on the inside of your eyelids, I am happy to remind you.

why don't you tell me why porn is in this narrative-focused game at all? Because now you're talking like the game isn't meant to be titillating and that makes no sense whatsoever. Don't you understand that pay-off for characters in the game is about having a narrative that makes sense of the sex scenes? Not just going on and on forever? Who apart from you is calling that a moot point? In fact, there seems to be enough people concerned about it if you'd just read the thread.
Why is porn in a narrative focused game at all? Because why not? There is no reason to only have one or the other. And there is no reason, if you want to have one of them in it to go to any extreme.

And yes, the game is titillating, however not everybody has the same preferences as you and preferences in terms of speed of development (I mean of the stories, not of updates here) and wants for background on a character before going into action differ. I would guess even within the same person, depending on how much they get involved with the storyline and how they feel on a certain day.

And while I will not disagree with "pay-off for characters in the game is about having a narrative that makes sense of the sex scenes", I will disagree with the order of what you say - not every story is "narrative so the sex makes sense but we're here for the sex", there is "sex is a part of the narrative, since it comes to it". But yes, I do want those scenes to happen in the end. But stuff can be easily the conclusion to a story without it being the main focus.

As to "who apart from me is calling" and so forth: I will not claim to be able to speak for others but from this thread I very much gather that most of the regulars are happy with the way the story develops (if not with the release schedule). I mean, that's why they're regulars. Would JJJ84 ask as many questions about characters' backgrounds if he was only here for the fap? Would whichone take stances as he does? How about Abhai or Ayhsel or c3p0?

Of course they might disagree. Or even if they agree we might be the victims of group think. But there are enough people who chose this very game and follow it because they are happy with how it is done. And, to repeat a point, how it is intended to be done.
 

Ayhsel

Chocolate Vampire
Donor
May 9, 2019
4,896
16,273
How about @Abhai or @Ayhsel or @c3p0?
I have been summoned, my future subjects!! Please... no applauds.. ok.. some applauds!:lepew:
I've enjoyed the story elements of this game, that's not really the point I'm trying to make. I'm saying you can go too far in one direction to the extent that your plot becomes really fuzzy at the expense of bringing some satisfaction to your audience. That might be fine in the dev's opinion and that of his loyal donators, by all means - it's his story, but acting as though there isn't some merit to the idea that most people playing this game will lose interest is a clear indicator of bias.
This is actually wrong and in fact you are doing precisely what you accused Cartageno of doing: assume stuff. There is technically nothing to say Hopes is trying to satisfy his audience. If anything, and going by what he did in game, you have an scene criticizing this kind of behavior with Caenis.
Nothing about "we want" implies *everyone*, it just implies there's more than one person.
Well, while English does not distinguish between inclusive and exclusive "we", a sentence with "we" where people apart from the author are not known or introduced is generally understood to mean "everybody". That may be semantics but it is how the language works.
This statement is true. Claiming we does not imply all. Cartageno simply assumed you were claiming "all". While understandable given context*, this is still his bad.

*I personally believe that you used we instead of I there not because you are trying to be a voice for other people, but because you wanted to make your case stronger by claiming there is another people thinking like you. This is, however, my assumption. Untested, as such it can be wrong.

In fact, if you were using the Royal We, We can still mean one person. I should start using the royal we, practicing for the future.

I don't care if that's what Hopes said, I'm saying if his intention is what you say it is, it's not helping him to create an engaging narrative nor supply people with quality spank material. That's just how discussion works.
You are assuming again he wants to create quality spank material. This statement was proven false by Hopes himself. So you are saying it is not helping doing something he does not want to do. Where is the problem?

"supplying people with quality spank material" wasn't the main intention, at least not in the way you seem to use it. So we can discuss how good this update (or the game in general) is, but trying to judge it on something it doesn't want to be is just a moot point in a discussion, and discussions also include that others will point out you making a moot point.
This is the point. In red and bold: "trying to judge it on something it doesn't want to be is just a moot point in a discussion" otherwise, we might as well criticize this game for being a terrible children's game. Clearly does not make sense.
It's a porn game, so to some extent the sexual content and narrative must intertwine.
This has been systematically proven wrong. It is not porn. It is erotica. Porn is all about the titillations, erotica includes sexual content but it is not the only aspect of the art at hand.
I can complain all I like and so can anybody else
Indeed you can. People can also complain about your complains and people can complain about people's complain about your complains and it follows ad infinitum.
Since you're just going to assume what I think and start talking about implications that don't exist, why don't you tell me why porn is in this narrative-focused game at all? Because now you're talking like the game isn't meant to be titillating and that makes no sense whatsoever. Don't you understand that pay-off for characters in the game is about having a narrative that makes sense of the sex scenes? Not just going on and on forever? Who apart from you is calling that a moot point? In fact, there seems to be enough people concerned about it if you'd just read the thread.
You are confusing sex with porn. Sex is the act, porn is type of art that specifically looks at representations of sex for stimulations' sake.
Stop assuming this is porn and your request are all irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
4.40 star(s) 508 Votes