Quetzzz
Active Member
- Sep 29, 2023
- 926
- 1,433
- 267
Honestly, the best place any LI can hope to achieve is 3rd.
Raziel_8
Forum Fanatic
- Dec 4, 2017
- 4,802
- 12,615
- 719
True, behind Emily and Madelyn. And then there is Lilly, so maybe some time soon, Hailey can only reach 4th place.
The other 2 aren't even the race
Im really really really a lisa guy but even i agree lol
Madelyn so won me over in just two conversations already.
You had to snuggle with Hailey while still looking at Emily's boobs earlier in the game to even see that scene. So, who's the bad guy here?After her egregious sock theft last chapter her second best girl status in under review.
SlowGoesSlow
Member
- Jan 5, 2024
- 473
- 1,551
- 229
Your honor my client was under extreme emotional strain, thus their actions were compromised and he was clearly not in his right state of mind.You had to snuggle with Hailey while still looking at Emily's boobs earlier in the game to even see that scene. So, who's the bad guy here?
- Jul 26, 2023
- 18,058
- 45,719
- 922
Everyone else is fighting for second place.True, behind Emily and Madelyn. And then there is Lilly, so maybe some time soon, Hailey can only reach 4th place.
The other 2 aren't even the race
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
TheNowhereWolf
Active Member
- Sep 24, 2018
- 520
- 805
- 171
I'm all in on Lisa honestly but as weird as I feel about Madelyn she does seem like a good choice. Our boy Jp making things difficult In a VN I was sure my main girl was set.
I still feel like Madelyn is off limits. Maybe that will change. I just think it isn't a healthy path for anyone involved.
Honestly she seems like TOO GOOD of a choice even more with Ben's words ringing in the back in the mind.
IF she becomes a LI she will immediatly take the top1 spot for me but i would fully understand not making her a LI too (but in that case she needs to be a LI in the second game!!!
).Like honestly, everything is TOO perfect with her, the chemistry and everything is just too good and it makes you wonder if the MC and therefore the viewer isnt wearing tainted glasses when looking at her.
All the other LI's seem to have at least some kind of baggage and their own partially dark life experiences (which imo makes them great and realistic) and than comes Madelyn along, floating like a fairytale princess, being so easygoing, careing, beautiful, simply perfect yet longing for connection and family (like ella).
It just feels too good, too easy lol
Its kinda displayed in the MC's behavior too, he needs time to warm up to the other (awesome) LI's, keeps them at arms lengths at times and to a certain degree keeps up the charade of a charming, happy guy.
While there is none of that with Madelyn, it feels like its the only time we see him being really himself without any barriers or playing and roles. It feels even like a step up compared to Ben and Vicky if we look at his behavior and openness.
I will hate jPk so much if he lets madelyn die too now
Dessolos
Board Buff
- Jul 25, 2017
- 19,656
- 27,681
- 936
I haven't gotten notifications from this thread for a minute and I see some handholding and I don't have this one in my handholding folder and yes I have a folder.
TheNowhereWolf
Active Member
- Sep 24, 2018
- 520
- 805
- 171
I agree, I feel duped though when El didn't stick around because I felt a whole VN was skipped, Madelyn could be too good to be true which Is why I'm sticking with Lisa until It's done so I know If there's a real path for Madelyn. I really like Lisa though and I love MC and her niece's interactions, some sad shit coming with Lisa and kids though.Honestly she seems like TOO GOOD of a choice even more with Ben's words ringing in the back in the mind.
IF she becomes a LI she will immediatly take the top1 spot for me but i would fully understand not making her a LI too (but in that case she needs to be a LI in the second game!!!
Like honestly, everything is TOO perfect with her, the chemistry and everything is just too good and it makes you wonder if the MC and therefore the viewer isnt wearing tainted glasses when looking at her.
All the other LI's seem to have at least some kind of baggage and their own partially dark life experiences (which imo makes them great and realistic) and than comes Madelyn along, floating like a fairytale princess, being so easygoing, careing, beautiful, simply perfect yet longing for connection and family (like ella).
It just feels too good, too easy lol
Its kinda displayed in the MC's behavior too, he needs time to warm up to the other (awesome) LI's, keeps them at arms lengths at times and to a certain degree keeps up the charade of a charming, happy guy.
While there is none of that with Madelyn, it feels like its the only time we see him being really himself without any barriers or playing and roles. It feels even like a step up compared to Ben and Vicky if we look at his behavior and openness.
I will hate jPk so much if he lets madelyn die too now
It seems maybe Madelyn Is the easy path but not the healthy one.
TheNowhereWolf
Active Member
- Sep 24, 2018
- 520
- 805
- 171
JillybeanEnjoyer
Well-Known Member
- Feb 19, 2021
- 1,391
- 3,468
- 349
- Jul 26, 2023
- 18,058
- 45,719
- 922
- Jul 26, 2023
- 18,058
- 45,719
- 922
TheNowhereWolf
Active Member
- Sep 24, 2018
- 520
- 805
- 171
I missed this... saw Milton's above It but hiding those thighs behind a spoiler, damn dude.
CrazyRabbit
Engaged Member
- Oct 30, 2019
- 2,278
- 10,959
- 697
Hah well yeah otherwise its what makes the avn really unqiue and special. And it seems like we will maybe get quite a few ella flashbacks via telling madelyn stories about the past. Usually im not the biggest fan of flashbacks but im sure they will be interesting if they happen here.
Lisa seems to be unable to give birth, she says "unfortunately, that will never happen" and i doubt its a random circumstance that the mc mentions that he cant imagine having kids himself (again) just on her path.
Which by the way would be a valid reason to not have a madelny path, if the MC really cant imagine having a child again ...
Madelyn craves family and is a young girl, the MC wouldnt be the right partner for her in that case, theres no way you could convince me that this girl which longs for family doesnt want her own kids at some point. We will see i guess.
And yeah, i really enjoy the Lisa-path too, shes the LI who feels the most equal with the MC imo in terms of life experience, standing and worldview and i like that she - like the MC - kinda integrated a little part of Ella's worldview into her own which makes the combination a bit symbolic in a nice way.
RNasc4444
Well-Known Member
- Aug 16, 2022
- 1,847
- 7,541
- 637
Fully agree. My MC would NEVER! That's just a level of creepy I'm not comfortable with no matter how many spirits push the MC towards it. Not gonna happen in my playthrough.