VN Ren'Py The Neverwhere Tales [v0.4.0] [Ceolag]

4.40 star(s) 38 Votes

Dark Silence

Devoted Member
Jul 17, 2021
8,351
12,601
We can agree to disagree (y). I have no problem with that. I'm happy we are talking about other aspects of the game and not just Kaija. That was my hope anyway, to stir some conversation.


Now you're talking!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hospitallers, Knights of Malta, I reckon bring them all back. :LOL:
If we do, we need the Furusiyya added in also. As I said above.
 
Oct 10, 2022
4,349
7,727
We do. Then we can also bring in the Djinns as a secondary to the infernals. :ROFLMAO:
If we do, we need the Furusiyya added in also. As I said above.
This is why I love this thread, I had no idea what is Furussiya or Djinn(except Witcher version) and learned something cool.

Go down on Kaija!

Shit...no...down with Kaija!
I second this.:giggle:

Nah, they are just as missguided and corrupted than the templars...
They are, that's the beauty of it. Let them fight each other we may get rid of both sides.

We can agree to disagree (y). I have no problem with that. I'm happy we are talking about other aspects of the game and not just Kaija. That was my hope anyway, to stir some conversation.
I need a few more updates then all I will do be that. :LOL:

Now you're talking!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hospitallers, Knights of Malta, I reckon bring them all back. :LOL:
Now we are talking. :LOL:
 
Oct 10, 2022
4,349
7,727
Well they are just a few hundred, they simply don't have the numbers to play secret police on the entire world, fight criminal syndicates, protect innocents and deal with Neverwhere on top of it (assuming they ever tried to get rid of the criminal elements).
Then they should stop giving speeches about being protector of humanity, should not they? Not caring and not being able to do, completely two different things anyway. They simply don't care about those people, they see them as collateral damage, remember how Kaija acts when MC wanted to help that guy at the Neverwhere. She simply didn't care. It is safe to assume they never tried to fight against criminals. Also this does support my point, they don't serve any meaningful purpose except protecting the vile ways of Neverwhere.

To me he seems like a meathead which is completely 'templars first', basically a older, male version of Kaija.
If he is a traitor, then yes, he's at best a puppet. But i can just as well imagine he's just heavy indoctrinated/convinced of the templars (and can easily be used/mislead, if you understand how he works).
All which benefit them is good, even if there is some fallout, the end justifies the means ect.
I think he is neither a meathead nor a moron. He seems to me clever enough to play the politics within Templars. Though I think he sees himself better than he actually is and whoever the third party is using him. So I believe either willingly or not he is a traitor. For the other leaders I don't think Linnae is one, even though she does not like Neverwhere she is loyal to the fault to Templars. I think other woman is not a candidate either, she seemed a person without hidden agenda. Though we have very little interaction with her to make an opinion on her. The other guy seemed suspicious also, he may be another traitor. Maybe he was the third party, using Jason Statham even without his knowledge. We really need more information about it.

 

Grumpy Old Aussie

Engaged Member
May 6, 2023
2,042
4,147
Then they should stop giving speeches about being protector of humanity, should not they? Not caring and not being able to do, completely two different things anyway. They simply don't care about those people, they see them as collateral damage, remember how Kaija acts when MC wanted to help that guy at the Neverwhere. She simply didn't care. It is safe to assume they never tried to fight against criminals. Also this does support my point, they don't serve any meaningful purpose except protecting the vile ways of Neverwhere.
They should but they believe they are what they say they are. Even though we can see them for what they have become. As you have said, cult mindset. They have "special knowledge", "only they know 'the real truth' so they are above everyone else", and so on. Its all very seductive and tragic. Hence why I don't hate them, its just sad to see what they have become from what the Templars use to be.

I think he is neither a meathead nor a moron. He seems to me clever enough to play the politics within Templars. Though I think he sees himself better than he actually is and whoever the third party is using him. So I believe either willingly or not he is a traitor. For the other leaders I don't think Linnae is one, even though she does not like Neverwhere she is loyal to the fault to Templars. I think other woman is not a candidate either, she seemed a person without hidden agenda. Though we have very little interaction with her to make an opinion on her. The other guy seemed suspicious also, he may be another traitor. Maybe he was the third party, using Jason Statham even without his knowledge. We really need more information about it.
Perhaps its Kaija (just joking, I couldn't resist). It could be none of the Templar Council are involved and a third party has just taken advantage of their corruption. I think Fiona's family will have a role in there somewhere. Although unleashing demons on the world doesn't seem like a very sane thing to do or very beneficial to anyone. It will be interesting to see how things evolve.
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,208
13,378
Could Linnae be the mastermind behind the demons? She is a step ahead of the rest of the Templars. Linnae is willing to act independently to achieve her goals. When she is booted from the council, she isn't fazed at all. She has taken a particular interest in the MC. Thoughts?
Could she be? Sure. Is she? I have no idea. With the scant information we have it's impossible to rule anyone out as the mastermind behind the demons. We've barely met two of the major players in a setting that presumably has a large number of players in it (since one of the few things we know about Neverwhere is that it connects to more than nine worlds). We can't even tell if said mastermind was working for the demons (trying to eliminate a dangerous mage) or against them (trying to get Durandal into the hands of the MC). So it's all guesswork.

If I had to guess, though, I'd say no. Linnae's situation seems like an adequate explanation for her actions so far. Yes, she's been more sympathetic to the MC than the others, but that wouldn't be surprising if she was a friend of the MC's parents. (And frankly it's not like her respect for the MC is uncommon among the other Templars we've seen, either.) Likewise it's easy to see how being booted from the Council doesn't faze her: from what we've seen the Council is a thankless waste of time. No one can agree on anything and they were apparently reliant on the MC's dad to provide any leadership. Now that he's back, who wouldn't want to be rid of the whole thing?

I think we'll have to see how Linnae takes to life after the Council before we should get suspicious. If she's still keeping a close eye on Templar/elf politics or tries to get the MC to support her own agenda, that would be the mark of someone who should have hated walking away from the Council. If she's happy to run errands and train recruits, it's more likely she's on the up and up. That's my $0.02, anyway.


I stand corrected. Moron wasn't the right word but I don't think he is a mastermind behind things.
Eh, moron seems like exactly the right word for William. I'm willing to be sympathetic to the ruthlessly pragmatic approach, especially since William seems to lead whatever passes for the Templar's military, but his proposal is ridiculous. He wants an all out attack on the elves (the same elves whose queen scares him shitless even on neutral ground!) to rescue a prisoner (whose location he doesn't know), all on the grounds that if they fail it's no worse than disbanding the Templars - an option everyone already rejected as unacceptable. I mean... wow.

That's a level of incompetence even Arnold J. Rimmer couldn't sink to: his "daylight charge across the minefield" might have had a horrific body count, but it was still a successful feint for the real plan. William, apparently, wants to get everyone killed ASAP because he's convinced Templar leadership is so incompetent that it's only a matter of time before they blunder into accepting the elves' ultimatum. :rolleyes:


The reality in Neverwhere's world is the Templars are the gateway between the human world and everywhere else. So they need to exist because some of those other realms would rain untold havoc on the human world without the balance the Templars keep. The Templars need to exist. So our mistreated hero needs to make a decision. Either the Templars need to have a reformation or a new entity put in their place. Which way should the narrative go?

Personally, I think a reformation is in order. No matter what organisation controls the gateways to Neverwhere, they will be filled with humans. Humans have a bad habit of messing stuff up especially over long periods of time no matter how good their intentions are. So I don't think disbanding them serves any purpose in the long run. Its much easier to reform them.
The Templars as shield to humanity is the party line, but even with our limited information we already know it's at best partially true. The Templars only control a portion of the connections between Earth and Neverwhere, and we know they can't even monitor others a short distance away. We're also told that people of public interest "paint a huge target on [their] back" if they make obvious use of Neverwhere as a means of transportation, so clearly there are one or more forces besides the Templars who also act as gatewardens for Earth. Whatever protection the Templars provide is either limited in scope or very selective.

That doesn't mean they aren't providing some sort of protection or that there services mustn't be valuable, but we currently lack the details to evaluate how - or even if - the Templars should be reformed. Hopefully now that the MC's father is safe we can finally start digging for some solid answers before we let the elves bombard us with their own propaganda.


Elves offer was disassembling Templars and closing the gates to Neverwhere. Which means closing the gates is possible. Also as Linnae said that place is wretched place and as far as we have introduced it has no real benefits to humanity except people do illegal stuff, so shutting it down has no downside to it. As far as I understood, Templars are just guard dogs for rich wrecthed people. They don't even protect people get killed by those people just because they talked about it.
So if we ever given an option, I hope we will have it, I am gonna choose the demise of Templars. You can't reform something as corrupted as Templars, if you really want to make it right you need to topple it down and rebuild something else in its place.
The elves demanded the Templars close their own connections to Neverwhere. There's nothing to indicate closing ALL connections was possible, or even that the elves would want that.

Also, it's important to note that, at least from what Kaija said, it's someone else who kills the people that talk about Neverwhere; the Templars just know how to keep a low enough profile to avoid getting killed themselves. While I'd take anything Kaija says with a hefty dose of salt, it does fit what we've seen. The Templars are barely able to escort the MC across town, I don't see them enforcing a global masquerade.
 

Grumpy Old Aussie

Engaged Member
May 6, 2023
2,042
4,147
Could she be? Sure. Is she? I have no idea. With the scant information we have it's impossible to rule anyone out as the mastermind behind the demons. We've barely met two of the major players in a setting that presumably has a large number of players in it (since one of the few things we know about Neverwhere is that it connects to more than nine worlds). We can't even tell if said mastermind was working for the demons (trying to eliminate a dangerous mage) or against them (trying to get Durandal into the hands of the MC). So it's all guesswork.

If I had to guess, though, I'd say no. Linnae's situation seems like an adequate explanation for her actions so far. Yes, she's been more sympathetic to the MC than the others, but that wouldn't be surprising if she was a friend of the MC's parents. (And frankly it's not like her respect for the MC is uncommon among the other Templars we've seen, either.) Likewise it's easy to see how being booted from the Council doesn't faze her: from what we've seen the Council is a thankless waste of time. No one can agree on anything and they were apparently reliant on the MC's dad to provide any leadership. Now that he's back, who wouldn't want to be rid of the whole thing?

I think we'll have to see how Linnae takes to life after the Council before we should get suspicious. If she's still keeping a close eye on Templar/elf politics or tries to get the MC to support her own agenda, that would be the mark of someone who should have hated walking away from the Council. If she's happy to run errands and train recruits, it's more likely she's on the up and up. That's my $0.02, anyway.



Eh, moron seems like exactly the right word for William. I'm willing to be sympathetic to the ruthlessly pragmatic approach, especially since William seems to lead whatever passes for the Templar's military, but his proposal is ridiculous. He wants an all out attack on the elves (the same elves whose queen scares him shitless even on neutral ground!) to rescue a prisoner (whose location he doesn't know), all on the grounds that if they fail it's no worse than disbanding the Templars - an option everyone already rejected as unacceptable. I mean... wow.

That's a level of incompetence even Arnold J. Rimmer couldn't sink to: his "daylight charge across the minefield" might have had a horrific body count, but it was still a successful feint for the real plan. William, apparently, wants to get everyone killed ASAP because he's convinced Templar leadership is so incompetent that it's only a matter of time before they blunder into accepting the elves' ultimatum. :rolleyes:



The Templars as shield to humanity is the party line, but even with our limited information we already know it's at best partially true. The Templars only control a portion of the connections between Earth and Neverwhere, and we know they can't even monitor others a short distance away. We're also told that people of public interest "paint a huge target on [their] back" if they make obvious use of Neverwhere as a means of transportation, so clearly there are one or more forces besides the Templars who also act as gatewardens for Earth. Whatever protection the Templars provide is either limited in scope or very selective.

That doesn't mean they aren't providing some sort of protection or that there services mustn't be valuable, but we currently lack the details to evaluate how - or even if - the Templars should be reformed. Hopefully now that the MC's father is safe we can finally start digging for some solid answers before we let the elves bombard us with their own propaganda.



The elves demanded the Templars close their own connections to Neverwhere. There's nothing to indicate closing ALL connections was possible, or even that the elves would want that.

Also, it's important to note that, at least from what Kaija said, it's someone else who kills the people that talk about Neverwhere; the Templars just know how to keep a low enough profile to avoid getting killed themselves. While I'd take anything Kaija says with a hefty dose of salt, it does fit what we've seen. The Templars are barely able to escort the MC across town, I don't see them enforcing a global masquerade.
That is a pretty comprehensive assessment.
 
Oct 10, 2022
4,349
7,727
They should but they believe they are what they say they are. Even though we can see them for what they have become. As you have said, cult mindset. They have "special knowledge", "only they know 'the real truth' so they are above everyone else", and so on. Its all very seductive and tragic. Hence why I don't hate them, its just sad to see what they have become from what the Templars use to be.
It is interesting that you count things what makes me hate them and then you ended it with I don't hate them. I am amused to see, how subjective opinions can be.

Perhaps its Kaija (just joking, I couldn't resist). It could be none of the Templar Council are involved and a third party has just taken advantage of their corruption. I think Fiona's family will have a role in there somewhere. Although unleashing demons on the world doesn't seem like a very sane thing to do or very beneficial to anyone. It will be interesting to see how things evolve.
Yeah, it could be none of the Templars. We just assume there is a traitor among them. I also think Fiona's family will be involved but I am not sure they'll have direct effect on this.

The elves demanded the Templars close their own connections to Neverwhere. There's nothing to indicate closing ALL connections was possible, or even that the elves would want that.

Also, it's important to note that, at least from what Kaija said, it's someone else who kills the people that talk about Neverwhere; the Templars just know how to keep a low enough profile to avoid getting killed themselves. While I'd take anything Kaija says with a hefty dose of salt, it does fit what we've seen. The Templars are barely able to escort the MC across town, I don't see them enforcing a global masquerade.
I kinda missed that part if they only demanded closing their own connection. Iirc, they demand they will close all the known connections. I may have misremember it though.

I don't say they are killing people over it but they do turn blind eye to it. Also I would not cross out that they'd kill if it serves them. What they do and what they say, is plain oxymoron. What you are saying is basically what I am saying in that regards.
They could not transport Grand Master's son within city, they are not aware even to the closest connections, they are not protecting anyone but they are claiming they are protector of humanity, they are the righteous ones etc. Either do what you are claiming or shut the fuck up, right? I don't say they do enforce a global masquerade, though they are helping it, I don't think they are even capable of throwing a house warming party let alone a global masquerade.

Thank you for your opinions, it really is a good one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grumpy Old Aussie

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,208
13,378
I kinda missed that part if they only demanded closing their own connection. Iirc, they demand they will close all the known connections. I may have misremember it though.
This is how she phrased her demand. I don't think it changes based on our actions, but I haven't looked at the code so I could be wrong.
Medb_close_Neverwhere_portals_demand.jpg

I don't say they are killing people over it but they do turn blind eye to it. Also I would not cross out that they'd kill if it serves them. What they do and what they say, is plain oxymoron. What you are saying is basically what I am saying in that regards.
They could not transport Grand Master's son within city, they are not aware even to the closest connections, they are not protecting anyone but they are claiming they are protector of humanity, they are the righteous ones etc. Either do what you are claiming or shut the fuck up, right? I don't say they do enforce a global masquerade, though they are helping it, I don't think they are even capable of throwing a house warming party let alone a global masquerade.
I see things slightly differently in that I don't necessarily think the Templars are turning a blind eye. It really depends on who's doing the killing and why. If the combined governments of Earth are hellbent on enforcing the secrecy, it's entirely possible the Templars couldn't protect people from them anymore than they could rescue the Grand Master from the elves: they might make a good showing for a moment, but they'd be swiftly wiped out and then whoever they were protecting would be killed anyway.

Likewise, just because they aren't protecting humanity's right to know about Neverwhere, it doesn't follow that they aren't protecting humanity at all. It could be that the Templars view their role as protecting humanity against specifically supernatural threats. Things like demons or elves they'll fight, but what humans do to each other is beyond their mandate. This would certainly fit in with Kaija's insistence she needed to fight the Hellspawn in chapter 4. If true, we could debate the morality of such a view, but they may still provide a valuable service even if it's not the one we'd prefer.

Again, we just don't know enough to judge, at least IMHO.

Thank you for your opinions, it really is a good one.
Thanks, I appreciate your views as well.
 

Ceolag

Member
Donor
Game Developer
Sep 6, 2020
261
3,559
ch5_preview_10.png


Hey everyone,

this Dev Log will be shorter than the last ones since this week has been pretty normal.
No stories of me getting ill, hard disks dying, and so on. Sorry, not sorry. ;-)

Although the week was pretty busy with work (end/start of the month usually is) and a bit of family stuff, the progress on the game was still decent.
On the render side, I got 84 static renders and 1 more animation done.
Script-wise, I'm sitting at 1300 lines which means 199 new lines this week... damn, let me add a useless comment line somewhere real quick...

The total numbers are:
405 static renders
3 animations
1300 lines in the script file

We're getting closer to the main part of Chapter 5.
Next week I'm going to work on the 2... animation-heavy scenes that are left before we get to the main part.
And the Steam Next Fest starts on Monday. The demo has already been tested and released. I hope there won't be any errors with that version so I can focus on the Chapter 5 development.

That's it for today, have a nice weekend.

Cheers,
Ceolag

ch5_preview_12.png
 
4.40 star(s) 38 Votes