For what it's worth I do think the game will probably get more traction and popularity with 3D art, and it gives you more freedom. But my personal preference is real porn. For me personally it just gives a greater level of immersion and believability to what I'm reading if there's a real image to pair with it. Particularly animated gifs/videos paired with a paragraph of writing. If I could pick. Even if it was just for the sex scenes. If I were to mix the two I'd probably have real porn for the more explicit content like sex scenes or modeling stuff, and use 3d art for the environment, meeting characters and other story stuff. But I can't tell you how to make your game. I can just say what I enjoy about it.
I suppose ideally if you could do it, to create a real porn model that looks real but is completely fabricated. Giving you full creative control but also looking lie a real porn actress. Just not one that's a real person irl. But at that point you're delving into heavy cgi work to make something that mimics reality that closely, and that is probably incredibly expensive and probably not worth it for you.
I also prefer html because I do play on a tablet, and renpy games just don't really work well on those devices. If they run at all, they'll frequently crash or give a variety of errors. It's unfortunate. So there are plenty of good games on other engines that I just won't experience because of running issues.
It's a big ask, but is there any chance you'll develop both versions of the game simultaneously? The writing could be the same. It is more work obviously. But it could appease both fan bases. It would just be a matter of finding new media as you expand the story. But I don't know what your plans are or how much you're going to expand what's already there.
I do appreciate that you've stuck with the game so long. It's very rare anyone would develop a project like this beyond a year.
I suppose ideally if you could do it, to create a real porn model that looks real but is completely fabricated. Giving you full creative control but also looking lie a real porn actress. Just not one that's a real person irl. But at that point you're delving into heavy cgi work to make something that mimics reality that closely, and that is probably incredibly expensive and probably not worth it for you.
I also prefer html because I do play on a tablet, and renpy games just don't really work well on those devices. If they run at all, they'll frequently crash or give a variety of errors. It's unfortunate. So there are plenty of good games on other engines that I just won't experience because of running issues.
It's a big ask, but is there any chance you'll develop both versions of the game simultaneously? The writing could be the same. It is more work obviously. But it could appease both fan bases. It would just be a matter of finding new media as you expand the story. But I don't know what your plans are or how much you're going to expand what's already there.
I do appreciate that you've stuck with the game so long. It's very rare anyone would develop a project like this beyond a year.