Thank you. I did have the list. I just catch a fish... ANY fish... (let alone the "target" fish from the fish shack) once every 30 to 40 casts with the right bait.
Is that the normal catch rate? Or is there more than RNG? (ex: you have to be on the edges to catch shark... or whatever). Or is it just cast and hope?
Don't know what you're doing wrong, but 30-40 casts to catch any fish is far from normal. Sometimes they reject, but if you try for another couple of casts with an appropriate lure, even the finicky ones usually take it. If not change colour or style, position on the beach, and where you put your lure relative to the direction of the target fish. It shouldn't be that difficult. Seems very strange...30-40 casts is ridiculous.
Note that pink squid is better than green plug for marlin, and it also picks up more than it's fair share of tuna. Although since it is more expensive than green squid, don't use it for tuna unless they're being shy of green squid...No need to waste anymore cash than necessary due to lost lures.