Yeah I hate when certain games are put on ‘rails’ where if you don’t progress with certain love interests, that’s it. I specifically ran into that with Fetish Locator. Hated being forced to pursue a relationship with Lydia, nothing about her character was appealing to me.
I’m only mildly interested in Jolina, moreso just to check out the extra lewd content. Objectively speaking, she is pretty hot, but something about her, the way she comes across (maybe her personality) just annoys me.
As far as finding the right combo of characters willing and to be in an open relationship, I wonder if Elaine and Bella have a combo they might be ok with. Clearly they’re both jealous of each other with the MC, so I’m not sure they are the sharing type. I do like them both individually, and it would save time not to have to restart the game and play their routes solo.