Kept the house. If Elaine is evil as it is making us feel, then yay, new house. If not, then whoops. Maybe we get an option later to sell it to her for like a buck or something.
Either way, my main is Katie, so I'm already losing my share of the money. Got a beach house and car, so don't really need the house. So sell the house for a nice amount of cash and get my payout that way. Sure it won't be the tons of money from the inheritance, but I'm not giving up Katie for some cash. Or even sell the beach house and keep the house. Both are prime real estate, so either will net a pretty penny.