Oct 8, 2019
206
411
All good man, nobody here has something against criticism but you have to admit there is certain posts here that do stretch the definition of "criticism". I have a hard time getting anything out of "this is no game", "this game will never finish", "dev is a scammer who milks patrons", and things like that, they hardly qualify as criticism.
I really value constructive criticism, heck I even find it acceptable if people say "the game runs like shit" or "the game looks like shit". At least thats something I can understand and relate to and know how to adress.
Well I guess the former is also something I know how to adress, but I cant relate to it. I cant just snap my fingers and have a finished game on the table, I just hope that with further progress in the story mode and graphical development those types of voices gradually quiet down.
peace
Great points, people do stretch criticism beyond. I fucking do it myself, definitely try to be more mindful of it of myself than before. Another great point is the example of criticism you made - if someone says the game runs like shit or the graphics are shit, hell if someone thinks something specific is boring; you at least know where you can look to start as you said.

You can't do that if someone just says "the game is shit" and/or "a scam" because there is no context... no elaboration. No explanation as to why they think this or that. So either between legitimate good intentions criticism but conveyed with poor communication and the actual undeniable trolling, there's definitely a difference between good and bad criticism.
 
  • Like
Reactions: limesseur

LjQujd

Member
Jul 18, 2020
187
591
I know the dude I replied to classes critics and random people shitting on the game in the same category.
Actually, I didn't specify the exact messages I was referring to in my post so there's no way you can know that. Please don't jump to conclusions too quickly.

To clarify, I do see a difference between genuine critics, those who are simply frustrated fappers, and then the actual haters. Hate, in this context, implies a level of hostility, an intention to slander, and to spread negative sentiments.
 

Wlms

Active Member
Apr 17, 2021
815
1,287
Actually, I didn't specify the exact messages I was referring to in my post so there's no way you can know that. Please don't jump to conclusions too quickly.
Jokes on you, 'cause I'm actually a mindreader.



For instance, right now, you're thinking about cheese.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: JDoeDude

Purple_Heart

Well-Known Member
Oct 15, 2021
1,853
3,222
if someone says the game runs like shit or the graphics are shit, hell if someone thinks something specific is boring; you at least know where you can look to start as you said.

You can't do that if someone just says "the game is shit" and/or "a scam" because there is no context... no elaboration. No explanation as to why they think this or that.
I've elaborated this so much I don't know how can I make this more clear. I've seen and played games that are deemed impossible by wild life fans. Here, this is just one example among many:

This game came out in 2016. It had great graphics for its time. It had an unique gameplay. It has ground battles. It has space battles. It is a strategy game. It is a third person shooter game. It's gameplay is certainly enjoyable. It has lots of animations. It has lots of AI controlled characters. AI is not dumb. It has gameplay. It's gameplay has depth beyond rock paper scissors mechanics of traditional strategy games. But most importantly, it was made by a single man and yet it didn't need decades of patreon money.

Games like that one example exist. They are not impossible to do. They were done before:

They are still being done even today:

There is no legit excuse that porn game developers can use. Yet here we are.

None of these games took 7+ years to develop. None of these games needed patreon. I'm adding this just incase someone still cannot see my point whether they don't want to or they are not smart enough.

Edit: Added yet another example:

This is a sequel. Dev made the first game in his spare time all by himself. Game was successfull enough he hired people while working on the sequel. Both games are very similar: they are fully 3d, animated, have good graphics, have enjoyable gameplay. They only have one drawback, they are short.
 
Last edited:

Ikarianus

New Member
Jan 1, 2018
10
3
That was our Apoc demo from back in 2018/19. Man a lot changed since then. But I really want to get that type of feeling back for Mayas part of the main game, so you can "fly around as the cute Girl with wings, doing Quests and having Sex. "
Damn i didn't know you're actually reading this.^^ Sorry if i were rude at some point. Just wanted to express my feelings about the actual version. But for me, it was awesome to be able to play as "The cute girl with wings" (Sorry i forgot her name at that time xD)

But to give you some good feedback: I love the animations and the graphics so far. The overall style is beautiful and i think, if you maybe go with two campaigns, one for Maya and one for the Explorers, then i think, the game could give a deep story to the player, while still being a porn game. Maybe an option to choose one of them, while they both meet at the trees? Or a change in the middle of the campaign could also be an awesome choice (Maybe with an picture of her being played, so people don't think they have to stick with the dude^^). Well, these options are just simple suggestions, but "maybe" they could fit in whatever you have planned so far.


Anyway, i will keep an eye on that. Have a nice day. ♥
 
  • Like
Reactions: AdeptusSteve

Akyana_Ako

New Member
Nov 30, 2021
8
2
Is anyone else having trouble with the downloads? None of them seem to work. Either removed or every time I download the file it appears corrupted.
 
Oct 8, 2019
206
411
I've elaborated this so much I don't know how can I make this more clear. I've seen and played games that are deemed impossible by wild life fans. Here, this is just one example among many:

This game came out in 2016. It had great graphics for its time. It had an unique gameplay. It has ground battles. It has space battles. It is a strategy game. It is a third person shooter game. It's gameplay is certainly enjoyable. It has lots of animations. It has lots of AI controlled characters. AI is not dumb. It has gameplay. It's gameplay has depth beyond rock paper scissors mechanics of traditional strategy games. But most importantly, it was made by a single man and yet it didn't need decades of patreon money.

Games like that one example exist. They are not impossible to do. They were done before:

They are still being done even today:

There is no legit excuse that porn game developers can use. Yet here we are.

None of these games took 7+ years to develop. None of these games needed patreon. I'm adding this just incase someone still cannot see my point whether they don't want to or they are not smart enough.

Edit: Added yet another example:

This is a sequel. Dev made the first game in his spare time all by himself. Game was successfull enough he hired people while working on the sequel. Both games are very similar: they are fully 3d, animated, have good graphics, have enjoyable gameplay. They only have one drawback, they are short.
I think I can see where you're coming from, and I'm not trying to say that criticism isn't valid. I personally think it's crucial for improvement. But it's the difference of being descriptive and providing examples along with the criticism to give it merit. Criticism without that is then just a personal opinion with no context.

More specifically onto your point, I'd have to say that it's pretty much comparing apples to oranges to compare adult games to conventional games. What will always apply to any genre of any skill based medium (meaning this applies to music, movies etc) is that every creator is going to have their own list of what they're good and bad at. Some people can effortlessly do what might be a 3 person job for another.

Now for comparing adult games to conventional - adult games get more criticism than conventional for 2 main reasons.

1. Personal taste (people want SPECIFIC kinks, content)

Conventional games can typically get away with going the route they originally set out to go from the start. If people dislike something about this game or that game, there's 10 more they could try and might possibly be better in that area. Adult games are very niche and far fewer. Which on its own brings MORE criticism because people have much less options to find better substitutes. If the game never improves for whatever reason, there isn't likely to be a similar game to exist let alone "get it right" the first time... So critics will be more vocal about the adult games they're passionate about.

Basically - adult games have more demand than supply whereas conventional has more supply than demand - in most genres.

2. Second branches from that in the sense that adult games get that more nuanced criticism so you get to a point where some of that feedback may be radically different than the original vision that the developer ever even intended their game to be.

Then you have a dilemma as developer... do you sacrifice your vision to try to please as many people as you can? Or do you stick to your guns and double down? You can never please everybody; and when it comes to adult games, people will want very personal things so then the people who don't get what they want are more disappointed than some COD bro mad they didn't add their favorite gun...
 
  • Like
Reactions: limesseur

Fuchsschweif

Active Member
Sep 24, 2019
986
1,563
1. Personal taste (people want SPECIFIC kinks, content)

Conventional games can typically get away with going the route they originally set out to go from the start. If people dislike something about this game or that game, there's 10 more they could try and might possibly be better in that area. Adult games are very niche and far fewer. Which on its own brings MORE criticism because people have much less options to find better substitutes. If the game never improves for whatever reason, there isn't likely to be a similar game to exist let alone "get it right" the first time... So critics will be more vocal about the adult games they're passionate about.
Uhm, quite the opposite. Operating in a niche field with very little competition allows for tons of mistakes, because people have to use your product if they want to have the experience. Don't like Counter Strike? Play one of the other 10.000+ shooters out there.

Don't like Wild Life? Well, good luck finding anything even remotely close. You better spend a few days learning the sandbox tools, otherwise you won't have this experience at all.

Also, adult games are much easier to milk, because people (men) think with their dicks. It's way easier to make someone pay who's horny for porn content than casual games, porn is WAY more addicting.


2. Second branches from that in the sense that adult games get that more nuanced criticism so you get to a point where some of that feedback may be radically different than the original vision that the developer ever even intended their game to be.

Then you have a dilemma as developer... do you sacrifice your vision to try to please as many people as you can? Or do you stick to your guns and double down? You can never please everybody; and when it comes to adult games, people will want very personal things so then the people who don't get what they want are more disappointed than some COD bro mad they didn't add their favorite gun...
CoD is one of the hardest criticized games out there. Last titles had terrible ratings on Steam and a lot of business decisions that upset the fanbase. Still it sells like nothing good. The CoD devs dont want to please people as much as they can, they just do what they think works best and then the audience finds them - not the other way round.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dawndmon
Oct 8, 2019
206
411
Uhm, quite the opposite. Operating in a niche field with very little competition allows for tons of mistakes, because people have to use your product if they want to have the experience. Don't like Counter Strike? Play one of the other 10.000+ shooters out there.

Don't like Wild Life? Well, good luck finding anything even remotely close. You better spend a few days learning the sandbox tools, otherwise you won't have this experience at all.
That's literally what I'm saying. Yet with adult games you're going to get more brutal criticisms from hormone horny dudes who have no dev experience to make a better game themselves.

Also, adult games are much easier to milk, because people (men) think with their dicks. It's way easier to make someone pay who's horny for porn content than casual games, porn is WAY more addicting.
Yes, that's a good example of my point - adult games get a degree of criticism that non-adult games don't. And yes, at the same time adult games are easy to milk... but so are conventional games. Look at GTA V, COD, anything with season/battle passes...

CoD is one of the hardest criticized games out there. Last titles had terrible ratings on Steam and a lot of business decisions that upset the fanbase. Still it sells like nothing good. The CoD devs dont want to please people as much as they can, they just do what they think works best and then the audience finds them - not the other way round.
And there's another good point which is going to differ between every developer... each has their own strengths/weaknesses and each have their own good/bad intentions. There absolutely are some devs in both adult and conventional gaming who set out from the get-go to milk a cashcow and scam. Look at The Day Before clownshow.

I'm just saying that's it's unfair to jump to conclusions especially if criticism doesn't give support to back up WHY someone feels that way about it. Like I said before, then it's just a context-less personal opinion. At the same time I'm NOT saying people can't have their own opinion on whatever, but those people can't give CONSTRUCTIVE criticism, then they're better off moving on without the worthless complaints.
 
  • Like
Reactions: limesseur

Fuchsschweif

Active Member
Sep 24, 2019
986
1,563
I'm just saying that's it's unfair to jump to conclusions especially if criticism doesn't give support to back up WHY someone feels that way about it. Like I said before, then it's just a context-less personal opinion. At the same time I'm NOT saying people can't have their own opinion on whatever, but those people can't give CONSTRUCTIVE criticism, then they're better off moving on without the worthless complaints.
Well, the OP you replied to wasn't about criticism or how loud it is. It was about the speed of development, how much can be done in what time with what budget.

Your post make it look like the Wildlife devs would have it harder because they're making a porn game and had to switch directions 30 times because fans wanted something different every 2 months, which led to a slow development.

But this isn't the case. The game is and was what it is right now from the very beginning. It was mainly a sandbox, and a singleplayer with story exists as an idea for later. It's slow because the devs don't set priorities and don't organize their project well enough. They were recording Fortnite'y like emotes with motion capture in a stage where that's one of the least things the game needed. They try to do two things in the same time: Offering casual porn and that beast stuff. The problem is, that many people don't want that beast stuff, so for a lot of fans over half of the game is literally unusable. It doesn't help that many scenes on the "casual" side are with that extra fat and disgusting man.

The devs also can't decide whether this is supposed to be a sandbox game or not. They're constantly distracted by trying to build an innovative next-gen sandbox while creating a full open world experience as if they were Ubisoft with 200 people in two different studios each. Of COURSE this will take ages with this approach. Instead of having a very good and polished story game or sandbox first, you only get alpha prototypes of both. New animations and assets are coming in too slow, but the story part also develops way too slow. As they saying goes: If you chase two rabbits at once, you won't catch either one.

Also they don't seem to hire more staff to speed up the creation of animations or assets, and everytime someone mentions it here, Steve jumps in and comes up with "you have no idea blablabla". I haven't seen their team scale up proportionally to the increased revenue.

The problem is how this project is being managed, not that there are "more critics". Good project managment is everything.

But anyways, we've discussed this many times here already. Repeating it all over and over again won't change anything.
 
Last edited:

maremaremare

Member
Aug 6, 2020
243
368
Oct 8, 2019
206
411
Well, the OP you replied to wasn't about criticism or how loud it is. It was about the speed of development, how much can be done in what time with what budget.
Um, whoever the OP who you're referring to originally replied to a reply of mine to Steve which was just me saying "Hey, I get that. Constructive criticism is good. Unhelpful hate isn't". Whoever, I haven't been paying attention to names, seemed like they wanted to debate over the objectiveness of actual constructive criticism kinda derailing from the topic. You literally can't say anything even remotely reasonable online... there's always someone that has a problem with it.

Your post make it look like the Wildlife devs would have it harder because they're making a porn game and had to switch directions 30 times because fans wanted something different every 2 months, which led to a slow development. But this isn't the case. The game is and was what it is right now from the very beginning.
Definitely not my initial intention and I felt that I defined constructive criticism and unhelpful opinions. Maybe not. I apologize if I wasn't clear enough. However, I'm also not outright defending the Wildlife team or Steve himself. I mentioned how every dev has their strengths and weakness, maybe management isn't one of their strong suits and that could be a fair assumption to make. Maybe they never had the game they wanted 100% thought out from the start and they keep adding which causes technical setbacks and problems popping up. I personally don't know their situation so I have nothing to say neither for or against them; and since I don't know the situation and my opinion wouldn't be constructive for them.



The devs also can't decide whether this is supposed to be a sandbox game or not. They're constantly distracted by trying to build an innovative next-gen sandbox while creating a full open world experience as if they were Ubisoft with 200 people in two different studios each.

The problem is how this project is being managed, not that there are "more critics". Good project management is everything.

But anyways, we've discussed this many times here already. Repeating it all over and over again won't change anything.
About the management aspect, I agree, and poor management definitely isn't just a problem with adult game devs. It's all the time with most games anymore. Games launch at full price in Early Access - get finished 2+ years later... usually when everyone's moved on. Greedy overpriced MTXs. Cut content to be sold as DLC. Gaming overall is in a bad spot for a while now. I think that itself has a bit of an impact on peoples' vocalness on games as a whole, which is what I tried to explain as well.

I'm not trying to argue or say people aren't allowed to have their opinions but what I am saying is that if feedback isn't accompanied by what makes a person dislike something; then it's not constructive and just a diss to the game and the dev.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GucciGang69

Mick Thompson

Newbie
Sep 25, 2019
40
62
There is one on both of the discord servers

For importing models from Blender, you first need to save/export it as a compatible file type (.obj is fine), then when in the sandbox editor, under the Prototype section of objects there is one called User Mesh. Place the User Mesh and find where it asks for a Mesh Path and select the .obj file you made. Then you can save it as a Collection to use it again in the future
Thanks for the instructions, but i cznt find prop like this in discord. Can u give the name of it?
 

limesseur

Member
Oct 7, 2019
237
236
Thanks for the instructions, but i cznt find prop like this in discord. Can u give the name of it?
It may have been deleted on discord, because I can't find it either. There was a heels prop though once upon a time. Some of the character mods might have heeled shoes with them, but other than that I think the heels may have been deleted
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mick Thompson

procher

New Member
Jul 12, 2018
1
0
Is there a way to use the Custom Materials menu to edit characters?
Or something similar. I wanna put womb tattoos on some characters
 
3.80 star(s) 176 Votes