Seagal

Active Member
Oct 10, 2017
533
2,210
If ICSTOR throw up the new update with Being a Dick to see who is better? just think about it
Milfy City has better renders, better posing, better animations, and in my opinion is a better porn game. One is a great nukige visual novel, and the other is a slightly above average eroge with high sexual content.

There are a lot of missing pictures here and there? WTF is that supposed to mean? OH BTW, you have heard of smartphones?
It means they're finishing piecing the whole thing together, and then they can begin the testing process.
 

TheFapperBoy

Member
Aug 13, 2017
484
2,018
So, if the update is that big, does that mean that he expanded the content for Caroline since he took that break? Because if I remember correctly, the Caroline content was done minus the animations. He said he could technically release the update at the time, but chose not to.

So, what gives? If the update has taken this long, because of only the neighbors content, then thats gonna be really disappointing.
 

Pillepalle

Newbie
May 12, 2018
92
129
So, if the update is that big, does that mean that he expanded the content for Caroline since he took that break? Because if I remember correctly, the Caroline content was done minus the animations. He said he could technically release the update at the time, but chose not to.

So, what gives? If the update has taken this long, because of only the neighbors content, then thats gonna be really disappointing.

Next update also has Celia content. However I wouldn't exactly 100% believe him when he said that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malkovichi

Seagal

Active Member
Oct 10, 2017
533
2,210
So, if the update is that big, does that mean that he expanded the content for Caroline since he took that break? Because if I remember correctly, the Caroline content was done minus the animations. He said he could technically release the update at the time, but chose not to.

So, what gives? If the update has taken this long, because of only the neighbors content, then thats gonna be really disappointing.
I guess no one will know for sure, but I'll bet everyone got some extra love, especially Caroline. ICSTOR knows she's a big fan favorite, so I'm sure her content won't disappoint. I'd suggest to try and not think to much about it, and just enjoy the huge ass update we're getting.
 

TheFapperBoy

Member
Aug 13, 2017
484
2,018
LOL. Being A DIK is by far the best game in this site and i don't event think Milf City is at top5.
I agree.... sort of.

Milfy City was definitely top 5 pre-hiatus. No questions asked. But, after this huge delay it's been bumped off. Maybe after this update, and the next we can better assess if the game can go back to what it was.
 

Q Who

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 16, 2017
1,718
1,788
Milfy City has better renders, better posing, better animations, and in my opinion is a better porn game. One is a great nukige visual novel, and the other is a slightly above average eroge with high sexual content.


It means they're finishing piecing the whole thing together, and then they can begin the testing process.
Milfy City is not even in the same ballpark as BAD. Milfy is the same as incest story tweaked slightly. The renders are marginally better than BAD. The posing is a win for BAD. Simply due to the numbers alone. All of these animations are crap. .5 seconds of looped unnatural animation is not worth discussing.

Milfy is not a game. It is a VN really. What gameplay is there to this game? Learning how to count to 50%? Putting up signs for the mayor? Climbing the wall to abuse his aunt? This is no more than click\do this to get this scene eventually. The story is utter garbage with no continuity whatsoever. The only possible way to judge Milfy as superior is if a person sees incest is important aspect.

The Milfy story is truly just sooo soooo terrible and cringe it makes engrish VNs look good. In BAD characters do not disappear for chapters at a time. Choices made in the game actually matter as to what is displayed going forward. The setting in BAD feels like a college and not a high school. None of the women in BAD are intended to be the MCs mother or sisters. The MC never rapes anyone. The list goes on but the point is made.

As for trusting Icstor not to stick a placeholder image(work in progress) in place of the "missing" render. That ship sailed a long time ago. I read that statement as he has not even done the render. Not that it is simply needs to be placed.
 

Q Who

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 16, 2017
1,718
1,788
You have three messages and registered less than a month ago. What can you know about this site? BADIK doesn't hold a candle to this game.
Other than renders perhaps you can point out the ways in which Milfy is superior to BAD? Please do more than say the story is better or something equally generic.
 

PashafromRussia

Well-Known Member
Aug 18, 2019
1,557
5,508
Only 2 games can compete with Milf city. It is Echoes of Lust and Midnight Paradise. Both have excellent animations and renders. Echoes of lust is even better than Milf city.
The main problem Milf city that all too quickly. Mother and sister starts sucking cock too fast. But in Midnight Paradise MC has made only assjob to Sister in 0.5
 

RC-1138 Boss

Message Maven
Apr 26, 2017
12,971
19,143
You have three messages and registered less than a month ago. What can you know about this site? BADIK doesn't hold a candle to this game.
The only thing Milfy City got better is perhaps the technical quality of the renders (although his knowledge of anatomy is weird) and even this isn't by much.

Everything else from the character's development, music/sounds, and a actual story with branching choices Being a DIK does a whole LOT better.
 
Last edited:

MeetYourMaker

New Member
Aug 26, 2019
4
12
You have three messages and registered less than a month ago. What can you know about this site? BADIK doesn't hold a candle to this game.
This is my second account and believe me kid i played tons of games in this site. My top 5 btw; BADIK Waifu Academy The Deluca Family Acting Lessons City of Broken Dreams. And yes they all better than Milf City. Im sorry :)
 

Seagal

Active Member
Oct 10, 2017
533
2,210
You guys are entitled to your opinion, but I don't think much of your opinion though, or hold really any value in anything you say because you're known trolls and haters of this game. Which is clearly evident from your nonstop posting in this thread. I'll entertain you with a response here one last time though.

And just an FYI - most people refer to a Visual Novel as a game, so if Milfy City isn't a game then neither is that other title.

Milfy City has better renders, posing, and animation. That really isn't for debate here either. Not to take away from that other creator, because I enjoy the game and even support him, but he's not as good as ICSTOR when it comes to those things. There's a few creators that are in that top tier with ICSTOR. The unnamed games creator is just a notch below them. Wish I could say more and give examples, but I know I shouldn't do that, and the mods scare me around here.

If you notice what I said in my post also, I said Milfy City is a better porn game, and I believe it is. If you want something with more of a story focus than maybe you'll enjoy that other title more. It's why I say Milfy City is a nukige, and that other game is a eroge with high sexual content. There's a different approach when it comes to story focus between the two. Look up the terms in you need to.

It just happens that I enjoy nukige a lot more than your average eroge visual novel. So that's why I say Milfy City in my opinion is a better game, but I won't call anyone crazy or anything for liking that other game more, because it's a great game.
 
3.70 star(s) 409 Votes