However, if there is one interesting thing that I have learned from this discussion it is that an unnatural or scientifically-based explanation for the inducement to incest in this particular game caused a fascinating reaction. Possibly much more interesting than the game itself. For those who were enjoying the story believing that the characters were inclined toward sexual attraction to family members due to their own inborn and natural predictions, this backstory of the experiment had a profound impact on their ability to enjoy the fetish. This in itself is an area of inquiry that merits further study.
Was thinking the same thing, it is interesting if you're interested in sociology / psychology studies. I mean I haven't thought that much into it but if I had to take a wild guess right now, I'd say that people who played this game and A Petal Among Thorns are probably more interested in playing a game where the characters share an emotionnal connection and a physical intimacy that would be expressed in a way that's considered taboo. It's not only the taboo of having forbidden sexual intercourses with members of the same family, it's also the taboo of having forbidden emotionnal and physical relationships ALONG with sexual intercourses, in a way that it's all connected within the characters. So in a way it's not only the taboo of just "doing forbidden sexual stuff", it's also the taboo of the girls
wanting to do stuff because it's just how they are and how they feel naturally, and, as a result, having not only a forbidden sexual relationship, but also a forbidden emotionnal and physical intimacy with
them. The experiment thing just take that away. Suddenly it's not
them, it's just the product of something that's added to their genes. Therefore we lose all the emotionnal and physical connection to them because it's fake, and we're left with only the sexual intercourses side of the taboo.
Taboos and fetishes are kinda complicated if we go that way too. In this case, even the incest fetish is not singular : there's a lot of different incest fetishes. There's people who stops at sex between family members and can go with that only, others prefer to add something of a romantic / emotionnal nature to it, others that prefer a more "realistic" emotionnal relationship with just the casual forbidden sex between family members etc etc.
It's about overcoming something you fear.
Take for example parachuting. Why would jumping out of an aircraft be interesting to do? Because it is scary! And therefore, if you did it, you overcame your fear.
If, for whatever reason, incestuous feelings would be totally normal and fine, then the taboo and fear of the consequences is gone and only the sex remains.
I don't think that's it about the fear, or at least not as you make it out to be. I mean the fear of the consequences remains, experiment or not. I think it's more about like you said about only the sex remains. Actually that's more about the fear of that. If only the sex remains because everything else feels fake, then either people stop enjoying the other aspects of the taboo (emotionnal and physical intimacy like I said) just because only sex is not what they want, OR they're afraid of still enjoying it even though only the sex remains. In both case, the over-reaction is still understandable.
This hypothetical genetic engineering took away the taboo and was therefore not a good idea.
Yes, that's really it. It took away a very important part of the overall taboo. Not entirely because forbidden sex would still be possible, but the other parts that I think people who played APAT and AMOB enjoyed too (or else they would have stop playing), which is as I said a little too much for my taste right now the emotionnal connection and intimacy between the girls and MC.
That's only true if the relationship was only based on sex to begin with. Most are not and it's more complicated.
So yeah, that. Even works with fictionnal relationships too.