Again, what you see in the comments does not reflect the reception. Content people have little reason to comment on it while dissatisfied people will go on ranting. If you make a poll and get sufficient number of people to vote on it, then you might see some feedback. Forum comments are simply not representative enough.I think this creator should view his users as his editor of sorts.
When overwhelmingly told this isn't the direction that the story should go. Nobody wants this.
You'd imagine that someone would rethink or at least make it so it's not 100% gonna happen. Depending on choices in the game. Choices which seem to be useless.
I get that he want's to tell his "story" and that it's based on some sort of reality (doubt it)
but as many others have written and as I myself said when that chapter was released. The fire stuff really killed the game for me.
Best of luck with telling your story.
Almost all developers will say that they listen to their fans. Of course, you then get the instant logical fallacy that follows (which has even manifested through this discussion thread a few times in various guises) that, of course, the most important fans are the ones who are paying patrons. "Listen to the patrons most, because after all, they are obviously the most important, putting their money where their mouths are". If you read through most of the discussion thus far, I'm sure you saw several mentions of judging this mainly by how the patrons respond...I think this creator should view his users as his editor of sorts.
When overwhelmingly told this isn't the direction that the story should go. Nobody wants this.
You'd imagine that someone would rethink or at least make it so it's not 100% gonna happen. Depending on choices in the game. Choices which seem to be useless.
I get that he want's to tell his "story" and that it's based on some sort of reality (doubt it)
but as many others have written and as I myself said when that chapter was released. The fire stuff really killed the game for me.
Best of luck with telling your story.
If you choose Rena there are good scenes of sex... After the death of your best friend (perhaps with a lesbian relationship) is hard makes tittiesfucks...Games gone all Game of Thrones - loads of tits and bums in the first few episodes followed by hardly any. Was there any sex at all in the latest update? I couldnt find any.
Used to be a fan - not anymore.
Even the reception on this site hasn't been that bad. Posts on this thread seem to be close to even split, people have not been adjusting their reviews down at least not enough to impact the overall average and new reviews have had more five star reviews than negative. I do hate to admit it but overall people do seem to like what's been done with the story.So fat the reception on his patreon has been positive - no negative comments noted so far.. this is not a development company - it’s a guy who got the idea for a story on a slow day at work.. so this is his first attempt at writing anything - and also his first VN - the game was developed in his spare time.. I give this information so that people can judge the game in context .. it will be criticized - and deservedly so for some aspects - but the author isn’t George r r Martin..
I've been taking a closer look at the game's patreon page now and the more I look at it the more I tend to agree that he absolutely shouldn't give any hints at all, but not for the reasons you stated.Great post - I’m actually caught in two minds about this ; as DrPinkcake had already written the story - on getting to episode 4 he probably faced some kind of conundrum - to change the outcome and depart from his original dream/story or continue on .. a more experienced writer might have decided to do the former - he didn’t receive any negative reaction either here or from his patrons,quite the contrary.. the reaction was very positive - but here’s the problem; people were judging it as a romantic drama - which it wasn’t ( no one knew different at the time ) so as far as DrPinkcake was concerned his original plan for the game was proceeding perfectly..
There was no - and couldn’t be any communication regarding the plot on his patreon; as this would give essential plot clues away.( ruining the whole project as far as DrPinkcake was concerned)
By now I would imagine DrPinkcake would have had some inkling as to what might happen - if he proceeded with the original story - that there would be uproar over how people’s beloved characters would be treated in the story.. as i’ve mentioned earlier a more experienced author might have stopped and rewritten the second part of the story - but that as i’ve said ( not a writer or developer so here I bow to others knowledge ) would have taken some considerable amount of time ( six months? ) the backlash from his patrons would have been severe - after all they were paying monthly...so he took a deep breath - and pressed on with his original dream/story.. should he be criticized for this?or applauded - I suppose I like many more of us will probably be able to judge better when this roller coaster of an endeavor finally comes to an end..
I'm just going to point out something I said a while ago.You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
He's working on the next project already, and you think he intentionally wrote this to deceive everyone rather than put forth an original work? The first 4 chapters certainly were deceptive in that they slowly worked us up into growing attachments, but that was so episode 5-8 would be effective. No one would have taken the last couple episodes seriously if those attachments and bonds weren't formed prior. We ALL would have laughed it off and said it was terribly written if that had been the case. The twists are there to get a knee jerk reaction, like a punch in the solar plexus. A very difficult to write response, which many just don't know how to respond to, lol.I don't think that Pink had any qualms or second thoughts about pushing the story out exactly the way he initially planned. As a matter of fact I think he is rotating in his seat right now, laughing maniacally. The more I look at his patreon page the more I can't help but feel that it is in fact meticulously crafted to deceive the viewer.
No doubt about that in my mind, I just think you are underestimating him by sayingThere is no doubt that this story has gone out exactly as it was intended
This doesn't feel like the work of an amateur at all, but a troll extraordinaire.a more experienced author might have stopped and rewritten the second part of the story
... played the game from beginning since i didn't see nurse path...
It would have been no spoiler at all to simply say up front that the story may have some dark turns, and may have an unavoidable death of a main character. It's sensible to make those kinds of warnings because you never know if someone is about to download and play your game to get a welcome distraction from some real life tragedy - like the death of a close friend to some kind of violence - and chose what looks like a lovely sweet game about romance between a boring stockbroker and an innocent aspiring actress ... something they may have deliberately chosen because they absolutely don't want violence and mayhem - two things for which there are a billion other games, and yet they chose to play Acting Lessons for some reason...Great post - I’m actually caught in two minds about this...
This is why Hollywood has their most talented and experienced writers assigned to slasher/horror films.A very difficult to write response, which many just don't know how to respond to, lol.
I'm assuming that's sarcasm (as you've never written anything serious and not for more likes), but I've never had any kind of emotional engagement to anyone in those types of films. I don't even see the relation to those movies in this work.This is why Hollywood has their most talented and experienced writers assigned to slasher/horror films.
You see no similarities between the final scene of Episode 7 and at least 10 Asian body horor films from the 2000s? Do you think those of us talking about tonal shifts are just making things up?I'm assuming that's sarcasm (as you've never written anything serious and not for more likes), but I've never had any kind of emotional engagement to anyone in those types of films. I don't even see the relation to those movies in this work.
Yeah, I'm sure no one would be stupid enough to do THAT.He's working on the next project already, and you think he intentionally wrote this to deceive everyone rather than put forth an original work? The first 4 chapters certainly were deceptive in that they slowly worked us up into growing attachments, but that was so episode 5-8 would be effective. No one would have taken the last couple episodes seriously if those attachments and bonds weren't formed prior. We ALL would have laughed it off and said it was terribly written if that had been the case. The twists are there to get a knee jerk reaction, like a punch in the solar plexus. A very difficult to write response, which many just don't know how to respond to, lol.
Unexpected events can alter the body's chemistry, so repeat after me. "Chemistry"