Alice has always had me in the love path, I will never deny that. The second she appeared she started winning me over but those scenes after he got hurt she had me.
Mel has it hands down in the harem path and she's a damn close second behind Alice in love which is why Mel gets overall top girl but Alice will be my main play through in love with Mel being second and Mel is my top girl in harem with Alison/Alice coming close behind.
However, were I to be there
Mel would be the first love box I tongue punched.