The Good: So far the story is holding my interest, and characters backgrounds and motivations are more complex than usual for the genre.
The Critiques:I applaud you for attempting to add animations. They are crude but you can always improve on them. Many of the scenes would benefit from better lighting and the overall visual quality is only passable or too grainy. I don't know if this is from lack of experience or a low end PC. Again with time these can improve.
The Ugly:
1) Don't get lost in the whole NTR/ non NTR debate. You will never please everyone, and attempting to do so will only lead to frustration. Think about what they are actually saying, "If you don't do the game my way, I won't pirate it any more." Okay cool.
2) Tell your story you way. If you want to add choices on content shown, that's great/ If you don't, those that don't like it can get their jollies somewhere else. I've seen too many potentially good games succumb to the slings and arrows cast here. Work on improving the overall aesthetic quality and story and you will do fine. Show you can provide regular updates: weekly, bi weekly, monthly etc. However you can fit it in, just try to be consistent.