AI Porn is here, Create and Fap TRY FREE
x

VN Ren'Py Completed Become a Rock Star [v1.01] [Mr Jet]

4.20 star(s) 265 Votes
Discussion Reviews (265)
mr.AwesomeGameTaste

mr.AwesomeGameTaste

Well-Known Member
Feb 18, 2021
1,208
2,043
407
MrJay said:
I've mentioned this in other projects but I'm going to mention it here too. Any game like this where there is any exclusivity of content, that is choosing one girl over others or having "consequences" for trying to be involved with several girls at once, is simply doing it wrong. The OVERWHELMING number of players aren't interested in making those choices, they just want all the lewd content. If I can't get all the content in a single save file, in a single playthrough, why should I bother? It just becomes a chore playing the game at that point, replaying it just to get missed content. It's literally just wasting my time. It's frankly insulting to think I have that kind of time to waste on a single game on this site when there are many hundreds of titles on here of similar or higher quality that just doesn't waste my time in that way. And before anyone says it, no, it doesn't make for an interesting or engaging story. It's incredibly contrived and forced to have all those women just happen to show up at the exact same place just to "catch" you. I'm hugely disappointed in what was otherwise a promising game.
Click to expand...
I don't know about the OVERWHELMING number of players,cause games like BARS are very popular,as we can all clearly see. It was never meant to be a harem,that's how the dev wanted to tell this story,and I don't think he took into consideration whether or not you have the time to play all the routes,you have gallery unlocker mod to get all the scenes btw. And no,it's not forced that the 2 of your girlfriends would meet you in the hospital after your sister got shot,one of said gf's being a worker there too,or that your gf outside of the band would want to meet the members of your band.
 
M

MrJay

Active Member
Apr 21, 2017
583
1,731
357
mr.AwesomeGameTaste said:
I don't know about the OVERWHELMING number of players,cause games like BARS are very popular,as we can all clearly see. It was never meant to be a harem,that's how the dev wanted to tell this story,and I don't think he took into consideration whether or not you have the time to play all the routes,you have gallery unlocker mod to get all the scenes btw. And no,it's not forced that the 2 of your girlfriends would meet you in the hospital after your sister got shot,one of said gf's being a worker there too,or that your gf outside of the band would want to meet the members of your band.
Click to expand...
No one has argued for it being a harem game, only someone with non-existent imagination thinks having all the content in a single playthrough means a game is a harem game, especially when there are many games on this site that disprove that notion.

And yes, hospitals are huge places, the idea that they would have to stumble upon each other is absolutely a contrived plot device and not at all necessary.

In the end it only negatively affects the plot. It's not interesting or compelling in any way to have the girls catch the MC. Imagine a porn game that punishes you for wanting more porn content, because that's exactly what's happening here. It's like some of you people lose all your discernment just because the game has the slightest bit of quality, you'll concede to any bad design decisions just because a game has good renders.

No, I am following over 150 games on this site so I have no patience for time-wasting bullshit like forcing the player to keep multiple save files, so I will call it out whenever I come across it. You all can do however you like but hopefully you realize you don't have to put up with pointless chores like that and that your time is better valued by other game designers, and in so doing teach all game designers here to not waste any of our time with pointless nothing.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: mofonistik, gibbonraver, stormdrain and 5 others
mr.AwesomeGameTaste

mr.AwesomeGameTaste

Well-Known Member
Feb 18, 2021
1,208
2,043
407
MrJay said:
No one has argued for it being a harem game, only someone with non-existent imagination thinks having all the content in a single playthrough means a game is a harem game, especially when there are many games on this site that disprove that notion.

And yes, hospitals are huge places, the idea that they would have to stumble upon each other is absolutely a contrived plot device and not at all necessary.

In the end it only negatively affects the plot. It's not interesting or compelling in any way to have the girls catch the MC. Imagine a porn game that punishes you for wanting more porn content, because that's exactly what's happening here. It's like some of you people lose all your discernment just because the game has the slightest bit of quality, you'll concede to any bad design decisions just because a game has good renders.

No, I am following over 150 games on this site so I have no patience for time-wasting bullshit like forcing the player to keep multiple save files, so I will call it out whenever I come across it. You all can do however you like but hopefully you realize you don't have to put up with pointless chores like that and that your time is better valued by other game designers, and in so doing teach all game designers here to not waste any of our time with pointless nothing.
Click to expand...
Nah man. It's not a design flaw, it' s something you don't like.I like it and many others do too, I don't play it for the porn, I'd much rather watch normal porn if that was my goal.If this why you play them, well, you said so yourself, there are many others that fits your needs better, but stating that this is objectivly a design flaw and that the story is less interesting cause of It, well that's Just not True, quite the opposite really, at least for a significant amount of People.
 
Pains7914

Pains7914

Newbie
Jun 6, 2021
15
18
53
MrJay said:
I've mentioned this in other projects but I'm going to mention it here too. Any game like this where there is any exclusivity of content, that is choosing one girl over others or having "consequences" for trying to be involved with several girls at once, is simply doing it wrong. The OVERWHELMING number of players aren't interested in making those choices, they just want all the lewd content. If I can't get all the content in a single save file, in a single playthrough, why should I bother? It just becomes a chore playing the game at that point, replaying it just to get missed content. It's literally just wasting my time. It's frankly insulting to think I have that kind of time to waste on a single game on this site when there are many hundreds of titles on here of similar or higher quality that just doesn't waste my time in that way. And before anyone says it, no, it doesn't make for an interesting or engaging story. It's incredibly contrived and forced to have all those women just happen to show up at the exact same place just to "catch" you. I'm hugely disappointed in what was otherwise a promising game.
Click to expand...
I must say then that I really enjoy the whole "Romantic" part of getting to know really well written characters like there are in some games.
Deciding who you like the most and start to date her and then build a relationship with her.
For me that becomes one of the most important part of the best games, when they get to the part where they sometimes feel like "life simulators" .
I mean, the girls in a few games are so much better written then any book, normal game or movie I've ever seen and I was stunned the first time .

But yeah, it's good still if you can do like many do in the first playthrough of being a Dik for example and enjoy every girl you can that playthrough.
And then for the next you do a fully faithful playthrough with the girl you felt the most for from your first playthrough. .

Then we have games on the complete other side of the scale ofc. Even though my example is quite good, in the VN "Wvm" you are encouraged by your girlfriend to date as many girls as you can (as long as they deserve you). But it actually felt silly at the end of the update with the number of relationships and budding relationships.. lol.
 
cxx

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
77,742
40,291
1,519
Pains7914 said:
Hey guys, this is my first playthrough of 4he game. So far I think it's incredible . Right up in the top along with Being a DIK, Melody, Acting Lessons and Leap of Faith! . So if i compare all other VN's to these 5 games they will all come up short unfortunately.
But tell me, is there any other games on pair with these 5 games? (Hopeful)
Click to expand...
ask on recommendations, mods don't look kindly advertising other devs games on not-their-threads.
 
S

shivz889

Member
Jul 19, 2017
157
29
169
hey guys i had a question, is there any way to avoid being kicked out by rosa and Catherine after the threesome scene? or is that bound to happen either way? also what do you think about it. i really don't want it to be over with rosa she is probably the hottest girl
 
Darkdevil66

Darkdevil66

Magnificent Bastard
Donor
Apr 16, 2020
1,875
51,811
708
shivz889 said:
hey guys i had a question, is there any way to avoid being kicked out by rosa and Catherine after the threesome scene? or is that bound to happen either way? also what do you think about it. i really don't want it to be over with rosa she is probably the hottest girl
Click to expand...
It's a bug
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

But there won't be more content with them, just like Emma they're just side girls. They won't have ending or additional content in the finale update (unless MrJet changes his mind).
 
S

shivz889

Member
Jul 19, 2017
157
29
169
Darkdevil66 said:
It's a bug
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

But there won't be more content with them, just like Emma they're just side girls. They won't have ending or additional content in the finale update (unless MrJet changes his mind).
Click to expand...
but I dont get how is it possible to not cheat on selina, especially when we are not dating rosa is the one who makes us cheat. also is the nest update the final update for the game ?
 
Englen

Englen

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2019
1,603
11,511
731
Intro11d.jpg
You must be registered to see the links


Hey guys! Sorry that I've been doing so few posts lately, but there really isn't much news. As usual, at the beginning of each update, I first did the planning of the update structure (since the update is final, it took a little longer than usual), and now I'm working on the content. Renders, text, scene creation, etc. As for the numbers, I currently have 160 renders ready.

I've been thinking about it for a long time, and decided to add a little wrap-up event with Nicole. It fit in with the main story pretty well, so I'm pretty happy with it.
I should also warn you that due to certain circumstances in my personal life, I won't be available all next week. I also won't have access to my PC, so I won't be able to work on the game. Well, actually, I'll have my laptop, but I'll be able to work with it only on the text. However, I promise you that right after that I'll get to work with double the effort. I hope for your understanding.

That's all I wanted to tell you right now. Thank you for your support and have a great week!

MrJet
 
  • Like
Reactions: xbinhoux, Ludak14, Coo3435s and 14 others
GetOutOfMyLab

GetOutOfMyLab

Conversation Conqueror
Modder
Aug 13, 2021
7,983
23,295
832
I'm totally ok with the concept of being faithful to one girl and not being in a harem situation. In fact, I kind of find the harem thing exhausting, just as I imagine it would be in real life. The thing that got me was how it was worded. When I agreed to be interested in something serious with these girls, to me it meant that we were still not in a full-on relationship, but still dating. That kind of threw me off.

So here are my thoughts. I've done two play-throughs, one being fully into it and the second loading an early save and picking one girl.

1. I like the story. It's well-written and thought out.

2. A little too much dialogue for my tastes. There was a lot of clicking involved and I eventually just skimmed a majority of it because I was able to get the gist of the situation and there was nothing critical or needed in those parts. It' s a bit of a pet peeve for me to have so much talking, but I'm sure there are people who like this aspect.

3. The character development was quite good (despite what I mentioned in #2 about too much talking).

4. Some of the most beautiful character models I've seen in a game. I'm not into blondes, but I'll echo what someone said earlier about Emma probably being the most beautiful. I'm into redheads, and so Selina was also incredibly gorgeous to me. The brunettes are hot, too.

Overall, I think it's a really good game and am looking forward to future updates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: markel1000, stormdrain, Deleted member 863691 and 1 other person
P

p22

Active Member
Jun 21, 2017
847
497
276
shivz889 said:
but I dont get how is it possible to not cheat on selina, especially when we are not dating rosa is the one who makes us cheat. also is the nest update the final update for the game ?
Click to expand...
Rosa herself does not count as cheating Selina.
You just do not need to be on the Love path with all other main girls.

So love path with Selina, and adoring love paths with other main girls.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.20 star(s) 265 Votes