Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,690
19,647
Seriously, Quinn is the only one that has any interest in rattling MC around... The bitch has to die!
Be careful what you wish for. Getting rid of antagonists is not always good for the game. Witness Eric from Big Brother. The developer gave us the means to get rid of Eric, and lost interest in his game.

I believe we need Quinn in this game to provide the necessary tension. She is really the most important NPC in the game. I don't want to get rid of her. I just want to be able to foil her plans.
 

Goblin Baily: DILF

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 29, 2017
7,319
15,639
Be careful what you wish for. Getting rid of antagonists is not always good for the game. Witness Eric from Big Brother. The developer gave us the means to get rid of Eric, and lost interest in his game.

I believe we need Quinn in this game to provide the necessary tension. She is really the most important NPC in the game. I don't want to get rid of her. I just want to be able to foil her plans.
Eric was unnecessary and if someone needs a lame antagonist like that, then maybe it's better to scrap the whole story. BB failed because the story became ridiculous with the sister blackmailing the family provider and the whole porn sub- plot.
BaDiK could continue without Quinn ,fueled by regular relationship and college life drama.
 

Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,690
19,647
That's true, but even if the MC is ok with it it doesn't mean people have to be ok with it too. It's a bit hypocritcal to ask for complete honesty if you don't want to reciprocate. I understand why she hesitates to share it, but...
Well, he kinda does, to both of them. With Josy he has this conversation when she asks to move with him you can say "I'm already living with a girl" and Josy says "I understand you're seeing other girls". And with Maya when you tell her about your date with Josy if you tell her everything she asks "Does she make you hurt?" So you can tell both of them you have feelings for other girls, they don't know for whom, though.
My point is that the MC is NOT reciprocating. And while the MC CAN tell the girls about his feelings for other girls, he NEVER does, not even in that phone conversation with Josy; 'seeing other girls' is not the same thing as having feelings for any of them, not the kind of feelings he is developing for both Josy and Maya.

Not only that, but TanusMorken has pointed out to me that Maya DID tell the MC that she had a girlfriend. How much more completely honest did she need to be? It happens during the conversation the MC has in Episode 3, when he returns to Maya's dorm room after spending the night with Jill.

Maya: "I've dated guys before... ...but I've never slept with one."
MC: "So, you're a virgin?"
Maya: "...no."
MC: "Oh...you mean that you've..."
Maya: "I've only been with a girl, so far."
MC: "But...what about...you know..."
Maya: "You and me?"
MC: "Yeah...?"
Maya: "It beats me... It's the first time I've gotten this close and felt this kind of attraction to a guy..."
MC: "Is this what you've been hiding?"
Maya: "... I can't complete that list on my own. And I shouldn't complete that list..."
MC: "This might be a long shot... ...but what if you told them where you come from?"
Maya: "And tell them that I've only been with a girl!? Are you insane!? No way! No fucking way! I'm not telling anyone that! Nuh-uh! Not again!"
MC: "You told me..."
Maya: "Don't tell anyone... Ok?"
MC: "Of course not. Is this why you have family issues?"
Maya: "It's that obvious, huh?"
MC: "I'm just trying to connect the dots here."
Maya: "Yes. That's why. My family is...um...well my dad is... He's very religious... And when he found out I had a girlfriend...he..."
MC "Oh...say no more...I understand."
Maya: "Ok... So...now you know. And please...don't tell anyone about it."


Maya is certainly more honest in that scene than the MC ever is.

I understand that some don't think that Maya has been honest with the MC. But that doesn't mean that their opinions have any validity or any basis in reality.
 

Blablablafapper

Engaged Member
Apr 19, 2019
2,027
7,232
My point is that the MC is NOT reciprocating. And while the MC CAN tell the girls about his feelings for other girls, he NEVER does, not even in that phone conversation with Josy; 'seeing other girls' is not the same thing as having feelings for any of them, not the kind of feelings he is developing for both Josy and Maya.

Not only that, but TanusMorken has pointed out to me that Maya DID tell the MC that she had a girlfriend. How much more completely honest did she need to be? It happens during the conversation the MC has in Episode 3, when he returns to Maya's dorm room after spending the night with Jill.

Maya: "I've dated guys before... ...but I've never slept with one."
MC: "So, you're a virgin?"
Maya: "...no."
MC: "Oh...you mean that you've..."
Maya: "I've only been with a girl, so far."
MC: "But...what about...you know..."
Maya: "You and me?"
MC: "Yeah...?"
Maya: "It beats me... It's the first time I've gotten this close and felt this kind of attraction to a guy..."
MC: "Is this what you've been hiding?"
Maya: "... I can't complete that list on my own. And I shouldn't complete that list..."
MC: "This might be a long shot... ...but what if you told them where you come from?"
Maya: "And tell them that I've only been with a girl!? Are you insane!? No way! No fucking way! I'm not telling anyone that! Nuh-uh! Not again!"
MC: "You told me..."
Maya: "Don't tell anyone... Ok?"
MC: "Of course not. Is this why you have family issues?"
Maya: "It's that obvious, huh?"
MC: "I'm just trying to connect the dots here."
Maya: "Yes. That's why. My family is...um...well my dad is... He's very religious... And when he found out I had a girlfriend...he..."
MC "Oh...say no more...I understand."
Maya: "Ok... So...now you know. And please...don't tell anyone about it."


Maya is certainly more honest in that scene than the MC ever is.

I understand that some don't think that Maya has been honest with the MC. But that doesn't mean that their opinions have any validity or any basis in reality.
She only uses "had" and "only been" indicating in the past and not currently. She only tells MC that she's only been with a girl before not that she currently has a girlfriend. Which is why he was shocked when Maya introduces Josy as her girlfriend.

At the very least Josy was honest enough to tell us that she currently is in a relationship regardless of the lack of ambiguity.
 

Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,690
19,647
Eric was unnecessary and if someone needs a lame antagonist like that, then maybe it's better to scrap the whole story. BB failed because the story became ridiculous with the sister blackmailing the family provider and the whole porn sub- plot.
BaDiK could continue without Quinn ,fueled by regular relationship and college life drama.
Dark Silver must have thought that Eric was necessary, since he added him in the 4th day of the game. Big Brother may have been ridiculous, but it developed a tremendous following.

DrPinkCake could do a lot of things, but he has chosen to make Quinn an important figure in his game. He has his recipe for this game and should be allowed to follow it as he wishes. From the first time that the MC stepped on campus, Quinn has been an integral part of the 'relationship and college life drama'. That was DrPinkCake's choice, and I highly doubt that he will seriously consider eliminating Quinn in the foreseeable future. You might as well ask him to eliminate one of the five main LIs.
 

Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,690
19,647
She only uses "had" and "only been" indicating in the past and not currently. She only tells MC that she's only been with a girl before not that she currently has a girlfriend. Which is why he was shocked when Maya introduces Josy as her girlfriend.

At the very least Josy was honest enough to tell us that she currently is in a relationship regardless of the lack of ambiguity.
The problem is that Maya does not really know (at that point) whether she is still in a relationship with Josy or not. The 'long-distance' arrangement has been troubling both of them. Also, Maya believes (wrongly, it turns out) that Josy has 'ghosted' her. Why should Maya have to tell the MC about some ambiguous relationship that she may or may not have with another girl?

Does the MC tell Maya how strong his relationship is with another girl, or even that he has more than a 'crush' on someone else? Hell no, he does not.
 

thedude

Member
Aug 9, 2016
437
694
DrPinkCake could do a lot of things, but he has chosen to make Quinn an important figure in his game. He has his recipe for this game and should be allowed to follow it as he wishes. From the first time that the MC stepped on campus, Quinn has been an integral part of the 'relationship and college life drama'. That was DrPinkCake's choice, and I highly doubt that he will seriously consider eliminating Quinn in the foreseeable future. You might as well ask him to eliminate one of the five main LIs.
I doubt Doc will get rid of Quinn so soon. He seems to like her and she has a very decent number of fans among patrons (myself included). I'm not even sure she'll end up being the villain of this game. Antagonist, no doubt, but a villain? I actually don't think so. So far, there even is a route where the MC can enjoy her services and I don't see any issues between them.

I think she is a red herring. Giving too much atention to her, making her look antagonistic, but after all is said and done she may not end up being the main source of drama. I think the main villain is probably a character that hasn't received as much spotlight.
 
Last edited:

Blablablafapper

Engaged Member
Apr 19, 2019
2,027
7,232
Why should Maya have to tell the MC about some ambiguous relationship that she may or may not have with another girl?
Because MC deserves to know about her already being in a relationship if anything serious is to happen between them. When Maya asks about the date MC had with this "crush" and about having feelings for other people she could have told him about her estranged relationship as a way to open up to him but instead we get interrupted and the game moves on.

MC is single and free to mess with or pursue who ever he so chooses. The option to stay faithful to a single girl is also possible and up to the player. Also the MC doesn't really have "more than a crush" on anyone. He states to Bella that he's still searching for what he really wants (for the player to decided it seems) and find out what love really is. Therefore he doesn't have to tell Maya anything about other girls.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ExDeath730

Mormont

Devoted Member
Nov 30, 2018
11,925
53,076
Having Quinn around as the antagonist is fine and it's fair enough if people don't like her but to write her out of the game would be madness where would the fun be in thwarting her plans, or seeing what she has in store for us next? If say she was to cross that line and in someway hurt a Li then yeah there would be no way back for her and I'd want to be rid of her myself, you take out her we are going to be left with an idiot like Tommy as an antagonist even though we'd have the fun of fucking his sister :p
 

michael1984

Engaged Member
Dec 9, 2017
3,529
9,565
We need to keep Quinn it makes the game a lot more exiting

Eric from Big Brother was a lot worse he had to leave he killed the mood

But Quinn is a lot better I like her actions a lot even tho it does piss me off at times, But she makes the game alot more interesting.

While Eric just killed the mood with his grasp over every women in the game glad he got kicked off.

But Quinn does things but does not take over every girl so lets all keep calm and keep Quinn in this game please.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,527 Votes