I'm gonna risk starting a war here but fuck it. STORY-WISE who do you guys think does a better job: DrPinkCake or PhillyGames? My personal pick would be Philly BUT DPC comes really really really close, both are currently my favorite devs in this site
Philly is great at world building,his creations are really immerssive but I dont care about his characters
DPC`s worlds are standard(so far) but I really care about his characters
I love,thick,rich atmosphere in a story but I also need someone to connect with,so personally I prefer DPC
I 2nd
name88. Philly does better worldbuilding, DPC writes characters better.
I agree with Name88 and M.Sato. A few things to add:
1. Philly's stories are more plot driven while DPC's evolve around character relationships. (Advantage DPC IMO)
2. Philly's MCs are very much
active characters, DPC's MCs are mostly
reactive. i.e Whether it's a Detective or a Ghost, Philly's MC is the one making things happen and pushing the narrative. AL's MC OTOH is basically a refuge, a shoulder to cry on, a cheerleader for
Megan's arc as she rises to stardom and Mel as she tries to break free of her dad. Mostly same in this game. (Advantage Philly IMO).
3. Item 2, in the case of Philly games however, causes something that I personally am not fond of when it comes to AVNs - there is no "Chase." Since the MC is so busy driving the story, there is really only one girl per game
Judy and Katie, respectively where any sort of chase/courtship/seduction is required. The rest just fall into MC's lap
(Carli is a "Hooker", Stella jumps you first time you meet, Chandra/Ellen/Vic all grab the MC for sex pretty much immediately etc.) In contrast, in BaDIK, with more content game time wise - you've actually not had full vaginal with any LI yet - with the half exception of Josy. My personal preference is for the latter style. (Advantage DPC IMO).
They are
both excellent devs but in terms of time spent playing the game, I've spent a lot more hours playing/replaying DPC's games.