- Aug 4, 2017
- 1,146
- 12,721
We know Jill & Bella are best friends, but not Bella's only friend shown in game: she's also friends with Cathy (hence going to Bella's house after that cluck) & formerly Jade/Stephen (they wouldn't have propositioned Bella if they weren't close with her). Bella turned them down, which presumably ended the friendship.First thing is that we know of only one friend Bella has, and that's Jill. Could there be another "friend" that she's referring to? Someone we don't know about? Perhaps, but right now, all we know of is Jill.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
This may also be what Bella is referring to here:
The young student is clearly the MC, who she made out with in Ep 2. Bella wants to distance herself from him for Jill's sake since she's trying to set them up (but continues to fail abysmally on that front thankfully).Ep 3:
isa "(This was for Jill.)"
isa "(Married women don't fool around with young students.)"
isa "(They aren't intimate with friends either...)"
isa "(But that...that was different!)"
isa "(It doesn't matter... I've stopped it.)"
The intimate with friends part could easily refer to the Stephen/Jade proposition, which Bella stopped, causing Bella & Jade to have a falling out.
No? Bella is upset about 'something' Jill is in the loop on, Jill tries to reassure her & gets rebuked for bringing up whatever they have an understanding about. End of actual info.Second thing, the context of that scene in Ep 5 would seem to suggest that this thing that happened that Jill is trying to assure Bella won't happen again is between the 2 of them.
All the staring can simply be put down to Bella being upset & Jill being pensive about how to deal with it. Nothing in this scene says 'it' has anything to do with an intimate encounter between Jill & Bella. Some folks are just projecting what they wish for me thinks.
Given your penchant for theorizing I'm surprised at your lack of imagination in this context?To me, it seems like there's an indication something happened between Bella and Jill and honestly, if this turns out to not be the case, then DPC will have thrown the biggest red herring into this game because it's hard to see what else this could be about.
The most obvious something else would be whatever caused James to disappear, which Jill clearly knows about. This would also explain why Bella tosses James picture during that Bella/Jill bedroom scene.
Or they're talking about the Jade/Stephen proposition, the triangular entanglement blowing up her friendships.
Or a hundred other things - DPC is hardly going to spoil the suspense by giving the players all the facts now is he?
Jade & Bella aren't friends now, but they were obviously close in the past, or they wouldn't have propositioned Bella. Bella putting a stop to that presumably lead to the falling out we see now.I remember that there were discussion prior to Ep 5 about who the "friend" was, and people often pointed to Stephen and Jade and that this was referring to her turning them down, but even at that time I doubted she was referring to them because she certainly does not seem to be friends with them.
Ultimately the best approach, but I fear all hope is lost against all the wild theorizing in this thread.I guess we'll just have to wait and see how things pan out.
Edit: spell good.
Last edited: