Even being offered the choice to "Go see Bella" isn't guaranteed.
There's a counter that weighs up Bella's opinion of the mc, it made up of the following:
- MC tries to kiss Bella in the car (she actually likes that... +1)
- MC offers to pay for Bella's meal (she likes that +1)
- MC is doing OK in class (Bella likes that +1)
- MC is doing really well in class (Bella really likes that +2)
- MC peeked at Bella when she was changing back in ep2 (she doesn't like that -1)
- Beth is angry at the mc for his jokes about the food from either ep1 or ep2 (Bella doesn't like that -1)
- MC is wearing the DIK helmet (Bella doesn't like that -1)
- Troy mentions the fight (whether mc win or loses the fight, Bella really doesn't like that -2)
If the sum of the above conditions is below zero, Bella tells Jill she doesn't like him but he's still better than Tybalt, but that also means your chances with Bella are gone.
Basically if your mc behaves as a DIK (doesn't offer to pay for Bella, fucks around in class, peeks on her changing, wears the helmet and gets into fights), you're gonna be well under the cutoff.
So to me, that choice is far from canon.
To me, there are clear choices to end the relationship at various times. There has to be clear choices, otherwise we get shoehorned into a permanent relationship in the game that we don't want.
- With M&J, regardless of the mc's affinity and if the girls like him, the mc can choose to be just friends with them.
- With Sage the mc can shoot her down numerous times (she is a persistent woman!)
- With Jill you can choose to "Fight for Jill" or not.
- And with Bella you also get the option. Although I felt like I didn't know what I was getting in to when I chose "Go see Bella". Maybe it should have been "Go see Bella to see if you can get into her pants".
But all that bullshit said, my point is I don't feel anything is canon. Everyone has their likes and dislikes, and there are characters and scenes that seem "right" to them. Others disagree. To DPC's credit he has captured characters that resonate with different player's personalities and it makes them feel they are on the right path.
You want the MILF path, Bella is canon. You want the virgin path, Jill is canon. You want the experimental path, it's the throuple for you. You want trouble, it's Quinn. You want hassle free sex and fun, that used to be Sage (now she's complicating things).
I think the game represents all the characters fairly equality, meaning it's the players own interest that tips the scales as to what feels canon, rather than DPC's bias in the presentation.