funkymonkeyjedi

Well-Known Member
Jan 16, 2023
1,848
3,360
The missing documents are not canon, while the intro to chapter 9 is universal
I agree that files going missing aren't a canon event as you put it. But if I'm not mistaken, you only fail that stage because you get caught in the act of trying to steal them (which is part of the canon scene). So it doesn't mean Patrick won't go looking for his daughter regardless.
 

ModiThorrson

Active Member
Jan 1, 2024
560
1,014
Did you miss the "of this render" part of what you quoted? Jill's face isn't in the render so is totally irrelevant, and Bella's body shape problem is worse from the front than the back and the back is all you can see in this render so again is not relevant.

This is the problem with blind simping, people just see a criticism of their favourite waifu and decide they have to argue against it while not paying attention to what the criticism is and then the thread descends back into pointless waifu wars, just like when certain people constantly post simp posts and apparently can't see how that would annoy fans of other characters and people who just dislike the girl they are simping.
:ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:
that's hilarious, people have been bashing maya for like a day straight with no reaction from me. I don't really care that others disagree with me. I was just stating my opinion on a couple of the LIs. I actually really like bella and jill I just don't find them particularly attractive due to their exaggerated proportions.

Maybe you shouldn't take opinions on the internet so seriously.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
13,537
17,824
Maya's by far the worst part of this render, it's kind of funny how she's so far behind the other MGs in attractiveness.
she is my favorite part of the render personally cause other wise just an render full of asses. If I ranked girls purely on attractiveness would go
Zoey , Sage , Nicole , Josy , Camila , Maya , Jill , Rio , Lilly , Sarah/ Mel , Bella , Quinn

Anyone I missed was forgettable to me

List is much different if I go by my favorites Maya is my 3rd favorite
 

ModiThorrson

Active Member
Jan 1, 2024
560
1,014
she is my favorite part of the render personally cause other wise just an render full of asses. If I ranked girls purely on attractiveness would go
Zoey , Sage , Nicole , Josy , Camila , Maya , Jill , Rio , Lilly , Sarah/ Mel , Bella , Quinn

Anyone I missed was forgettable to me
hmm i'm obviously a maya fan so i'd move her up personally but in general i agree with your list. DPC has been wildly inconsistent with sages proportions, so she moves up and down my list a lot. I would move mel up above camilla for me as well but other than that I respect your opinion
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnDelfino

TonyMurray

Engaged Member
Apr 8, 2024
2,954
5,076
she is my favorite part of the render personally cause other wise just an render full of asses. If I ranked girls purely on attractiveness would go
Zoey , Sage , Nicole , Josy , Camila , Maya , Jill , Rio , Lilly , Sarah/ Mel , Bella , Quinn

Anyone I missed was forgettable to me

List is much different if I go by my favorites Maya is my 3rd favorite
I'm slightly dreading doing my ranking for the girls in this game - I'll leave that until I've finished it for some of the other games first.

I'm curious about your ranking of Sarah/Mel though - are they together like that because you consider them as one (but not important enough to be separated like Josy/Maya), or because you consider them separate but equal in looks?
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
13,537
17,824
hmm i'm obviously a maya fan so i'd move her up personally but in general i agree with your list. DPC has been wildly inconsistent with sages proportions, so she moves up and down my list a lot. I would move mel up above camilla for me as well but other than that I respect your opinion
yeah i'm a Maya fan too but that is just on her looks / attractiveness. Maya is my 3rd favorite character in the game and even then im not sure I have a true top 3. Cause whenever I play J&M I want to move Maya to first same with Sage so I say realstically my top 3 is a 3 way tie between Zoey , Sage and Maya

I'm slightly dreading doing my ranking for the girls in this game - I'll leave that until I've finished it for some of the other games first.

I'm curious about your ranking of Sarah/Mel though - are they together like that because you consider them as one (but not important enough to be separated like Josy/Maya), or because you consider them separate but equal in looks?
Well that list is only base off looks not how I feel about them list is much different otherwise. For Example Maya would be 3rd not 6th only. But to answer your question is I only vaguely recall what Sarah / Mel look like without looking up a picture. I always confused which one I think is hotter but I do think they are roughly about the same in hotness if I only go by looks and nothing else. But I do like the one you can ditch class with the most whichever one that is
 
  • Like
Reactions: ModiThorrson

Acsuka

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2023
1,358
2,344
she is my favorite part of the render personally cause other wise just an render full of asses. If I ranked girls purely on attractiveness would go
Zoey , Sage , Nicole , Josy , Camila , Maya , Jill , Rio , Lilly , Sarah/ Mel , Bella , Quinn

Anyone I missed was forgettable to me

List is much different if I go by my favorites Maya is my 3rd favorite
Your list is interesting and of course everyone has different preferences... I would single out just one name from the list: Sarah...
This girl would only be on one of my lists: She wouldn't have to, even if they gave her away for free...
And please don't get mad, this is just my opinion...
 

TonyMurray

Engaged Member
Apr 8, 2024
2,954
5,076
I only vaguely recall what Sarah / Mel look like without looking up a picture. I always confused which one I think is hotter but I do think they are roughly about the same in hotness if I only go by looks and nothing else.
I think it's an interesting one, because they are so different in looks so a lot of people will like one more than the other, at least to some degree. Taste is a weird thing though, it's different for everyone. From what I've seen, I think people seem to like Mel more than Sarah (among those being vocal about it).

I'm massively the other way – Sarah is cute, but Mel doesn't do it for me at all. I think I remember that she has a pretty good body, but I don't like her hair or ink. But then I like Zoey, and although I don't like the ink there either (just a preference against big pieces, particularly in certain locations), she looks good enough overall that it doesn't work against her overall ranking (or not much, at least).
 

godkingxerxes

Engaged Member
Sep 27, 2020
2,210
6,019
I agree that files going missing aren't a canon event as you put it. But if I'm not mistaken, you only fail that stage because you get caught in the act of trying to steal them (which is part of the canon scene). So it doesn't mean Patrick won't go looking for his daughter regardless.
There's a lot of ways to fail it actually, especially as a DIK.

It's a point system anymore than six points and MC doesn't go back in to help.

So if you stick up for Neil at the dinner table you already at two points, if you punch Patrick that puts you in five.

And if you a DIK in episode 7 no matter how nice you are to Patrick he'll still look at you negatively.

So sure as a CHICK you can get it pretty easy, a DIK is more of a challenge, especially if you punch him, on my Sage run I successfully punched him and got the papers though, so that's ace.

Though either way if it's Patrick or James who shows up at Bella's, does it really matter, we're exchanging one dragged out boring plot with another even more boring plot.
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
13,537
17,824
Your list is interesting and of course everyone has different preferences... I would single out just one name from the list: Sarah...
This girl would only be on one of my lists: She wouldn't have to, even if they gave her away for free...
And please don't get mad, this is just my opinion...
no worries and yeah I confuse Mel and Sarah all the time till I look up a picture. I do like one slighty more in terms of character and looks but they are roughly the same to me at least when I only go by looks otherwise yeah I wouldn't of put them together otherwise.

I think it's an interesting one, because they are so different in looks so a lot of people will like one more than the other, at least to some degree. Taste is a weird thing though, it's different for everyone. From what I've seen, I think people seem to like Mel more than Sarah (among those being vocal about it).

I'm massively the other way – Sarah is cute, but Mel doesn't do it for me at all. I think I remember that she has a pretty good body, but I don't like her hair or ink. But then I like Zoey, and although I don't like the ink there either (just a preference against big pieces, particularly in certain locations), she looks good enough overall that it doesn't work against her overall ranking (or not much, at least).
okay I was lazy b4 to look up a picture to remind me what they do look like since I haven't been awake long but this convo got me to look it up. Yeah I do feel the same where Sarah is cute and hotter but not by alot for me compared to the other girls anyways and yeah mel doesn't do it for me either now I looked up a picture. Still prefer Mel over Bella and Quinn in terms of attractiveness however just cause teacher / librarian thing hard for me to over look very rarely im okay with that type of relationship in these games and Quinn's negative personality as well cant overlook that.
 

TonyMurray

Engaged Member
Apr 8, 2024
2,954
5,076
okay I was lazy b4 to look up a picture to remind me what they do look like since I haven't been awake long but this convo got me to look it up. Yeah I do feel the same where Sarah is cute and hotter but not by alot for me compared to the other girls anyways and yeah mel doesn't do it for me either now I looked up a picture. Still prefer Mel over Bella and Quinn in terms of attractiveness however just cause teacher / librarian thing hard for me to over look very rarely im okay with that type of relationship in these games and Quinn's negative personality as well cant overlook that.
Just in case I need to say this, I was generalising, and not at all calling you out on thinking they are equal, or anything like that. I really am surprised at all the hate Sarah gets, as I consider her one of the better-looking girls in the game. I think a lot of it is her character though, and people not separating that out from her looks in these conversations. But again, different people have different tastes as well.

I'm not a Quinn fan in terms of looks (although she has a great body - did I see somewhere that it's Maya's body but with the natural instead of fake tits?) but I would still put her above Mel. Bella... I'm not sure, I'd have to have a proper think about it. They are so different, but Mel and Bella might rank about the same for me because of the things I don't like about them, as opposed to the things I do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Swarovsky7

ModiThorrson

Active Member
Jan 1, 2024
560
1,014
I really am surprised at all the hate Sarah gets, as I consider her one of the better-looking girls in the game.
This kind of surprises me, I don't find her attractive at all. It's not just personality which is extreme bottom of the barrel for me. I think it's mostly the face, and makeup combo, and maybe that she's a bit too thin?
 

Dessolos

Message Maven
Jul 25, 2017
13,537
17,824
Just in case I need to say this, I was generalising, and not at all calling you out on thinking they are equal, or anything like that. I really am surprised at all the hate Sarah gets, as I consider her one of the better-looking girls in the game. I think a lot of it is her character though, and people not separating that out from her looks in these conversations. But again, different people have different tastes as well.

I'm not a Quinn fan in terms of looks (although she has a great body - did I see somewhere that it's Maya's body but with the natural instead of fake tits?) but I would still put her above Mel. Bella... I'm not sure, I'd have to have a proper think about it. They are so different, but Mel and Bella might rank about the same for me because of the things I don't like about them, as opposed to the things I do.
O I know the convo just made me think about it a bit more and was enjoying it is all. Yeah I honestly don't get the hate Sarah gets either tbh. For me she is the "FUN" hot to be around. If she was more than a side girl I can see myself really liking her to be honest as I cant think of one interaction with her I did not like or enjoy.

But what you said about Quinn if I separate by personal thoughts which is hard to do even on a list based only looks. I somewhat agree and somewhat dont agree. Love the body the face with her hair and piercing not so much . I think id find her more attractive even with a negative personality if she had a different hairstyle and hair color as it really just not my cup of tea on her yet fits her personality perfect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TonyMurray
4.80 star(s) 1,598 Votes