felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,403
22,191
Oh well in that case, your only real "official" girlfriend is Jill. You tell your friends, her parents, and make a Cluck about it #HAPPY

The throuple is technically public, but MC spun it as he's dating/fucking them separately while the girls agreed to share him, yet not dating each other. It's a small distinction, but it keeps them from being entirely truthful.

Bella obviously has to hide.

Lily is showing you off as part of her stupid attempt to downplay her feelings as just "rolling", but you aren't actually dating.

Nicole is trying to figure out what you two are, Quinn has caught feelings real bad but still tries to play it cool View attachment 4039214 , Rio is coming around to the idea of a relationship.

As for Sage, you're dating but not official. Still trying to feel it out, but she definitely loves you.
The relationship with Sage is official for everyone except Sage....
 

Macky009

Active Member
Oct 29, 2020
737
676
So as far as I know currently MC can have serious official relationship with: Sage, Maya&Josy, Lily, Jill (?)

First of all, am I missing someone? And second of all, which relationship from these feels the most authentic and real to you guys? As I haven't explored these I am curious.
Sage and Jill for me. You forget Bella
 

Macky009

Active Member
Oct 29, 2020
737
676
Oh well in that case, your only real "official" girlfriend is Jill. You tell your friends, her parents, and make a Cluck about it #HAPPY

The throuple is technically public, but MC spun it as he's dating/fucking them separately while the girls agreed to share him, yet not dating each other. It's a small distinction, but it keeps them from being entirely truthful.

Bella obviously has to hide.

Lily is showing you off as part of her stupid attempt to downplay her feelings as just "rolling", but you aren't actually dating.

Nicole is trying to figure out what you two are, Quinn has caught feelings real bad but still tries to play it cool View attachment 4039214 , Rio is coming around to the idea of a relationship.

As for Sage, you're dating but not official. Still trying to feel it out, but she definitely loves you.
The relationship with Sage is official for everyone except Sage....
I think Sage and MC is technically official especially during the bbq event were they talk about there "relationship" and they declare they are My Guy and My Girl to each other. Also during the beer pong with Sage where she's telling the hots that they can only look but not touch and she's telling that "he is my guy" to the hots
 

Banana4Fun

Newbie
Game Developer
Sep 7, 2024
29
103
Is Lily really a main girl? I thought she was just an "Other". Or maybe shes like the "main girl" of the Others route.
 

MiltonPowers

Conversation Conqueror
Jul 26, 2023
6,000
11,579
Is Lily really a main girl? I thought she was just an "Other". Or maybe shes like the "main girl" of the Others route.
You can do a Lily path or you can do others path without Lily. Or you can do both on same path, because Lily says she doesn't mind who you do it with, (except Becky, you have to wear a condom, hahaha), she really does mind, but won't force you to be exclusive yet. She calls it rollin'.
 

TonyMurray

Well-Known Member
Apr 8, 2024
1,371
2,298
Is Lily really a main girl? I thought she was just an "Other". Or maybe shes like the "main girl" of the Others route.
Kind of this, yeah. She's not a main girl (there's just five - Bella, Jill, Josy, Maya, Sage), but along with Quinn, she's probably got the most story of the "Others" girls and it makes it seem like an official route.
 

shazba jnr

Member
Feb 3, 2024
249
1,928
I don’t really get the vibe that Lily has it bad for the mc. She sees he’s hot property and she wants to use it to her advantage.

She does the same thing when she finds out Quinn is dealing, she gets a better deal for her and the girls. She’s looking out for numero uno. But she’s up front about it, she’s not leading the mc on, she tells Quinn who her previous supplier was.

Shes not bad by any stretch of the imagination, she’s just an opportunist.

I’d rather she have this angle than just another girl who’s fallen head over heels for the mc:
  • Josy: totally in love
  • Maya: in love with being in love
  • Jill: fatefully in love
  • Sage: confusedly in love
  • Bella: stupidly in love
  • Nicole: tentatively in love
  • Quinn: ironically in love
  • Zoey: shitballing in love
  • Riona: just chilling
  • Lily: rolling
Yeah, the whole rolling spiel was kinda cringy, sounded more like some grade school clubhouse bs (other than the fucking, don’t fuck in grade school, kids!) but the gist makes sense. And like I said, it elevated her from the likes of Mel and Sarah who are basically just whores (I’m sorry girls, you’re great and all, but it’s time to stop fucking asking for cash already!), but gives her a unique agenda…

…Ok, yeah, she’s probably in love… :rolleyes:
 

KАRАMBA

Engaged Member
Jan 6, 2021
2,529
8,412
I don’t really get the vibe that Lily has it bad for the mc. She sees he’s hot property and she wants to use it to her advantage.

She does the same thing when she finds out Quinn is dealing, she gets a better deal for her and the girls. She’s looking out for numero uno. But she’s up front about it, she’s not leading the mc on, she tells Quinn who her previous supplier was.

Shes not bad by any stretch of the imagination, she’s just an opportunist.
She's not that simple, and I think she's hiding something. :unsure:
I don't rule out that she's in league with Vinny, and initially wanted to frame Quinn. :cautious:
Poor gullible Quinn didn't notice the sneaky trap. :cry:
Of course, it's all her kindness and responsiveness. :(
Sneaky people always use it. :mad:
 

MilesEdgeworth

Well-Known Member
Nov 8, 2021
1,268
1,638
I kinda like the fact that the relationship with Josy would've had completely different rules if it was just josy as she was legit serious unlike Maya who is still in the testing stage
 

iamcomming

Active Member
Apr 22, 2024
795
537
So as far as I know currently MC can have serious official relationship with: Sage, Maya&Josy, Lily, Jill (?)

First of all, am I missing someone? And second of all, which relationship from these feels the most authentic and real to you guys? As I haven't explored these I am curious.
mc and Lily have not official relationship, only rolling. what looks like for me as an open-relationship, but the relationship part is less, the open part is more
 

Roger-a-Dale

Active Member
May 9, 2024
644
951
So as far as I know currently MC can have serious official relationship with: Sage, Maya&Josy, Lily, Jill (?)

First of all, am I missing someone? And second of all, which relationship from these feels the most authentic and real to you guys? As I haven't explored these I am curious.
It sounds like you're arguing semantics the way you leave Bella out of it. One might also argue that since MC hasn't actually married anyone or even gotten engaged, none of the relationships are official.

I myself measure seriousness by emotional attachment. Having legal documents and telling your friends and family are a long way behind in importance to how you feel about each other and how you spend your time together.

The five main girls Bella, Jill, Sage, Josy and Maya have this edge on all Others: In episode 8 MC will on his own decide that it's wrong to go around fucking other people and he should either fully commit to the relationship or stop leading them on. With the Others he feels no guilt at all. In season 3 the Others do get more serious, but not to the point of the episode 8 choice.

To compare Bella who was left out and Lily who was added: MC is emotionally more committed to Bella on her path than to Lily on the Others path. (This is objectively true MiltonPowers.) This may of course change later on and I certainly hope that the Others relationships get more serious than the MG paths were at episode 8. It is highly unlikely that the Others will ever be neck to neck with the MGs in any episode, but their endings may very well be on an equal footing.

So main girls have more serious relationships than Others, but how serious are they within their respective leagues?

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Which seems most authentic? Well if you allow some adjustment for porn, I'd say Sage, Bella and Jade.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

Lord Bradley

Active Member
May 28, 2019
663
1,508
It sounds like you're arguing semantics the way you leave Bella out of it. One might also argue that since MC hasn't actually married anyone or even gotten engaged, none of the relationships are official.

I myself measure seriousness by emotional attachment. Having legal documents and telling your friends and family are a long way behind in importance to how you feel about each other and how you spend your time together.

The five main girls Bella, Jill, Sage, Josy and Maya have this edge on all Others: In episode 8 MC will on his own decide that it's wrong to go around fucking other people and he should either fully commit to the relationship or stop leading them on. With the Others he feels no guilt at all. In season 3 the Others do get more serious, but not to the point of the episode 8 choice.

To compare Bella who was left out and Lily who was added: MC is emotionally more committed to Bella on her path than to Lily on the Others path. (This is objectively true MiltonPowers.) This may of course change later on and I certainly hope that the Others relationships get more serious than the MG paths were at episode 8. It is highly unlikely that the Others will ever be neck to neck with the MGs in any episode, but their endings may very well be on an equal footing.

So main girls have more serious relationships than Others, but how serious are they within their respective leagues?

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Which seems most authentic? Well if you allow some adjustment for porn, I'd say Sage, Bella and Jade.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
While I appreciate the detailed post, I don't know why you feel like I am arguing anything and overall thew such negative vibe at me. You seem to have taken my post personally for whatever reason. I literally mentioned "as far as i know" and asked if I left anyone out, I don't have any secret agenda to leave Bella out, I have never pursued her and wasn't aware you can be serious with her. As far as Lily inclusion I literally saw a picture of MC and her walk together in school very closely and I knew she had a route, so that was just my assumption that they are indeed a couple now.

Now what I meant by serious official relationship. It wasn't some 200IQ secret formula with hidden refference and secrets of the universe. Some examples of, in my opinion, serious official relationships: Tomy and Heather, John Boy and Elena, Sally and that nerd guy whos name escapes me, Chad and Sage at the start, Dawe and Arieth etc. That is why I didn't include my favorite girl Nicole there since I know you can just date, but it's not publicly known fact you are a couple. You can argue that people with open relationships or cheating spouses or very weak bond between them are not serious couples, but they are couples. It was a simple question and I asked about how players feel about them not made some grand statement.

I am sorry I offended anyone with my apparently very rude and stupid post, I will just stick to fawning over Nicole and write a poem once in a blue moon. Will leave the extremely complex relationship discussions of this game to professionals.
 
Last edited:

bZokko1

Newbie
Feb 2, 2019
42
59
It sounds like you're arguing semantics the way you leave Bella out of it. One might also argue that since MC hasn't actually married anyone or even gotten engaged, none of the relationships are official.

I myself measure seriousness by emotional attachment. Having legal documents and telling your friends and family are a long way behind in importance to how you feel about each other and how you spend your time together.

The five main girls Bella, Jill, Sage, Josy and Maya have this edge on all Others: In episode 8 MC will on his own decide that it's wrong to go around fucking other people and he should either fully commit to the relationship or stop leading them on. With the Others he feels no guilt at all. In season 3 the Others do get more serious, but not to the point of the episode 8 choice.

To compare Bella who was left out and Lily who was added: MC is emotionally more committed to Bella on her path than to Lily on the Others path. (This is objectively true MiltonPowers.) This may of course change later on and I certainly hope that the Others relationships get more serious than the MG paths were at episode 8. It is highly unlikely that the Others will ever be neck to neck with the MGs in any episode, but their endings may very well be on an equal footing.

So main girls have more serious relationships than Others, but how serious are they within their respective leagues?

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Which seems most authentic? Well if you allow some adjustment for porn, I'd say Sage, Bella and Jade.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Agree with you, but one thing I noticed in my mega DIK Bella path; was how Quinn reacted when you told her the reason you were not looking at her so much at the party.
She took it well at the surface level, but clearly was hurt by it. Felt believable enough.

This also has potential, because Quinn has been in the background noticing you and Bella interactions. In the cafeteria and library at least. Makes me wonder about the broken look she has in the early previews. Is this on all Quinn paths or only if you shoot her down with Sage or Bella? So her background and situation is perhaps not the most authentic, but her interaction with MC is. (y)



Choose your Yoga Girl :cool:

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Camila > Melanie > Heather :cool:
 

Darkwen

Forum Fanatic
Nov 10, 2020
5,230
11,432
Agree with you, but one thing I noticed in my mega DIK Bella path; was how Quinn reacted when you told her the reason you were not looking at her so much at the party.
She took it well at the surface level, but clearly was hurt by it. Felt believable enough.

This also has potential, because Quinn has been in the background noticing you and Bella interactions. In the cafeteria and library at least. Makes me wonder about the broken look she has in the early previews. Is this on all Quinn paths or only if you shoot her down with Sage or Bella? So her background and situation is perhaps not the most authentic, but her interaction with MC is. (y)




Camila > Melanie > Heather :cool:
Josy>Bella>Yoga Girl
 
4.80 star(s) 1,562 Votes