Darkmetal

Well-Known Member
Jul 6, 2019
1,102
14,268
Re: Bella - Jill

- Good friend
- Older step sister
- Favorite aunt
- Her (favorite) babysitter

Occam's razor says one of the above. However, in addition to that ...

The more interesting picture (for me) is Bella's sad expression when the MC says "It's not like she's your daughter or anything"

Belladowncast.jpg

My guess is this:
It was not Jill's father that failed her, like many here have posted, it was her mother that was useless. In the end, it was Bella that had to protect and guide her and become almost a surrogate mom for Jill while she was growing up.
 

Moryaka26

Member
Aug 28, 2019
398
761
The best thoery I still like is a close family babysitter or she became her Guardian/Godmother.

As long as it isn't some step family or niece/aunt thing we see too many times in these games, I'm good.

The Mother theory tho plausible seems a big surprise since DPC by all accounts doesn't want any incest in his games and he has pics of them together.
Maybe Bella was librarian in the Jill's hight school ?
 

sloppy gonzo

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2018
1,396
5,063
Re: Bella - Jill

- Good friend
- Older step sister
- Favorite aunt
- Her (favorite) babysitter

Occam's razor says one of the above. However, in addition to that ...

The more interesting picture (for me) is Bella's sad expression when the MC says "It's not like she's your daughter or anything"

View attachment 425405

My guess is this:
It was not Jill's father that failed her, like many here have posted, it was her mother that was useless. In the end, it was Bella that had to protect and guide her and become almost a surrogate mom for Jill while she was growing up.
As long as she isn't her teen mum who hasn't told Jill she's adopted (to a rich family) and her true biological mother, that's why she was so sad and kept close with Jill by being a family friend/babysitter.....

:unsure:
 

Darkmetal

Well-Known Member
Jul 6, 2019
1,102
14,268
As long as she isn't her teen mum who hasn't told Jill she's adopted (to a rich family) and her true biological mother, that's why she was so sad and kept close with Jill by being a family friend/babysitter.....

:unsure:
On that, I posted this possibility a while back,

"there is the slim possibility that Bella had Jill when she was underage and was forced to give up the baby to be raised by her older sister and her rich husband. (This would also account for Bella's past trauma and why Jill doesn't know that Bella is in fact her mother.) "

but like you I prefer them not to be related, and hope it's not going to be accurate :p
 

Moryaka26

Member
Aug 28, 2019
398
761
On that, I posted this possibility a while back,

"there is the slim possibility that Bella had Jill when she was underage and was forced to give up the baby to be raised by her older sister and her rich husband. (This would also account for Bella's past trauma and why Jill doesn't know that Bella is in fact her mother.) "

but like you I prefer them not to be related, and hope it's not going to be accurate :p
Jill and Bella havent blood conection
 

CynicalBstrd

Newbie
Feb 10, 2018
17
38
The whole picture thing we should be asking why she has a pic of Bella? who is she to her are they related in some way.
I think that in the photo on the right are bella and the mother of Jill because the resemblance with Jill is very remarkable. So what is the relationship between Bella and Jill mother? I don't know but maybe Bella is the grand daughter of jill mother (so jill mother is the aunt of Bella) or they are family friends. We'll see.
 

Mormont

Devoted Member
Nov 30, 2018
11,926
53,093
I think that in the photo on the right are bella and the mother of Jill because the resemblance with Jill is very remarkable. So what is the relationship between Bella and Jill mother? I don't know but maybe Bella is the grand daughter of jill mother (so jill mother is the aunt of Bella) or they are family friends. We'll see.
Perhaps Bella was a close friend of Jill's mother something maybe happened to her and Bella promised she would look after Jill. I do feel as though Bella has a sort of maternal instinct towards Jill but then again it could also be like a sisterly bond they have as well.
 

icesun

Be nice! Until it's time to not be nice...
Former Staff
Nov 2, 2018
911
2,420
Perhaps Bella was a close friend of Jill's mother something maybe happened to her and Bella promised she would look after Jill. I do feel as though Bella has a sort of maternal instinct towards Jill but then again it could also be like a sisterly bond they have as well.
I'll just quote me from a while back to say: I agree...
I think it's more of a "Jill's mother passed away, Bella was her best friend and promised to take care of her" thingy...

...and to add on that: The stuff Jill played on the piano is somehow connected to her mom, that's why she's so vulnerable at that moment...
 

Wizard_Shiryuu

Engaged Member
Sep 6, 2019
2,794
6,022
I think we shouldn't pay much attention to look alikes. In AL I spent most of the game thinking two characters were related and they weren't.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
There is no way two characters have TWO moles in the exact same positions that way and not be related. And yet... they weren't. So I wouldn't pay much attention to those photos either.
 
4.80 star(s) 1,573 Votes