Yeah, that's not what a plot hole is. And no, the MC didn't cheat on anybody. You can't cheat if you're not in a relationship
. Josy and Maya did cheat on each other and forgave each other too easily, that's something I have a problem with. But the MC didn't cheat, and you get the option to tell both J&M you're fooling around with other girls (or not). Where's the cheating there?
The MC is not engaged with one of the girls so he hasn't cheat. He can date others(on one of my playthrough i avoided the sex with Josy because the MC wanted something serious and was waiting for Josy to break up with her "boyfriend". If you play the "casanova" path he overacted and can admit it during a dialogue. This is called role-play). The cheaters are both Maya and Josy.
Exactly, this was my take on the drama. I felt like many people just looked the issue objectively without putting themselves in the MC's shoes. There are multiple paths to play and you choose what kind of a MC you are. Let me give a example from my first playthrough of how I choose to act and why MC's reaction were normal.
Mind you, in my playthrough I was faithful to both of them, first Josy, then Maya when I gave up on Josy. I even eat the fucking condom at the cumpetition, you can guess my commitment lol. (I really hated DIKs at earlier parts of the story)
So I obviously turned down every optional choice that gets closer with other girls.
Only with forced stuff in the story, MC does not deserve to be put aside in my opinion. Their rejection of MC is outright stupid, and polygamy stuff is so forced, it is just the usual VN fantasy of long term threesomes, at least at the moment.
So with all that and the fact that MC is a teenager, he had only one partner in his past that he had a romantic relationship, he has a right to feel betrayed. It might not be morally or logically right or justified as MC has its faults, yet still in the perspective of MC, who tried to open up to a woman at first, gets semi-rejected but still she clung onto him, and the second woman who meant a lot to him, keeping such a big secret fucks the head of the MC. Two people he were emotionally invested in turns out they are together without telling MC. They hurt MC's feelings.
So maybe MC did not do the perfect reaction to their revelation, but it is normal, MC is human just like them. No one can have a perfect response in a delicate situation like this.
Apologies for the wall of text, site was down so I had time to write some stuff. And the guy who attacked almost everyone last night triggered me
