Come on man. The most realistic girl you can meet in real life is Josy. It is Josy who is an ordinary, simpleton, friendly neighbor who is easy to communicate with and has a minimum of drama. Also, Josy is not a stereotypical collective image that is presented in the game:
Sage: The most popular girl in school, a hot cheerleader but with a rich inner world, beautiful, smart and with a big heart
Maya: Damsel in distress
Quinn: Bad girl, tsundere
Jill: Typical Disney Princess
Bella: Favorite MILF
Josy is odrinary
If I want an ordinary girl in this game - I choose Josy
If I want a good girl, I choose Maya
But my favorite you can see on my signature