Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,866
43,798
from the very start with ep1, Josy isn't even there at that point and won't be for at least another week. Sure that isn't a long time but it better then nothing yet she put all her faith in joining a sorority to save her to make it worse ep11 solve it in one night added there some other factors too
Such determination in solving her problems is enviable. But being in an emotionally vulnerable position, Maya easily succumbed to Quinn's prank (which by the way was not a prank, free tuition was real through Burke's bed). Quinn probably denied Maya from it, realizing later that she was not restaurant material, but still used it as a dirty joke. Wasn't the best of her ideas, the restaurant closed because of it :ROFLMAO:
 

Valithor

Newbie
May 2, 2017
50
36
Important thing to note about Maya and Josy is that they are still freshman, straight out of highschool. It shouldn't be surprising that they can seem immature when compared with Jill/Sage who are in their last year (not sure about Jill) or Bella who is twice their age. It shouldn't be a surprise that those characters have better defined goals and personalities, a lot of freshman don't know what they want to do about themselves and their lives.
I feel Josy's arc works well for some ppl (albeit i did not play her route) and that's the beauty of this game, that you have varied deep characters which will speak to different ppl.
 

Darkwen

Forum Fanatic
Nov 10, 2020
5,710
11,915
Such determination in solving her problems is enviable. But being in an emotionally vulnerable position, Maya easily succumbed to Quinn's prank (which by the way was not a prank, free tuition was real through Burke's bed). Quinn probably denied Maya from it, realizing later that she was not restaurant material, but still used it as a dirty joke. Wasn't the best of her ideas, the restaurant closed because of it :ROFLMAO:
if she didn't put all her eggs in one basket would had made her look better to me anyway, thankful as Sage and a wise crazy simp once said Josy was the mastermind that got it done;)
 

Hahn1900

Well-Known Member
Jan 3, 2021
1,603
3,495
It shouldn't be surprising that they can seem immature when compared with Jill/Sage who are in their last year (not sure about Jill)
Sage is the only one (relevant) that is graduating. Jill started her third year and will have another one.

Though... it doesnt really matter for the game.

And just for the sake of it, Sage is 22, Jill 21. Josy, Maya, MC are 19.

But as i said, not really important, the game will not go on after the first semester anyways, Most likely Spring Break will be the end.

Besides... immature age related? Is not a age thing. I knew people who were 14 and more mature than people at the age of 40. In that regard, age doesnt mean shit and never will.
 
  • Like
Reactions: treechild1

Geralt From Rivia

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 15, 2022
6,866
43,798
if she didn't put all her eggs in one basket would had made her look better to me anyway, thankful as Sage and a wise crazy simp once said Josy was the mastermind that got it done;)
And she almost ratted out MC to Sage when she almost let slip where she got the idea from. Girl should be able to keep her mouth shut. :p
 

Valithor

Newbie
May 2, 2017
50
36
Sage is the only one (relevant) that is graduating. Jill started her third year and will have another one.

Though... it doesnt really matter for the game.

And just for the sake of it, Sage is 22, Jill 21. Josy, Maya, MC are 19.

But as i said, not really important, the game will not go on after the first semester anyways, Most likely Spring Break will be the end.

Besides... immature age related? Is not a age thing. I knew people who were 14 and more mature than people at the age of 40. In that regard, age doesnt mean shit and never will.
Obviously maturity is impacted by other things than age, but age plays a part here. Maturity is highly impacted by previous life experiences, so the more rocky childhood you've had the more mature you'll turn out (that's another simplification, coz every trauma can develop you in multiple directions, but I'm trying to keep it simple). If we take 19 yo Quinn vs 19 yo J/M for sure Quinn would handle her shit better, but that's the thing I've had in mind.
If I were to compare maturity of Maya vs Josy id it depends on aspect which you compare them in, but overall id favor Maya coz she's got her goals clearly set, but her goals come from what I've surfaced earlier - tough childhood. If you take Josy you'll get an easy going girl, who never had too much spotlight, but everyone liked her, she had a happy life w/o many troubles (iirc the divorce thing happens shortly before story of the game), so it's not surprising that when problems start piling up (like aforementioned divorce) she doesn't know how to handle them.
My post was a generalization and included this unspoken assessment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ksuha and Vill3m
4.70 star(s) 1,632 Votes