Baka plays

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Aug 31, 2017
2,533
5,501
We're not discussing dialogue, but a concept. Please don't twist what I'm saying. Having morning expositional breakfast does nothing to further the idea that this is an actual family, rather than a bunch pretending to care for each other. In fact the scene where Ann is cooking with no clothes other than an apron is much more realistic in terms of closeness, inappropriate attire aside.
it would be cheap, yes, but the game doesn´t position the family members at any time this much close to each other than breakfast. It´s only logical to exposition the story with bonding time at this time. And people do talk about all kind of things when eating, from the most mundane to the most problematic themes.
So, as a more or less professional writer, putting into context that this is a porn game, it doesn´t need structure or dialogue like a Tolstoi book.
And the naked apron scene is a hidden one and not real part of the plot, it´s just implemented fanservice.
 

armion82

Devoted Member
Mar 28, 2017
11,977
16,097
Not in the game must be some fan art and put a spoiler on that pic
Actualy some pics are in the early version of the game like 0.1,0.2 and 0.3 but after that DS change them or didn't use them anymore.Like this one you can only find it in 0.1
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

elmandor

Active Member
Respected User
Mar 6, 2017
954
2,999
Actualy some pics are in the early version of the game like 0.1,0.2 and 0.3 but after that DS change them or didn't use them anymore.Like this one you can only find it in 0.1
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Are you archiving everything or you know where to find them? Because I'm impressed
 
Last edited:

Asphyx

Well-Known Member
Jun 11, 2017
1,148
1,181
While family dynamics like that can exist, the only way they'd lead to incest in the real world is if the mother was the instigator of it all.
Not entirely true...The Mother merely needs to be somewhat open to the idea of looking at her son in a sexual way. And in many cases it is the son's instigation, which makes her think about the subject in the first place.
Finding mature porn on his computer, Finding her panties in his room and catching him peeking at her naked (similar to how Max has done) are all instigations from the Son that cue the mother into realizing there may be a sexual attraction to her on the part of her son.
You are correct however that for the relationship to be consummated, the Mother will have to be the one to agree in order for it to be consensual. Instigation merely brings up the subject. that instigation is the breaking of the Ice that shows both parties there is sexual interest. Mother has to be on board with it to be consensual but she does not have to be the one that suggests it from the beginning. Most mothers would never bring up the subject until they were fully convinced the Son wanted that kind of relationship.
 

Asphyx

Well-Known Member
Jun 11, 2017
1,148
1,181
I think this is the result of skewed views on family dynamics. He apparently has a singular idea on what they can be like and that's that. This results in his inability to understand how incest can arise from normal relationships without someone being coerced into it.
Well this is why I have always said that DS made an Incest game for the Marketing value not because of any interest on his part for the Incest Genre.
I don't even think he likes the Genre at all which is why it is as dark as it is. He can't see a situation where Incest is consensual. And it doesn't seem to be a turn on kink for him at all. It's just that all the best supported games are Incest related so he decided to jump on that money train and made a game based on the only way he can imagine incest ever happening.
He should read the incest sub on Reddit and look at what those stories do. Real or not (and who can say for sure which is which) at least he would see what variety and romance there can be in a family situation.

Instead of worrying about being believable he should have spent more effort into making it EROTIC!
 

Baka plays

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Aug 31, 2017
2,533
5,501
Not entirely true...The Mother merely needs to be somewhat open to the idea of looking at her son in a sexual way. And in many cases it is the son's instigation, which makes her think about the subject in the first place.
Finding mature porn on his computer, Finding her panties in his room and catching him peeking at her naked (similar to how Max has done) are all instigations from the Son that cue the mother into realizing there may be a sexual attraction to her on the part of her son.
You are correct however that for the relationship to be consummated, the Mother will have to be the one to agree in order for it to be consensual. Instigation merely brings up the subject. that instigation is the breaking of the Ice that shows both parties there is sexual interest. Mother has to be on board with it to be consensual but she does not have to be the one that suggests it from the beginning. Most mothers would never bring up the subject until they were fully convinced the Son wanted that kind of relationship.
some interesting stuff i found


 
  • Like
Reactions: Asphyx

Ignazzio

Engaged Member
Donor
May 8, 2017
2,891
3,300
Instead of worrying about being believable he should have spent more effort into making it EROTIC!
But the case is if he could achieve such a success if his game wasn't so believable at early stages. I doubt it. Way too many of similiar concepts around
 

Blades1138

Active Member
Jul 29, 2017
539
1,140
it would be cheap, yes, but the game doesn´t position the family members at any time this much close to each other than breakfast. It´s only logical to exposition the story with bonding time at this time. And people do talk about all kind of things when eating, from the most mundane to the most problematic themes.
So, as a more or less professional writer, putting into context that this is a porn game, it doesn´t need structure or dialogue like a Tolstoi book.
And the naked apron scene is a hidden one and not real part of the plot, it´s just implemented fanservice.
If I, as a layman, can imagine a better way to do it, then why can't the person supposedly intent on making the best erotic game on the market ? Again, not talking about finer dialogue details but overall presentation and atmosphere. As it is now, we have several people doing their own thing, simply being roommates for the most part.

Not entirely true...The Mother merely needs to be somewhat open to the idea of looking at her son in a sexual way.
Talking about engaging the whole family in it, not just the son. The game isn't just about Max and Ann after all.
 
N

netkeliye

Guest
Guest
some interesting stuff i found


Seriously though all these research are just motivated by someone's personal agenda(My personal opinion)
@baraka do you really think this is legit research
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Baka plays

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Aug 31, 2017
2,533
5,501
If I, as a layman, can imagine a better way to do it, then why can't the person supposedly intent on making the best erotic game on the market ? Again, not talking about finer dialogue details but overall presentation and atmosphere. As it is now, we have several people doing their own thing, simply being roommates for the most part.


Talking about engaging the whole family in it, not just the son. The game isn't just about Max and Ann after all.
well, there´s a difference between "I can imagine to do better" and actually "being better". And since you´ve shown not much expertise in terms of writing , i highly doubt that. It´s always easy to say, i can do better when other ppl have done all the work. But feel free to convince me otherwise.
Yes, the characters are more behaving like isolated islands rather than ppl, we already established that a long time ago in this thread. Personally i don´t think it´s the best game on the erotica market. There´s Dreaming of Dana and Dreams of Desire, handling plot+structure much better than BB. Ppl don´t always do reasonable things, i like the more realistic looking graphics the most(no DDD Tits and ridiculous Ass curves)
 

christopher thompson

Active Member
Jun 12, 2017
903
5,493
Have just cancelled my Patreon with Dark Silver, game is dragging out, all sex scenes are the same and to me it seems he isn’t listening to his followers as I am sure he released a poll a couple of months back asking if he wanted more characters added to which everyone said no, but low and behold after this version it seems there will be a 2nd new character, don’ Get me wrong I still like the game but don’t seem the need to pay someone who doesn’t listen to his providers
 
  • Like
Reactions: AkitoH
3.40 star(s) 107 Votes