- Oct 24, 2018
- 3,155
- 21,962
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,822
- 17,844
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,822
- 17,844
So if you had an option to pick Jaye, Tara, Jill and Jeane, you'd pick Jill every time?
No offense but I find that train of thought ridiculous.
It's just a topic of discussion. I don't have any issues with it (nor do I think felicemastronzo and WICKEDp4th have issues with it), I've said it many times before - I don't care if Jaye is a virgin or not. I'd still pick her every time.
No one's throwing a tantrum. It's just a conversation about the LI's and their past. I don't see how you got that impression.
It's an issue with all AVN's anyway. The MC has to be the best at everything, the most liked guy and the one who's always right and whenever he loses/makes mistakes it isn't of his own accord, but due to circumstances that aren't in his control.
I think Chasing Sunsets does well to avoid that trope. We've already seen Alex make mistakes and cause things to go wrong, due to his actions. We've also seen him be vulnerable and be overwhelmed with guilt because of his actions. I think it's good writing in terms of personality and characterization.
It seems that Jaye already knew at the end of the Prologue who she loved and who she wanted to be with. It's the circumstances and the misunderstanding of the subsequent events that followed that lead to the breakdown of the relationship with the MC.
Jaye was presented as fiery, impulsive, stubborn, independent and incredibly headstrong. She doesn't like it when people stick their noses in her business (as was shown with the girl that got punched in the throat and the MC at her graduation party).
If she's virgin or not at this point is irrelevant, the point is that she wanted to save herself for the MC. She loved him more than anyone else at that point, though she might not have realized it. Perhaps she discovered those feelings after MC ran away and the feelings overwhelmed her.
Mallory on the other point as personality and presentation is heavily contrasting to Jaye. Some people perceive Mallory as a pity case and that's wrong IMO. Mallory, while reserved and shy, is still capable of doing incredibly daring actions. We learn that she had bad experiences before (that she's a Sarah clone in an entirely different matter). Mallory though, IMO, does suffer from not being as clearly defined as Jaye for example. I feel, personally, that I understand Jaye better, while at times I do scratch my head at things Mallory says or does.
Let me state this for the record, I don't think Mallory is a badly written character at all. I guess that the devs wanted to leave that feeling of mystique and make us wonder about her more.
So you could say that with Jaye, you practically play with open cards while with Mallory, not all cards are still revealed and there's still to come.
- May 17, 2020
- 11,123
- 21,761
Why Jill?So if you had an option to pick Jaye, Tara, Jill and Jeane, you'd pick Jill every time?
No offense but I find that train of thought ridiculous.
Jill is a virgin for her own sake, Jaye is only a virgin because of the MC, they are two different situations. Wanting Jill is more like Mallory, not Jaye
Jaye gives a huge show of affection, love call it what you will, to MC. Mc could tell her she fucked up? While he for his part enjoyed life? Really?
Blackmail is too strong a term, but it's a confession (pretty useless as you say) that puts a huge weight on MC's decision
P. S. Jeane even against the other three put together
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,822
- 17,844
I put Jill in there because she was the only LI that I can thinking of that was saving herself for someone, while her situation isn't exactly like Jaye's. That's why I said in the last paragraph that Jaye was incredibly headstrong - she knew who and what she wanted.
The rocky start of the relationship again can be attributed to both of them being tentative and careful not to screw up again. They already realized their feelings for each other and know what they want.
Besides your decision shouldn't be based on if Jaye waited or not. The MC certainly doesn't know it when he's away that's why he was surprised when Jaye told him no when he asked about others.
And to answer my own question - Jaye without even thinking about it. I'd pick the Goddess everytime.
But isn't it weird that a woman that can be described as fiery, impulsive, stubborn, independent and incredibly headstrong has weird hangups about purity? Let's be honest, Jaye being a virgin is porn logic entirely. On the other hand the PC's purity doesn't matter to her and in the end she'll probably happily share him with Mallory depending on our choices.
There's nothing wrong with porn logic in a porn game, but from a story telling perspective it's a little meh.
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,822
- 17,844
It can be attributed to her personality, though. It's something that she has chosen based on her feelings for the MC. Morally right isn't the right word I was looking for, but I guess it can be used to describe Jaye. That doesn't mean she's completely virtuous though, as she's shown that she's prone to wrath.
That's why I've said it that the devs did an amazing job in writing the characters. Like there are no perfect and flawless characters in the game.
maybe she intimidated guys cause of her personality, maybe she perceived them as beneath her, her virginity can be explained in various ways
- May 17, 2020
- 11,123
- 21,761
But does the fact that Jaye waited in sexual abstinence (and not as an assumption but as an explicit statement) mc add anything positive to the character?
In my opinion no, it gives her at most a disturbing nuance
And those for whom it is very important news scare me a bit
- May 17, 2020
- 11,123
- 21,761
It is Jaye who tells us this, why should we not believe her?
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,822
- 17,844
Here’s the thing though - is that her defining character trait? Is that the first thing to come to your mind when someone mentions Jaye?
If your answer to both questions is yes, then cool, but I don’t think you understanded the character very well.
Besides, it’s not something that’s overbearingly important, it’s just a detail of her past.
It’s not like it’s something that she mentions every time she talks with the MC.
- May 17, 2020
- 11,123
- 21,761
It is the second moment of intimate confession between the two, which effectively starts their relationship. It may not be fundamental but you cannot consider it unimportant either...
i was addressing that person's complaint who believes a fiery girl can't be a virgin, according to him it's weird & unrealistic, i simply presented a few scenarios where such a thing can happen.
- Jan 20, 2022
- 707
- 17,406
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,822
- 17,844
Okay, maybe unimportant wasn’t the right word to use in that sentence.
It’s significant, but not like a critical part of her character would be the more appropriate way to describe it.
Like if you learned if she was in a relationship with someone else while the MC, would that diminish her value in your eyes?
- May 17, 2020
- 11,123
- 21,761
No, but the point in fact that she has not to tell anything, she had her life as MC. It would be uninportant, but if she wanted to tell that became significant
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,822
- 17,844
Since the words came out of her mouth, it became a part of her character. So what, I don't see a problem with it. Why is it such a big deal anyway?
- Oct 24, 2018
- 3,155
- 21,962
- Mar 29, 2019
- 2,822
- 17,844
You have no heart.Because it makes me feel bad when I dump her
Apparently all of you need to learn to appreciate the Goddess.
- May 17, 2020
- 11,123
- 21,761
Don't be a fanboy....
Jaye waited 5 years illibate her brother/lover, that is creepy for me, or any way not positive
At the first date with a long time crush do you ask how many partners she had? I don't, and if she answer she waited for me i would find that creepy
I should forget that moment