Don't take a shower and say you did, that's what lying is about...
I know
But as i said before, it doesn't work. But the reason might be the one given by Le Pew. I've wait for the last minute (every other quest finished) to start the Susan's Sacrifice quest, because I'm not really into Femd.
So it seems like after Amy arrival, it is too late to start this quest.
Did you start Susan's Femdom events after Amy's arrival ? I did that and I was in the same situation. I had to restart almost the whole game to have it correctly, because the dialogue paths change after Amy arrives and you don't get the shower scene anymore.
You're perfectly right. I was afraid it was something like this. I always find it easy to avoid punishment and Femdom isn't really my thing, that is why I start it at the end, just to get the 100%. I guess it is to late.
I've just restart the game yesterday before my old save wasn't working any more, so I don't feel like doing it once again, I think I will just give up and hope that by turning of the Femdom, I will not miss too much content.
Thank, at least I know where the problem is. If I have more motivation in a few weeks or month, maybe I will restart from my save before Amy arrival.