VN Ren'Py Completed Dating My Daughter [Ch. 1-4 v1.01] [MrDots Games]

[WätSûp B8tch]

I do not think we are ever going to agree, you want to make it a multiple protag game at best, but do have a look at my edit. I think we will have to agree to disagree. To me it is a game all about the father and the daughter is just there to help his story and it is not her story. Now like I said in my edit, that game with D as protagonist with all your arguments and analysis in your original post might have made an even more interesting game.

Well idk how they can think about F agreeing to have his daughter in threesome circle specially if it is about MMF I mean on his watch rests is on D since she can make her own decisions and has the right to go against fathers wish...but then again you know how weird it's gonna be and it's probably gonna end up them going their separate ways in life...I am talking about this from fathers point of perspective as someone who is in his right mind would never want their daughter's to take those paths never...idk how young is the F but I'll assume him to be atleast as young and good looking as one of his friends who appeared as a waiter once, I forgot which chapter he appeared on but it did happened...If I remember it correctly he was looking like someone who would be in his 35 or so...but that grahm guy looks old and Olivia will be atleast in her 30's or so I guess it somewhow make sense that grahm somehow/anyhow allowed her daughter to do what she wants with F I mean it still doesn't make sense but I guess he felt some common ground between F and himself about their circumstances and it was one time thing or was suppose to be according to Olivia...but yeah grahm made it clear that he is not interested in D in such a way...and the weirdest will be anything with F's work mate route what his name again I forgot...oh well..all I wanna say is that's the least making sense path this VN can have....I stopped at chapter 2 because it was really getting overboard with all the not making sense paths...I guess it was not suppose to take that turn in the beginning but I guess more people are supportive and onto having a path which consists of d with f's workmate or mmf with D route...which I guess got this VN to where it stands today.

 

[Trikus]

Well don't take this too hard...yeah this is an incest VN but now you tell me...this was suppose to be from fathers point of perspective but yeah no denying that D has her own life she can make her own choices but father making her daughter involve in such events is unthinkable... specially mmf...if you were a father and had a dauther would you ever share your own statement...I feel awe by people's weird nature's of speaking without giving a proper thinking but it's okay everyone has their own rights to keep their mentality the way they want...but this just doesn't make sense.

What you are doing is applying your thoughts and preferences onto someone else. You might not want to share your daughter, in fact, would you even develop a sexual relationship with your daughter? Probably not, am I right? This is a work of fiction. The MC has always checked with D if she wants to do something. If she does, he supports her. He isn't possessive of her. This caveman view of "She is mine, nobody elses, but I can screw around with everyone" is not shared by the character in this story. The idea of the MC helping his daughter open up and blossom is one that has been there since the VN started and not something that just happened in Chapter 3. Technically D is already guilty of mmf sharing in Chapter 1 as she already has a boyfriend, though they haven't done anything sexual.

 

[WätSûp B8tch]

Well I broke his binocular along with his 2 peeking eyeballs...

Technically, F allowed the beach binocular guy to spy on D at the beach

 

[WätSûp B8tch]

Well th

What you are doing is applying your thoughts and preferences onto someone else. You might not want to share your daughter, in fact, would you even develop a sexual relationship with your daughter? Probably not, am I right? This is a work of fiction. The MC has always checked with D if she wants to do something. If she does, he supports her. He isn't possessive of her. This caveman view of "She is mine, nobody elses, but I can screw around with everyone" is not shared by the character in this story. The idea of the MC helping his daughter open up and blossom is one that has been there since the VN started and not something that just happened in Chapter 3. Technically D is already guilty of mmf sharing in Chapter 1 as she already has a boyfriend, though they haven't done anything sexual.

that's the thing...it was forced unwanted relationship and hense nothing happened wouldn't have minded if she had already been in forced sex which would open up a nice route where she is afraid of sexual act and father slowly making her open up to him...but it didn't happen...and again this is VN and also an incest...even though it is an VN it still has a father in it which leads to existing of father insights...which in my textbook automatically leads to father disagreeing with his daughter with her going for such acts like MMF(well she can do it behind fathers knowledge which is highly unlikely for the time being)...and such it is what it is and again I don't think anyone who would be in his right mind would want their daughter's to take those paths in life ofcourse never complained about finding out a nice guy who would be close in her age like that photographer guy...but seriously it just seems like fetish met overdosed.


Edit;And I am not talking about anything else out of this VN.

 

[yltohawk]

W

Well don't take this too hard...yeah this is an incest VN but now you tell me...this was suppose to be from fathers point of perspective but yeah no denying that D has her own life she can make her own choices but father making her daughter involve in such events is unthinkable... specially mmf...if you were a father and had a dauther would you ever share your own statement...I feel awe by people's weird nature's of speaking without giving a proper thinking but it's okay everyone has their own rights to keep their mentality the way they want...but this just doesn't make sense.

Edit; Sorry it was suppose to be for the the guy who commented above you.

Look... All the father is trying to do is widen the social circles of his daughter

 

[Trikus]

Well th

that's the thing...it was forced unwanted relationship and hense nothing happened wouldn't have minded if she had already been in forced sex which would open up a nice route where she is afraid of sexual act and father slowly making her open up to him...but it didn't happen...and again this is VN and also an incest...even though it is an VN it still has a father in it which leads to existing of father insights...which in my textbook automatically leads to father disagreeing with his daughter with her going for such acts like MMF(well she can do it behind fathers knowledge which is highly unlikely for the time being)...and such it is what it is and again I don't think anyone who would be in his right mind would want their daughter's to take those paths in life ofcourse never complained about finding out a nice guy who would be close in her age like that photographer guy...but seriously it just seems like fetish met overdosed.

Nothing is forced though. You get options to share and if you don't want to, you can easily say no to all sharing options. D doesn't mention her attraction to Ryan if you aren't on the Margo sharing path. In fact, she says she isn't interested in Margo and Ryan if you aren't on the path. She doesn't have the dream about Martin unless you chose the correct dialogue in Chapter 1 either. Also, at no point in the game have I ever seen "based on a true story" being applied to this game. Just because you cannot imagine something, doesn't mean everyone is the same as you. The developer wants the sharing options but understands there are people like yourself who don't want it so gave the options to reject any and all sharing paths. Don't like it, why choose this game?

 

[DA22]

Nothing is forced though. You get options to share and if you don't want to, you can easily say no to all sharing options. D doesn't mention her attraction to Ryan if you aren't on the Margo sharing path. In fact, she says she isn't interested in Margo and Ryan if you aren't on the path. She doesn't have the dream about Martin unless you chose the correct dialogue in Chapter 1 either. Also, at no point in the game have I ever seen "based on a true story" being applied to this game. Just because you cannot imagine something, doesn't mean everyone is the same as you. The developer wants the sharing options but understands there are people like yourself who don't want it so gave the options to reject any and all sharing paths. Don't like it, why choose this game?

Because for them sharing was not a part of it and based upon history of game they have a strong point. The devs will get loads of hate when the sharing is in and lose people over it whether optional or not. It is their choice though, but based upon chapter 1 and 2 and a few years of development of the game plus fact it has been an MC focused male protagonist game from start and each of the 3 semi daddy's make horrible male options for D over the love relation she aleady has with F. It was never a female protagonist game about D, as the three male choices also proof or there would have been a young boyfriend with Elena or Jenn available. It is up to the devs though and hope for them they have a thick skin, since the hate will not be based on logic but emotions. Those last are always stronger unfortunately.

It is how they will feel and you can think that is not logical or weird, but it is still how they will feel anyway, whether you will allow it or not.

 

[Trikus]

Because for them sharing was not a part of it and based upon history of game they have a strong point. The devs will get loads of hate when the sharing is in and lose people over it whether optional or not. It is their choice though, but based upon chapter 1 and 2 and a few years of development of the game plus fact it has been an MC focused male protagonist game from start and each of the 3 semi daddy's make horrible male options for D over the love relation she aleady has with F. It was never a female protagonist game about D, as the three male choices also proof or there would have been a young boyfriend with Elena or Jenn available. It is up to the devs though and hope for them they have a thick skin, since the hate will not be based on logic but emotions. Those last are always stronger unfortunately.

It is how they will feel and you can think that is not logical or weird, but it is still how they will feel anyway, whether you will allow it or not.

There is a boyfriend choice for Elena. Jordan, the boy she meets when they visit the country turns into her love interest if she isn't in a relationship with the MC. She actively chooses not to go back to MC's country at the end of Chapter 2 and it is mentioned a few times that she is talking with him a lot and they are planning to go to University together.

 

[DA22]

There is a boyfriend choice for Elena. Justin, the boy she meets when they visit the country turns into her love interest if she isn't in a relationship with the MC. She actively chooses not to go back to MC's country at the end of Chapter 2 and it is mentioned a few times that she is talking with him a lot and they are planning to go to University together.

Now there could be a sharing option for D that could work and make some sense from a curiosity pov, but there is no path for that in the game .... Still it is only as MC not chooses to have Elena as a LI which goes against it and again shows it is a pure MC centered game. Same it would not surprise me Georgina might end with Martin if MC does not pursue her in game.

The game is about the father and always has been until the last few updates. If devs break that it will be at their own peril and risk, they will lose at least as many fans as they will gain.

 

[Trikus]

Now there could be a sharing option for D that could work and make some sense from a curiosity pov, but there is no path for that in the game .... Still it is only as MC not chooses to have Elena as a LI which goes against it and again shows it is a pure MC centered game. Same it would not surprise me Georgina might end with Martin if MC does not pursue her in game.

The game is about the father and always has been until the last few updates. If devs break that it will be at their own peril and risk, they will lose at least as many fans as they will gain.

D has also been making her own choices since Chapter 1. For example she can choose to explore a sexual relationship with Elena. Their first shower together happens in Chapter 1 and there are a couple more in Chapter 2. The MC doesn't find out about that until much later.

 

[SeveredRealms]

If they build that path into the game but leave it optional for those of us not wanting to share her with other men then there should be no problem. I prefer not to share her some may say selfish but it should be player choice and if it is then no one should be upset if the devs put it in the game as a optional non forced route. Everyone has their own kinks and if they did add it optional it should make the game more well rounded for the way others like to play as well. Like I say as long as its optional and not forced onto the player.

 

[DA22]

D has also been making her own choices since Chapter 1. For example she can choose to explore a sexual relationship with Elena. Their first shower together happens in Chapter 1 and there are a couple more in Chapter 2. The MC doesn't find out about that until much later.

3 choices for when F is not there against a few hundred by F does not make it a game where D is the focus of the world. The focus of the game world is F. D is the NPC, not the MC or co-MC and she never was, just the main focus as NPC. Besides even from those choices you can say they are made from the perspective of what isin F's interest and if he wants to be on an Elena sharing path and not real choices made from a D perspective.

 

[Trikus]

3 choices for when F is not there against a few hundred by F does not make it a game where D is the focus of the world. The focus of the game world is F. D is the NPC, not the MC or co-MC and she never was, just the main focus as NPC. Besides even from those choices you can say they are made from the perspective of what isin F's interest and if he wants to be on an Elena sharing path and not real choices made from a D perspective.

That bundle of straws you keep grasping at is getting smaller and smaller isn't it?

 

[dreamfdr]

In fact, reading the comments (and the fantasies of some users) is much more interesting than looking at the next issue of DMD. The game has been marking time for a long time and has become monotonous.

 

[jamdan]

You can name D, that's why we all call her D, because she doesn't have a NPC default name, thus she is not a non-player character.

We make lot's of choices from D's perspective. Just in this latest update we made a decision with Margo in the park. I'm sure we'll make choices when she is alone at the competition too, in fact her going to that competition by herself shows she is indeed one of the games protagonists.

D and F are both the protagonists. We make choices for both of them, we see things from both perspectives, both of them are named by the player, both of them move the story forward. Being a protagonist doesn't mean they have equal content, or have equal choices.

This game is mostly from F's perspective (for male player immersion reasons), but the game is about D. She is the one who is gaining a career, making choices and growing as a character. Just like how Melody was about Melody, or Haley's Story is about Haley.

 

[DigDug69]

People keep talking about sharing as if it only refers to MMF, but it also refers to females sharing the same guy.
And I lost count of the number of times that it has been clearly stated that sharing of any kind would be completely OPTIONAL and decision based. The players choices determine what happens, so if you showed interest in things that can lead to MMF sharing, then you will likely get the OPTION, but if you did not, you are far less likely to get the OPTION for it. As I stated in a previous post we are now up to DAY 40. That means that only 40 days ago D was a sweet innocent, if somewhat spoiled little girl who knew little about sex and pretty much nothing about debauchery, so expecting MMF already is very unrealistic.
When it comes to FFM, the first female that D was with was her best friend that she grew up with, and that is a very believable start on the path to FFM because it was someone she knew for a long time and trusted. Then later when she found out that Georgina also had a thing for her father and she (D) was already seen to be attracted to her, it made sense for her to let Georgina in on the fun too. But the other men in the story have spent very little time with D and therefore have had very little time for attachments to form with them, unlike it has been with the females.


And last but not least the current who is the main protagonist? Read the games title. Dating "My" Daughter. Only F can be the one making that statement and that makes him the main protagonist, and the character that you the player are represented by. Rachel is out of the equation for that, since she is hardly ever present in the vast majority of the game. D we answer questions for, because she is the focus of the game, and she is, while not a full protagonist, can be seen as a part of the protagonists dynamics, "part of the time". In reality, we are the protagonist for BOTH of them, but for D we are in charge of her decisions, only part of the time, when she is alone, or with anyone other than F.
In most of the game, D makes most of her own decisions.
Whereas for F, we are the ones who make all of his decisions 100% of the time.

 

[DA22]

That bundle of straws you keep grasping too is getting smaller and smaller isn't it?

Not really, but you keep adding straws indeed instead of arguments to try to built your point the game was always geared to sharing and slutting D up so you can kidnap her to a whorehouse after she is gangbanged so you can pimp her out or whatever you want. Fried did that way better though, but also his points failed on the one point that this is and has been a heavily MC centered game in the first years of development with a few choices by others on behalf of the MC when he could not be there and no serious male options for D around except for Daddy 2, daddy 3 and daddy 4 who make no sense with F around or while already in a relationship with F. The game is also not about game over choices, just since there was a game over in chapter 1 if did one choice wrong.

Now if devs want to change that in chapter 3 a lot of the more romantic and MC players are going to be heavily disappointed and even angry with reason , whatever you or me are going to tell them they can or cannot be, avoidable in game or not.

 

[Spfjolietjake]

even though I chose Olivia to talk to in the park and have Margo/threesome set to know (cause i don't want Ryan to touch D). It still acted like mc and d went out with margo and Ryan the night before. Glitch?

 

[DigDug69]

even though I chose Olivia to talk to in the park and have Margo/threesome set to know (cause i don't want Ryan to touch D). It still acted like mc and d went out with margo and Ryan the night before. Glitch?

Known glitch being worked on. Already many, many, many reports about it in this thread.

 

[Spfjolietjake]

Known glitch being worked on. Already many, many, many reports about it in this thread.

I appreciate you being kind and letting me know. I should of searched, thats my bad. I was just shocked and posted without searching. Again ty for not busting my balls