IMO, Chapter 12 really jumped the shark. It's bad enough that Moe, the MC's friend for many years is now going behind the MC's back and conspiring with those trying to hurt the MC. Not happy about that, but it's not too unreasonable if one assumes that Moe isn't playing with a full deck. But to suddenly, and I mean suddenly, have Amanda doing the same shit is beyond crazy. In the previous chapter she was madly in love with the MC. Now she's not only cold and distant, but she's looking for truth from someone who's already stated that she wants to destroy her father (and therefore has plenty of motive to lie about her father). The same father that Amanda has been in love with? The father that has spent the past 18+ years raising her, and is so devoted to her that he's centered his whole life around making her happy? The same father that recently drove across the country to fix a jukebox just to make Amanda happy? The father who, despite his promise to her mother, told Amanda the truth?
Amanda is behaving ridiculously and unbelievably. And the worst part of all of this is that it's all being rammed down our throats without the player having any damned choice in the matter at all.