- Apr 12, 2018
- 228
- 434
Pretty sure the last ten pages alone prove this thread is for more than just tech support.
- Sep 26, 2017
- 285
- 840
- May 28, 2017
- 2,281
- 13,112
@Palmer, we've communicated before going wayyyy back to ESA days. I admire that you've always been passionate about your games, stubbornly so. That passion does cause you to dig in your heels at times and over-react at other times. Those tendencies are part of what has made you successful, so I don't think you need to apologize for it. I imagine you find it kind of funny looking back on it now just how seriously you took things when Shark moved your content, seeing where you are now 
.
So that being said, you've tended to defend against people critical of Amanda (or Amanda's plot path) by falling back on her reaction and behavior as being "realistic for a girl that age." People will disagree about her sudden lack of trust in a man she's trusted her whole life, but I'll give you that point. Maybe in this case the realistic behavior results in her becoming less likable. Girls are crazy and unpredictable in real life all the time... maybe I don't want that in my porn game haha. Amanda can be perfectly authentic and less sympathetic at the same time.
I just went back and replayed chapters 12-16 to see if it made "more sense" in one sitting without the release delays between 14-15 and 15-16. It did actually, and like I said originally, I do have faith that your writing team has the talent to pull it off, even though I can't see a resolution that will make me forget that, right now, I don't like Amanda much anymore.
And that is the point here. Forget the debate over whether her behavior is authentic or realistic or believable or consistent with her personality. Just realize her behavior and choices in chapters 14-16 made a lot of players like me like her less. And that made me sad. That's all.
.So that being said, you've tended to defend against people critical of Amanda (or Amanda's plot path) by falling back on her reaction and behavior as being "realistic for a girl that age." People will disagree about her sudden lack of trust in a man she's trusted her whole life, but I'll give you that point. Maybe in this case the realistic behavior results in her becoming less likable. Girls are crazy and unpredictable in real life all the time... maybe I don't want that in my porn game haha
. Amanda can be perfectly authentic and less sympathetic at the same time.I just went back and replayed chapters 12-16 to see if it made "more sense" in one sitting without the release delays between 14-15 and 15-16. It did actually, and like I said originally, I do have faith that your writing team has the talent to pull it off, even though I can't see a resolution that will make me forget that, right now, I don't like Amanda much anymore.
And that is the point here. Forget the debate over whether her behavior is authentic or realistic or believable or consistent with her personality. Just realize her behavior and choices in chapters 14-16 made a lot of players like me like her less. And that made me sad. That's all.
- May 24, 2018
- 1,185
- 614
If it’s the online version, use these if you don’t want to play through all again:
You must be registered to see the links
- Jun 8, 2018
- 12
- 69
That's actually not a bad thing. One of the strong points of writing is that you can kinda prey on the experiences of your audience to bring out the desired emotions in them. So if you're writing for teenage girls, you talk about the stuff that they might experience in school, with friends, etc. and then they can't help but have a gut reaction to it. But the problem here isn't that this was done, it's how it was done.
With something like this it's something that should evolve naturally over a few episodes. So for example aunt is introduced in episode 1 and she acts like a bitch. In episode 2 she comes back and tries a more carrot and stick approach that seems to convince Amanda to listen. In episode 3 Amanda is spending time with her and getting a bit standoffish at times but nothing huge. Episode 4 comes and Amanda is now acting more cold and distant. Not indifferent, like she's written here, but less prone to displays of affection and not interested in sex. Come episode 5 and she's pulling all the crap she's pulling in these episodes. It makes it seem like the aunt is slowly wearing her down and twisting her to believe in her BS. This is only made worse by the fact that it's either something she's making up 100% or we, as the audience, aren't being told what the problem is. So to us it looks like Amanda is 100% being a jackass for believing what the aunt is saying.
Amanda doesn't come off as "undecided" on the matter. She comes off as emotionally abusive. One day she's sunshine, sparkles and rainbows and doesn't want a thing to do with her aunt. Then the next day she's not coming home, she's not responding to texts, she's cold and indifferent in conversation and when you finally try to confront her on it you get a "if you don't know what you did then I'm not going to tell you." Then, when stuff feels really hopeless, they have pity sex with you before telling you it was a mistake and kicking you out, taking you from the high and crashing back to the ground.
This is actually pretty classic emotional abuse. Flip the tables and imagine a guy doing this to his girlfriend / wife and you'll see how destructive it is. There's a number of really drastic flags here. The disappearing for all hours of the day / night with no communication, trivializing or not caring about your feelings and an unwillingness to actually communicate the problem are classic abuse signs. I used to work with emotionally abused women and this shit sets off some insane red flags that immediately made me loathe the daughter.
- Sep 26, 2017
- 285
- 840
It's not that I'm here defending what we made. If I come of us as sounding like that; my intent is actually to listen to what other people think and why, and reply the way we thought about it when doing it, and what our thought process was like. It's taking in feedback, try to understand other people's thoughts of views, and make better games. But yeah, stuff like that is not always clear when you write posts on a forum@Palmer
So that being said, you've tended to defend against people critical of Amanda (or Amanda's plot path) by falling back on her reaction and behavior as being "realistic for a girl that age." People will disagree about her sudden lack of trust in a man she's trusted her whole life, but I'll give you that point. Maybe in this case the realistic behavior results in her becoming less likable. Girls are crazy and unpredictable in real life all the time... maybe I don't want that in my porn game haha
I just went back and replayed chapters 12-16 to see if it made "more sense" in one sitting without the release delays between 14-15 and 15-16. It did actually, and like I said originally, I do have faith that your writing team has the talent to pull it off, even though I can't see a resolution that will make me forget that, right now, I don't like Amanda much anymore.
And that is the point here. Forget the debate over whether her behavior is authentic or realistic or believable or consistent with her personality. Just realize her behavior and choices in chapters 14-16 made a lot of players like me like her less. And that made me sad. That's all.
Have a good evening bud!
I switched from Amanda to Heidi now ^^
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- May 28, 2017
- 2,281
- 13,112
I should have clarified I was referring more to replies you've posted on Patreon than posts you've made here. And I'll be very interested to read anything you want to post about your team's thought process both in coming up with Amanda's "turn" and also after the players' reactions to it, but that should wait until the entire story is complete I imagine
.My last words on this topic will be: I'm still very eagerly waiting for Chapter 17!
- Nov 22, 2018
- 1,201
- 2,089
Yet again they will just say it was justified how she acted. Its ridiculous and the longer he plays this game of denying it was just a dumb decision the more anger fans will feel.
Like seriously just make a post saying after receiving loads of negative feedback we may have played up this Amanda goes cold storyline too far and too long and we understand her reasoning is lackluster, we will try to avoid this misstep in the future. Me and others would be happy with just a little acknowledgement that we might know wtf were talking instead of continually saying "your doing it wrong". Just bad business.
- Sep 19, 2018
- 1,234
- 1,700
Not even "your doing it wrong", just that they're listening and that they take it into account.
Whatever else - and I'm a bit surprised FWIW at the vehemence on here, but what would I know? - GOOD CHOICE.
Only ... TOOK YOU LONG ENOUGH!
Kathy is great, but Heidi is a wonder. They all have issues, who hasn't, but those are the two stars of the saga ... in ascending order ...
- Jan 1, 2019
- 218
- 190
I don't know if it's been covered or not, but it seems like my Online backup saves are not working correctly. I'm playing the online version and going between Ch 11 to 12 has everything wrong. My choices, the name of the diner. It's wrong. Anyone know what could be the cause of it?
Am I alone in feeling like Kathy is way more interesting than Amanda?
- Oct 12, 2018
- 96
- 126
- Jan 1, 2019
- 218
- 190
Update (a couple of moments after posting above), now going to Ch 13, it's showing choices I never made or even knew that I had a choice to make. I had noticed this before, but it was so small of a choice change that I thought that it didn't matter. Like when going from Ch 10 to Ch 11, I think it was, it said in the recap that Kathy asked me if I thought Heidi was Bi. In my playthrough of the Chapter, Kathy never asked me that question. Now in the recap of Ch 12, it says that Heidi and Kathy asked me out and things got out of hand leading to me fucking Kathy I guess. That choice of question about going with those two never came up in my playthrough.
So, what could be going on with my online backup saves?
And yes, to Kathy more interesting.
So, what could be going on with my online backup saves?
And yes, to Kathy more interesting.
- Sep 5, 2017
- 373
- 187
With change ch 13, you’ll need to use the cheat: ch13nothreesome
As for backups, it could be changing your relationship and diner name to default, but don’t quote me on that.
- Sep 5, 2017
- 373
- 187
Heidi is better than kathyTeam Kathy represent
- Jan 1, 2019
- 218
- 190
I know you said "don't quote me on that" But I am for this post. I just don't understand why it would change them so far into the game. Does, at leat the Downloaded versions of the game transfer to the next DL version. I know it doesn't work for online version for download versions. I am wondering if playing the downloaded version's save carry to the next chapter.
- Jan 1, 2019
- 218
- 190
Hedi as the Triss Merigold, from The Witcher games , (which I love Triss) vibe. Nut, that still doesn't make me choose Kathy over Heidi.