Somehow I don't believe you
Oh, it's no horror at all! Play your games however you want. But nothing will prevent me from thinking that, leaving aside some fetishes you may want to avoid (futa, NTR, pissing, etc.), sticking to just one route because you're infatuated with a certain pixel girl and thus missing out on 20%, 25%, 50%... of a game makes no sense.
But I understand I'm a completionist; I like to see as much content as I can, to compare every small variation in the story, and to assess the dev's work based on what he or she created as a whole.