You don't seem to understand the huge difference between an NGO like the Red Cross and a for profit business like Patreon. Patreon is a subscription service not a charity. Look at the Dev's patreon page, he has four different levels of rewards that people can receive IF they pledge a certain amount of money to him. So if he doesn't fulfill his end of the deal then people can ask for their money back, and if he doesn't comply with that request then they can take legal action against him and patreon. Patreon is a company that is incorporated in the state of California, so they are bound to follow the laws of the US Government, and the State of California.
You are correct, when a patreon account owner has listed Rewards, then you enter into a transaction where the money is given in exchange for the rewards. This is by tax definition. Now, if a patreon account owner does not list rewards, it become purely a donation or gift. Patreon, in their terms of use, gives the account owners the right to change the reward, including completely removing it. This does not immeditely stop future payments from patrons.
- $1 MEMBERSHIP TIER
- First & Foremost: My undying gratitude. Thank you for your support!
- Access to Patron-Only feed containing important announcements.
- Regularly recieve notices regarding future releases of development.
- $5 MEMBERSHIP TIER
- THE GAME: Download the latest chapter/version of Dual Family! Releases occur every month or sooner!
- PREVIEWS: Basic Scenes (Enviromental/Clothed). Get a sneak peek of upcoming scenes in the game!
- Participate in voting polls influencing future direction of development.
- All previously listed tiers & their rewards!
- $12 MEMBERSHIP TIER
- PREVIEWS: Softcore Scenes (Nudism/Intimacy). Get a sneak peek of upcoming scenes in the game!
- Detailed Walkthrough of the latest release. Never make a mistake!
- THE GAME: Download the latest chapter/version of Dual Family! Releases occur every month or sooner!
- All previously listed tiers & their rewards!
- $20 MEMBERSHIP TIER
- PREVIEWS: H A R D C O R E (Sex – Before, During & After) Get a sneak peek of upcoming scenes in the game!
- THE GAME: Download the latest chapter/version of Dual Family! Releases occur every month or sooner!
- ALL Dual Family tiers & rewards!
He never promises to anyone to PM them. The only area I see where he is lacking in giving what he promised to his patrons is in the $5 tier: "Releases occur
every month or sooner!" He is currently 9 days past one month after his last update (18/06/17). As he seems to so often not meet his goal, it would behoove him to change the statement or remove it concerning the frequency of his updates.
You
could file a report with patreon, saying that he is not delivering promised goods ... which could simply result in him saying "fuck it", working on the current release, and then deleting his patreon. (which is, hopefully, not something any of us here want). The best thing you could do, is bring this up to him after the current version of the game is released to us, when he's not balls-to-the-wall trying to get the update out to his patrons.