- Mar 17, 2019
- 1,085
- 1,176
If it's him, then trying to be better doesn't make the guilt go away, if it's one of their fathers, then MC would have killed whoever did it and that would have resulted in them going to prison. Cheating just doesn't mesh with the overall tone the game, and feels at odds with what we know of her personality. She adores him. Always has.I see why people think she was raped by him, but I still don't think so. The info card say step-daughter, and all the pain of those three years would have been avoided by her telling him if he had blacked out. Her refusing to tell him makes absolutely NO sense. If he raped her, tell him so he can repent and avoid it in the future. If she was protecting someone else, why still avoid telling decades later?
She isn't lying, she's just not telling him who did it. Not out out maliciousness or just because, but probably to protect him or stop him doing something incredibly stupid. And he doesn't really deserve anything. He's a rapist and a cheater himself, and that started before she got pregnant.
I'm not a huge fan of Hiroko, myself. I find her a bit boring compared to most of the cast in character and design, but it's kinda fucked up that people are painting her as some kind of awful person taking advantage of the MC or something, when the MC is a straight up monster.