MagnaSonic3000
Well-Known Member
- Jan 22, 2018
- 1,172
- 1,726
- 236
I'm more just interested in it for the accuracy. Their virginities being off can mess with your perception of the characters. An innocent character being a non virgin changes how you may view her for example. In extreme cases, it might make a character seem dishonest and go against their dialogue. Like a character is pretending to be innocent and have no sexual experience for some reason. Maybe they're worrying about people thinking they're slutty or they just like to fuck with people and lie a lot.I don't think it really matters because the player usually invades their pussies at some point anyway.
Or they could have had a bad/immemorable/unnoteworthy sexual experience, or during their however many hundred years of living had a change of perspective/behavior, or a number of other reasons. Like being prudent or reserved and a virgin aren't mutually exclusive. Social stigma might be a factor and reputation is everything when you're a hundreds year old demon or whatever who's renown and/or authority is a facet of everyday life and personal safety.I'm more just interested in it for the accuracy. Their virginities being off can mess with your perception of the characters. An innocent character being a non virgin changes how you may view her for example. In extreme cases, it might make a character seem dishonest and go against their dialogue. Like a character is pretending to be innocent and have no sexual experience for some reason. Maybe they're worrying about people thinking they're slutty or they just like to fuck with people and lie a lot. It's actually kind of important imo.
A big issue with this stuff is it's still headcanon. Yes there are a million ways that a girl that doesn't seem promiscuous could have had sex before, but it's always a stretch and can't be proven. Just saying old age = she banged is pretty odd given the canon info we have about a lot of the girls. Most of these girls aren't human and don't need to follow our social norms for starters. Many of the girls are quite peculiar and don't act anything like typical humans. Some are hyper focused on some task, some are heavily reclusive and almost never interact with others, some have never even met humans outside of Touhou girls and such (I believe). Most these girls are demons, gods, ghosts, machines, fairies, etc.Or they could have had a bad/immemorable/unnoteworthy sexual experience, or during their however many hundred years of living had a change of perspective/behavior, or a number of other reasons. Like being prudent or reserved and a virgin aren't mutually exclusive. Social stigma might be a factor and reputation is everything when you're a hundreds year old demon or whatever who's renown and/or authority is a facet of everyday life and personal safety.
Like I don't know about you, but I wouldn't exactly want to bring up playing these kind of games to acquaintances I know irl either, regardless if they gave a shit. And I'd be equally uncomfortable if people tried to have a conversation about that sort of thing unless I was behind closed doors and was knew the guy well enough. Am I "pretending" or "fucking with people"? Not really. It's my business what I do and I'm not thrilled to talk about this kind of shit without some degree of separation from my social life.
You're thinking way too deep. We're never going to have confirmation of casual sex because 1) it's irrelevant to most official media and 2) because it directly affects irl people's perception of the franchise. There's then also the issue of inconsistencies even within official mediums, especially when it comes to spin-offs. If those can be written off as alternate universes, why shouldn't a porn parody be treated as the same?A big issue with this stuff is it's still headcanon. Yes there are a million ways that a girl that doesn't seem promiscuous could have had sex before, but it's always a stretch and can't be proven. Just saying old age = she banged is pretty odd given the canon info we have about a lot of the girls. Most of these girls aren't human and don't need to follow our social norms for starters. Many of the girls are quite peculiar and don't act anything like typical humans. Some are hyper focused on some task, some are heavily reclusive and almost never interact with others, some have never even met humans and such (I believe). Most these girls are demons, gods, ghosts, machines, fairies, etc.
Thinking of them as well rounded individuals that must have experienced most things normal humans experience just because they're old doesn't make sense. Like a real human that spends all day every day studying in a library doesn't really exist, but Patchouli does it. I don't think her hyper fixation/extreme personality is even all that rare in Touhou lore. I think Sakuya is supposed to be around 10-20 years old until she entered the Scarlet Devil Mansion, and then she just apparently stopped aging or something. So her non virgin status is questionable. She was likely "in her early teens" before she met Remilia, so when did she bang? I guess we're also now assuming even young teens have fucked, cause I doubt she's banging dudes with her maid duties while working for Remilia.
Then we apparently have no info on Kurumi, but she's fucked before, unlike the other vampires. Merlin was created as a ghost and was never human, but apparently she's banged. The list goes on. Judging Merlin by her lack of virgin status would make you assume she was probably a human that died. I had no idea she was created. So perfect example there of how it can cause issues. That shit can completely change your perception of a character. A created ghost vs a human that died and became a ghost is a massive difference in experiences.
You can turn everything you're saying right back on anybody claiming girls are non virgins, lol. You realize that right? At the end of the day you're making assumptions about the characters, and often ignoring lore. It's "nitpicking" just the same to claim that some girls aren't virgins without evidence.You're thinking way too deep. We're never going to have confirmation of casual sex because 1) it's irrelevant to most official media and 2) because it directly affects irl people's perception of the franchise. There's then also the issue of inconsistencies even within official mediums, especially when it comes to spin-offs. If those can be written off as alternate universes, why shouldn't a porn parody be treated as the same?
As for your argument that the girls don't follow human norms, I don't think it matters. Plenty of them have some sort of interest in humans and the outside world, evident in the foods they eat, the clothes they wear, the things they read, etc. Just because they are unbound to human activities/thoughts doesn't mean they don't participate in or assimilate it.
Regarding Sakuya, what you're saying doesn't make sense. She has days off in the game. If she's got time to visit your character and fuck, she's got time to fuck other people too. There's even times where she goes into town in a casual outfit, if I'm remembering right. Sure, Patchouli reads almost all of the time, but there's no hard rule saying that she doesn't have days where she does something else, and I'm fairly certain canonical examples exist. Like you're arguing that there's no evidence they do X, but there's no evidence they don't do X either.
Honestly though, I feel like nitpicking these details completely goes against the spirit of the game. You're already playing as a walking contradiction to established cannon, wooing girls that shouldn't be able to be woo'd that easily, but you're drawing the line at the virginities?
Oh? A wholesome dating game like EratohoTW has a NTR? Hm...I guess I am more vanilla than I thought....or I'm just dumb.I know there are a handful of instances of NTRish stuff in TW.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I haven't tested these myself, just going off of what I've read in threads.It's hard to search for the specifics because people whine about NTR for entire threads, so a ctrl F search of it is useless, lol.Nevermind, I found the thread that has the specific info on it.
Never waited out a full pregnancy so not sure on those ones.some more TW questionsto distract from this kinda dumb argument
how long does pregnancy last? & What happens when they give birth (assuming they do)?
Also; can you move in with a girl or convince her to move in with you?
I'm actually not sure how long it lasts day wise. But if it feels too long for you, you can go into the cheat menu by clicking options at the day start menu and then the stars at the top. In there you can set pregnancy speed to go faster.some more TW questionsto distract from this kinda dumb argument
how long does pregnancy last? & What happens when they give birth (assuming they do)?
Also; can you move in with a girl or convince her to move in with you?
Yes, that's the point I'm making. At no point did I make the argument that they aren't virgins, I've been trying to explain how there's no concrete evidence one way or the other due to various reasons. The whole "does does girl seem like they should be a virgin" is basically conjecture, or as you put it, headcannon. That's why I've been telling you you're thinking way too deeply into this.You can turn everything you're saying right back on anybody claiming girls are non virgins, lol. You realize that right? At the end of the day you're making assumptions about the characters, and often ignoring lore. It's "nitpicking" just the same to claim that some girls aren't virgins without evidence.
Your existence in this game is a unique oddity to Sakuya. Remilia has ordered Sakuya to work with you. She threatens to kill you when you first meet and only allows you to live because of Remilia. You think this girl is casually banging dudes in the city? You're not just ignoring her canon lore, you're even ignoring her ingame lore. You've admitted yourself that the player is a walking contradiction that is able to do things normal humans can't, remember? But somehow rando humans that barely have a chance to meet most girls are fucking them, even though the MC struggles with that for months? Wow, sure seems like there are some consistency issues there with the game world.
As I've mentioned, innocent until some shred of evidence is best for default. There are girls that have canon or implied relationships, there are even girls we have confirmed have had kids. Why do you feel the need to stretch so hard to force sex on girls we have zero evidence for, it's just plain bullshit. The best you can come up with is "They interact with humans, so they must have fucked"? Lmao. A lot of humans are interested in other humans and are still virgins, but you think the demons/ghosts/gods and such that are locked away in a fantasy world and have extreme personalities have fucked before just because they have access to some humans in one village? Again, I've already accepted many times that "It's possible", but "possible" shouldn't guarantee things. There is already an option for that in the virginity toggles. I'm asking for an "accurate" toggle so people don't need to fill in the blanks with bullshit.
The virgin/non virgin status being off can straight up conflict with shit in their canon lore and in game lore and cause misconceptions, that's a fact. People end up having to jump through hoops to explain them, much like you're doing. Guess we should just assume all the girls are non virgins because they can access the Human Village, lmao. This isn't a fantasy dating sim with eccentric fantasy races anymore, we need to assume all characters act like real human girls. Let's just ignore everything we know about most these girls to make that a reality.
Pregnancy lasts for 102 days iirc.some more TW questionsto distract from this kinda dumb argument
how long does pregnancy last? & What happens when they give birth (assuming they do)?
Also; can you move in with a girl or convince her to move in with you?