- Apr 14, 2021
- 736
- 1,478
Well in that continuity, Lauren would be a sex slave even after the MC died, if I understand it right.
- Thread starter Caribdis
- Start date
- Apr 26, 2022
- 333
- 1,030
Wow okay well that's horrible and I'm glad I've never played it either. But it's still doesn't make sense to me. The only people who could make a point here are people who'd enjoy sharing. You share, you get punished. You don't share, you're all good. All we have to do to avoid pain is to make the right choice (much like the Regina scene in Eternum even though it's less extreme). Were they just mad that the scene exists at all ?
Unless again people were just throwing a party to celebrate the fact that Cari does not condone sharing or netorare in his games, since it's literally punishable by death. I would have been to that party.
- Nov 27, 2021
- 1,212
- 1,945
Apologies if I'm not understanding your statements, but yes, some ppl cannot even accept that a game could contain certain content that they don't specifically like, even if its very easily avoidable, or hell even has a "turn off all x content" option at the very start of the game.
And yea I think ppl are just glad Caribdis isn't including any scenes like that this time around. I know I was spooked by that scene in OIALT lol, I'm someone who scum saves to see all endings and options cuz I wanna see all the content the dev worked on, and man bad endings always make me revert back to my main playthrough so fast lol
- Jun 18, 2022
- 233
- 595
Currently playing the game but is Luna using Triss Merigold's outfit or is my mind just misrembering things?
- Nov 18, 2019
- 4,661
- 8,612
Complaints about that choice, because a lot of people felt it was unnecessary and too cruel toward Lauren, of course the majority expressed their concern in a civil way, but I read there were some harsh words about that.
In a story that was pretty much positive ( despite some very serious points) like OIAL putting a scene like that was seen as a low blow, and I'm honest here, I was glad to know what to do beforehand and avoided that, because I don't like that type of event, even if they are meant as bad ends only.
I just don't like them at all, I already had some issues with the few darker games I play, I don't want to even hear something like that for games like OIAL, or Eternum.
Call me a softie but I really can't stand to see the characters suffer when I can avoid it, I leave certain types of games to those who find these themes interesting, when I play I want to only relax and play a great story with a " and they lived happily forever" ending if possible and nothing else.
I mean there's already the reality to make me depressed, I don't want to see that in my fantasy as well, thanks but no thanks.
Anyway I hope I clarified my point of view about the discussion, and why I don't like to see certain themes or endings in the games I play.
- Feb 20, 2019
- 1,520
- 3,677
I believe you're referring to Luna's outfit in the Red Herring server (it does look similar albeit a different colour iirc). There's also a trio of the Witcher themed wallpapers released sometime ago. These are the links if you wish to take a look at them.
You must be registered to see the links
(Nancy with Triss Merigold's outfit)
You must be registered to see the links
(Alex with Ciri's outfit)
You must be registered to see the links
(Luna with Yennefer of Vengerberg's outfit)
- Oct 10, 2022
- 4,349
- 7,725
- Apr 26, 2022
- 333
- 1,030
I mean I can't stand to see the characters suffer either, but I'm not going to complain that it's there if I can easily avoid it. I don't even want to see that scene. Even when someone showed the picture of Penny crying in this thread I quickly closed it because I hate it, and I know for a fact that I will never play this scene myself. Thing is I kinda enjoy knowing there's a bad path I can avoid / have avoided. It's relieving to me, like I can enjoy the good path more. I don't even need to know the details of said bad path, just that the path I took is better and that the bad one is entirely and easily avoidable.Complaints about that choice, because a lot of people felt it was unnecessary and too cruel toward Lauren, of course the majority expressed their concern in a civil way, but I read there were some harsh words about that.
In a story that was pretty much positive ( despite some very serious points) like OIAL putting a scene like that was seen as a low blow, and I'm honest here, I was glad to know what to do beforehand and avoided that, because I don't like that type of event, even if they are meant as bad ends only.
I just don't like them at all, I already had some issues with the few darker games I play, I don't want to even hear something like that for games like OIAL, or Eternum.
Call me a softie but I really can't stand to see the characters suffer when I can avoid it, I leave certain types of games to those who find these themes interesting, when I play I want to only relax and play a great story with a " and they lived happily forever" ending if possible and nothing else.
I mean there's already the reality to make me depressed, I don't want to see that in my fantasy as well, thanks but no thanks.
Anyway I hope I clarified my point of view about the discussion, and why I don't like to see certain themes or endings in the games I play.
I guess making Lauren a slave was indeed a bit much though that's true, having the MC die probably would have been enough... I mean since that's a game over and stuff.
See ? Isn't it just better to enjoy the good path patting you on the head and smothering you in her chest when you know there's a bad path out there that can't reach you as long as you stay safe in the good path's arms ?
Anywho, I got it. Thanks for the explanations.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- Nov 11, 2022
- 2,571
- 7,243
- Jun 20, 2022
- 5,650
- 9,420
- Jun 20, 2022
- 5,650
- 9,420
But you can avoid it. Some of the optimal choices in both Eternum and Once in a Lifetime make no sense at all which is my biggest nitpick in Caribdis's games. However that is not the case here. it is very obvious that selling lauren to a yakuza boss is a bad choice. Unless you are not reading the story, I dont know how anyone can think selling her is a good idea.Complaints about that choice, because a lot of people felt it was unnecessary and too cruel toward Lauren, of course the majority expressed their concern in a civil way, but I read there were some harsh words about that.
In a story that was pretty much positive ( despite some very serious points) like OIAL putting a scene like that was seen as a low blow, and I'm honest here, I was glad to know what to do beforehand and avoided that, because I don't like that type of event, even if they are meant as bad ends only.
I just don't like them at all, I already had some issues with the few darker games I play, I don't want to even hear something like that for games like OIAL, or Eternum.
Call me a softie but I really can't stand to see the characters suffer when I can avoid it, I leave certain types of games to those who find these themes interesting, when I play I want to only relax and play a great story with a " and they lived happily forever" ending if possible and nothing else.
I mean there's already the reality to make me depressed, I don't want to see that in my fantasy as well, thanks but no thanks.
Anyway I hope I clarified my point of view about the discussion, and why I don't like to see certain themes or endings in the games I play.
I like the addition of bad choices and the consequences that follow those choices because it adds some weight to the decision making. Maybe showing the rape scene may have been unnecessary and it could just have been a written description however I am not sure that would have carried the same narrative impact.
I dont want Caribdis to waste development time on a bunch of scenes most players will dislike and will never see but I dont mind the addition of the occasional bad ending here and there. I prefer bad endings that fit into the story such as the lauren rape scene and the penny/dalia breakup scenes far more than scenes where the MC is a horndog - for example I disliked the MC being a creep and peeping on Dalia in the shower and the scene where the MC goes after Eva immediately after Annie gives him her life savings (I loved the Eva scene itself because of the conversation we had with her but I disliked the part leading up to it and the MC's attitude towards the whole thing).
Last edited:
- Nov 18, 2019
- 4,661
- 8,612
That's exactly what I did as well, I knew that there where scenes that I wouldn't have liked and I simply avoided them.I mean I can't stand to see the characters suffer either, but I'm not going to complain that it's there if I can easily avoid it. I don't even want to see that scene. Even when someone showed the picture of Penny crying in this thread I quickly closed it because I hate it, and I know for a fact that I will never play this scene myself. Thing is I kinda enjoy knowing there's a bad path I can avoid / have avoided. It's relieving to me, like I can enjoy the good path more. I don't even need to know the details of said bad path, just that the path I took is better and that the bad one is entirely and easily avoidable.
I guess making Lauren a slave was indeed a bit much though that's true, having the MC die probably would have been enough... I mean since that's a game over and stuff.
See ? Isn't it just better to enjoy the good path patting you on the head and smothering you in her chest when you know there's a bad path out there that can't reach you as long as you stay safe in the good path's arms ?
Anywho, I got it. Thanks for the explanations.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Sadly not everyone is the same and many are vocals about, let's call them issues, regardless of the fact that they were warned and decided to see them anyway, it's their fault in my opinion, not the dev.
I mean when it's abundantly clear that a choice will lead to a bad scene or end, deciding to see it and then complaining the fault is completely on the player, imho.
I'm not against bad ends, they are necessary in a story that want to be as complete as possible or it would be like a fairy tale, but it's up to the (presumed) common sense of the player to avoid it.
You said with different words the same thing I said, I agree with you I didn't complain about the bad ends ( or the Lauren one in particular) I just reported what I read about it.
As I said when it's clear that there's a possible bad ends I avoid it, but at the same time I know it's necessary for it to be present if I want a better story, and especially a story that reward me when I do the correct choices.
Uhm, regarding the scene where Orion looks like a creep, honestly to me they are a matter of sensibility and how you perceive them so I don't know I think it depend.
The scene with Dalia in the bathroom is on a grey area to me, I mean Orion was cleaning the bathroom and Dalia appeared all of a sudden, Cari could have played it differently like maybe with her already half dressed and leading to a similar ending but overall I didn't consider that so bad it was a cliché typical of porn, while the Eva one puzzled me too a little, not because it wasn't good but because it was too abruptly after Annie went to get the sword.
It could have been played better? Yes, but to consider Orion so negatively? No, I respectfully disagree with you.
It would have been bad if there was the choice to let Annie know about it, that would have been a bad end plain and square, but as was played it was the typical scene that you could find in a cyberpunk, my only complain is that it was just too sudden, at least that's my opinion.
P.S. About the Eva scene I still have the impression that it was instead a planned scene by Caribdis that will come back in the future, my opinion is that we will see Eva again and maybe deciding to have sex with her will make her a potential side LI, or an ally for Orion and the girls.
It's a gut feeling nothing more, but the fact that she said that Eternum has a way to make people connect again lead me to this thought.
- May 21, 2017
- 3,065
- 15,791
The reason I dislike the Dalia scene was because Orion was awake, Dalia specifically yelled Orion's name to see he was there and Orion chose to hide. It would be different if he was actually asleep. But with the way it is written, I felt like the choice to be a creep was a deliberate one and I did not like that.Uhm, regarding the scene where Orion looks like a creep, honestly to me they are a matter of sensibility and how you perceive them so I don't know I think it depend.
The scene with Dalia in the bathroom is on a grey area to me, I mean Orion was cleaning the bathroom and Dalia appeared all of a sudden, Cari could have played it differently like maybe with her already half dressed and leading to a similar ending but overall I didn't consider that so bad it was a cliché typical of porn, while the Eva one puzzled me too a little, not because it wasn't good but because it was too abruptly after Annie went to get the sword.
It could have been played better? Yes, but to consider Orion so negatively? No, I respectfully disagree with you.
It would have been bad if there was the choice to let Annie know about it, that would have been a bad end plain and square, but as was played it was the typical scene that you could find in a cyberpunk, my only complain is that it was just too sudden, at least that's my opinion.
P.S. About the Eva scene I still have the impression that it was instead a planned scene by Caribdis that will come back in the future, my opinion is that we will see Eva again and maybe deciding to have sex with her will make her a potential side LI, or an ally for Orion and the girls.
It's a gut feeling nothing more, but the fact that she said that Eternum has a way to make people connect again lead me to this thought.
As for the Eva scene I dont like that the first thing that came to Orion's mind was throwing away Annie's life savings just to get laid. I think it would have been very easy to write a different scene where Orion could have met Eva under different circumstances. The sex scene itself was a very good one - it was one of my favorites in fact because I loved the philosophical conversation he had with her. But I did not like the lead up to it.
As for Eva as a potential side LI, personally I hope not because I feel like 7 girls - 8 counting Calypso is already way too much. I want the existing characters to get more screen time and be better developed.
Last edited:
- Apr 25, 2020
- 4,668
- 12,693
You're complaining about choices, choices you don't like. If it doesn't suit you well, then don't spend your money to have sex and it's all good. "But if it's possible it means it's his character" No, it's only your choice. It's like complaining about an optional kink you don't like only because the option is present. Build your own canon story.
- Apr 26, 2022
- 333
- 1,030
I don't feel like the choice to be a creep was a deliberate one (at least not from the character, obviously from the dev since he's writing everything and make these situations what they are). Orion just panics and hides, then commits to avoid awkwardness but take this opportunity to enjoy the sight (so he's taking the opportunity to be a creep even though it wasn't planned, see what I mean ?). I guess him falling asleep in the bathtub could have work too but I mean it still works all and all. We're talking about a time when Orion (who is a horndog, as already established) wasn't as close as the LIs so it's possible to explain why he got to Eva or why he's creeping a little bit when he gets the chance. But it's fine he doesn't need that anymore.
Plus the comedy of all of it is on point. Orion trying to teleport away was kinda hilarious. Dalia's kick and her being mad at him later is also kinda funny.
- Nov 18, 2019
- 4,661
- 8,612
Yeah, I understand your reasons, that's why I talked about how one perceived it and it's ok to have different views on them, it's the good thing of having a discussion about it.
In the end it's a sign that Caribdis created a really engaging story with characters so loveable that we care a lot about them.
I was just stating my preference for bad endings and sad scenes over scenes where the MC gets rewarded for being a horndog. Optional or not, it is a scene in the game and so I am allowed to have an opinion about how I think it fits within the story and affects the character because Orion is not a self insert blank character - he has a proper personality of his own.
I liked the regina + brock scenes and the lauren/orochi scene where the player is penalized for making dumb choices more than the consequence free scenes that reward the MC for being a horndog like the Eva and Dalia scenes - I dont think it being optional or not matters in the context of this discussion. I did not take the lauren/orochi scene as part of my canon playthrough but it being optional does not stop me from thinking it fit within the story, added weight to the decision making and was a good addition for penalizing the player for making stupid choices. But again thats just my preference. Others would disagree with this and say that a rape scene like the lauren/orochi scene has no place in a harem game like Once in a Lifetime but thats their opinion and it is ok to disagree.
Last edited:
