- Nov 18, 2019
- 4,693
- 9,323
Thank you for sharing your thoughts and clearing my misunderstanding, because your previous post sounded a bit dismissive in regards of what we were talking, and considering how many thoughtful and well crafted theories Dorfnutter shared here with us I felt a little disheartened, so I apologise to you if I sounded rude and I'm glad to know you appreciated that theory instead and shared all that infos.The reason I made that post was precisely because it was a good observation and a plausible theory. If the 7 LIs are indeed the Pleiades, it is more likely that the story has something to do with the mythological Orion and you can use that information to theorize where things will go in the future.
Because I liked that theory, I decided to search through some of Caribdis's posts to see if this was planned from the start and I found comments on itch.io and on his discord server where he said there were originally supposed to be 9 LIs then he changed it it 8 and then finally 7. Because people here are so invested in theorizing I wanted to share what I found - based on caribdis's original plans and posts from long ago, I thought that this was more likely to be a coincidence and the number of LIs were reduced for practical reasons rather than story reasons and this line of thinking could possibly be overthinking it a bit. Not sure why you are so offended by it.
I like reading the theories here as much as anyone else and if I find something that can help people refine their theories I prefer to share it. It is possible that it is not a coincidence and the LIs are indeed the Pleiades but I think it is useful for people making theories to be aware of Caribdis's old posts regardless.
My point of view about the theory of the let's call them the "big seven" + Calypso is that like in OIAL Caribdis is perfectly balancing the suspension of disbelief about them and Orion being the characters of the greek myths or simply sharing their names because they are cool names to use.
He's very good in dancing "around" the truth without giving you the last detail to confirm one theory or the other, and this is one of the thing I love the most about his style.
He knows perfectly how to play the game, and to put a lot of references to myths and legends not only from history but religions or from fantasy works ( I include in fantasy everything, so Sci-Fi, Fantasy and other works from literature, movies, comics etc etc), under this point of view he's the most similar to the japanese authors that are masters at handling these themes in their works.
Just to make another "simple" example the scene in Ion with Eva was a sign on how much he knows how to play with these aspects, how she was introduced as the "first" woman, her telling him to savour the forbidden fruit, to the detail of her looks ( the pendant, the veil, the red dress all details that played about the myth of Eva).
Even from there you can see how much thoughts, creativity and obsessive care he put in this game, rarely I've seen such a level of layering before in a western game at least.
It is always possible that something that was intended as a simple play of words and names became something more as soon as the theories started going on; and then he started to use it more heavily ( in this regards the obsession of Orion for the crossbows could be another example, another one is the fact that there's a correspondence between the name of the girls and the codenames they used in the Garrington's heist).
Some may be nothing more than a simple "it's a cool thing to show, I will use it" like it happened with Maat in the egyptian server, other may be more deep like the Pleiades theory + Calypso but there's no certainty ( for now), so we need to wait and see.
Anyway I will end my wall of text for now, I bored you enough I think, thanks again for your post and again sorry for being rude towards you, I hope we could talk more about our opinions and theories and share them here.
There's still a lot of things to discover and I think the next update will increase the number of ideas and theories on where the story is leading and I can't wait to play it.