This all makes sense, I appreciate the explanation.
That being said, this paints Patreon as a needlessly brassbound, ball-less company who will gladly make money off a pornographic project while, simultaneously, banning content it views as morally-reprehensible. There's no U.S. law against depictions of hypnosis or non-consent in pornography, for instance. There's plenty of depictions of those things in Hollywood film as well. What sense does it make to arbitrarily forbid content that wouldn't get the site in any legal trouble?
So, I originally had this in the original post, but I took it out because I thought I already had a big enough wall of text in it and I didn't want people to just sleep through the post, but let me re-post what I had in there explaining why Patreon does this.
Before I post this though, to be clear, this isn't in defense of Patreon or censorship of adult content in general; this is more just explaining matter-of-factly why they do the things they do.
The main problem is actually with Visa/Mastercard, and before that even, it's a problem with the culture of the country we're in.
You must be registered to see the links
If you search "1.3.3.4" on that PDF, you'll be brought to a section that shows all the content that Visa has banned for places using its service to process credit card payments.
It's identical to the only content Patreon bans (if you expand it out into hypno as non-consent).
Additionally, Patreon's also trying to avoid being branded as an "adult site", which means Visa/Mastercard would slap it with "high risk transactions" rules, which are a big deal for sites like Patreon because it means backers would have far less of thier money go to creators due to much, much higher fees per transaction; this is why practically no sites prior to Patreon ever succeeded in being a hub for people to make these kinds of games on (Offbeatr, for instance) because the fees were simply too high.
Cycling back to the culture thing, you can pay for everything on that "banned list" in Japan, with your Visa/Mastercard, but you can't do it in America. Why?
Because the culture of the USA would find it reprehensible to buy that content in America, but Japanese culture generally doesn't get as outraged by it. Thus, Visa/Mastercard enact different rules, per country (this is why that terms of service address reads usa.visa.com), and as a result, those rules are then handed down to Patreon.
If Patreon ignores those rules, best case, they get branded an adult site. Worst case, they lose the ability to process payments and the site dies.
Don't get me wrong; Patreon definitely has some issues, I'm just clarifying why they have the rules they do have.
You're clearly stuck with Patreon for this particular project, but I'm begging you: please find a better crowdfunding host for whatever projects follow Future Fragments. We can hand-wave content being removed with clever writing all we want (just as you can justify or add content that way), but Patreon meddling clearly played enough of a role to bother mentioning it. I'm not asking you to reply to me with "yeah, we will definitely abandon Patreon", since you're still in business with them. But please consider it.
tl;dr - If Patreon gets something I actually like removed from this game, or Faye's Game™, I'm going to leave a bag of burning shit on the porch of their office.
So the ideal situation would be that Future Fragments sells like gangbusters, both in its initial big sales period of the first 5 weeks
(which is why we'd like to humbly ask for people to not pirate the game during those 5 weeks, as it's when a majority of a games's sales are made), and in residual sales over time.
If it does do really well, we won't have to worry about having enough money to sink into Faye's game, as well as keep a roof over our heads while we work on it, and not be beholden to any sort of crowdfunding service as a result.
Now, that said, in any circumstance, if we do stay on Patreon through Faye's game, we'll likely still be making enough money off of Future Fragments's sales that if we
did get told we had to remove any content, we could just leave Patreon without financial worries due to those residual sales.