kasdiddd

Member
Sep 15, 2018
113
70
1. Bug to be fixed: Male voices are muted, but they play in game over scenes anyway
2. Way too much unnecessary talking...it's the spam Z key simulator. Most of these conversations are meaningless...whether they are about lore, gameplay, whatever
3. Gallery is well done
4. Was hoping there would be some new sexual content, but there isn't an ounce of new sexual content. None of the random NPCs have any cutscenes or animations for sexual content whatsoever
 
  • Like
Reactions: MortimerScharf

MasterXY

Newbie
Apr 23, 2018
26
159
Dearest OmnFurious,

I appreciate your well wishes. And hope everything is well on your end too.

I'm sure most of these NPCs don't make a difference to the overall story, but it's not that different than flavor text for items in any other game right? It's just some fun little info for people who enjoy that kind of thing and make the world feel a bit less empty.
But I want to be engaged with the story, and given how this game has been talked about I was under the assumption these NPC's and choices I make now will effect me later and I'd like to be able to follow the story somewhat as opposed to just mashing through every dialogue box that pops up.

Simply saying "well you don't have to read it" is a very poor argument when the dev wants you to take his game seriously. How is anyone going to take this game seriously when the most common response to lore is "lmao just skip it, the dev is already expecting people to not read it". Especially when 75% of the game is this lore.

My argument is not against the inclusion of databanks that tie into NPC's, my argument is that there is simply too much meaningless databanks mixed together with ones that are actually relevant to the plot/lore/characters, and that it is creating contradicting gameplay loop in which the game wants to be an action platformer, but every room you enter has at least 2 databases with 2-5 minute voice clips and 1 NPC so you're getting like 30-60 seconds of gameplay inbetween every cutscene or voice clip. There is no balance between gameplay and story telling, and the sheer volume of databanks being thrown at you is overwhelming. I am trying to follow the story but I can't keep track of anything, and if I'm trying to keep track but can't, imagine all the people who aren't going to try. Some of the databanks should honestly be culled or removed, or turned into a bronze databank where they just get sent to your codex instead where you have to open it to listen to them there. The silver ones can be ones that are important to the plot/story or an NPC, and the gold ones are about seeber. That would be a better solution if people are against their removal, because there's no way in hell you will ever convince me half of those databanks are even worth reading.

Regards,
MasterXY

Also, you guys here seem to think in black and white: just because pointed some areas where I thought the experience was not that good that didn't mean I hated the game. Just that there are parts I don't like that much. I repeat, FF is better than 80% of the games in this site.
I agree, which is why I think this game is worth the asking price of 15-20$, there are many many worse games on both here and dlsite that ask for 20$ without having half the polish or content of FF. But I can point out things that I think are bad about this game/demo without being a hater.
 

12435

Newbie
Jan 15, 2018
77
23
1. Bug to be fixed: Male voices are muted, but they play in game over scenes anyway
2. Way too much unnecessary talking...it's the spam Z key simulator. Most of these conversations are meaningless...whether they are about lore, gameplay, whatever
3. Gallery is well done
4. Was hoping there would be some new sexual content, but there isn't an ounce of new sexual content. None of the random NPCs have any cutscenes or animations for sexual content whatsoever
Some npc's do have sexual animations, some flat out ask if you wanna do it, but you are either killing them on sight, or just constantly saying no.
 

OmniFurious

Newbie
Sep 7, 2021
78
112
Salutations MasterXY,
But I want to be engaged with the story, and given how this game has been talked about I was under the assumption these NPC's and choices I make now will effect me later and I'd like to be able to follow the story somewhat as opposed to just mashing through every dialogue box that pops up.
Ah, sorry friend, I paid more attention to the 2nd part I had quoted instead of giving equal attention to the entire thing as a whole, and appear to have only responded in a way that makes sense if you ignore the first half.
I would imagine that several NPCs contribute to their own little stories that span across several levels, even if not directly relating to or making an impact on the general plot of the game.
As cool as it would be to have every NPC play a vital role in the overall story, I feel like with the first level alone, even if half the NPCs were re-occurring characters that played a role in the plot, that would be too many. There's what, like 12 or so NPCs with their own little stories? I can't imagine how someone would work out 48 different characters having such important roles.

Simply saying "well you don't have to read it" is a very poor argument when the dev wants you to take his game seriously. How is anyone going to take this game seriously when the most common response to lore is "lmao just skip it, the dev is already expecting people to not read it". Especially when 75% of the game is this lore.
I assumed you meant that the databanks were a chore that you felt that you were forced to collect. You're right though, the argument for "just skip them" doesn't apply in the case. I hope you see where my viewpoint came from.
If you're indirectly referring to the last thing I quoted and responded to, that was a joke as I took an absolute stance to combat your absolute stance, as this scenario seemed pretty open ended.

My argument is not against the inclusion of databanks that tie into NPC's, my argument is that there is simply too much meaningless databanks mixed together with ones that are actually relevant to the plot/lore/characters, and that it is creating contradicting gameplay loop in which the game wants to be an action platformer, but every room you enter has at least 2 databases with 2-5 minute voice clips and 1 NPC so you're getting like 30-60 seconds of gameplay inbetween every cutscene or voice clip. There is no balance between gameplay and story telling, and the sheer volume of databanks being thrown at you is overwhelming. I am trying to follow the story but I can't keep track of anything, and if I'm trying to keep track but can't, imagine all the people who aren't going to try. Some of the databanks should honestly be culled or removed, or turned into a bronze databank where they just get sent to your codex instead where you have to open it to listen to them there. The silver ones can be ones that are important to the plot/story or an NPC, and the gold ones are about seeber. That would be a better solution if people are against their removal, because there's no way in hell you will ever convince me half of those databanks are even worth reading.
I'm actually right there with you, there's way too much to keep track of without keeping a diary. However, after having done and seen (possibly) absolutely everything this demo has to offer, I see the appeal of fleshing out minor characters and having all this extra stuff, regardless of it probably not contributing to the story. All this lore building of random characters isn't really my main concern when playing a game, so the fact that I can ignore it entirely, or spend some time to learn more about something I assume won't matter in the long run, isn't too big of a deal to me. It's not that much different from audiologs and whatnot in other games, just some extra filler for those who want it.
I'm almost positive that the game tells you not to worry about talking with anyone or looking at silver databanks as they're a waste of time, then mentioning that gold databanks are all you need to focus on if you only want the main story.

I mean, who knows, these little sidestories impact so many things already in this level, so I'd imagine they'll contribute either directly, or indirectly, to the overall story at some points.

Cordially,
OmniFurious
 
Mar 18, 2019
113
117
Do you need to retake second grade? Do you know how to count?

Jan 2016 One year anniversary of development
Jan 2017 Two year anniversary of development
Jan 2018 Third year anniversary
Jan 2019 Fourth year
Jan 2020 Fifth year
Jan 2021 Sixth year
Jan 2022 Seventh year
Jan 2023 Eighth year
Jan 2024 Ninth year

So sure, in three months we'll hit the ninth anniversary of game development, but ideally the game will be finished by then.
I think you might want to read what the other homie said again, and then excuse yourself for calling him stupid in a very backhanded way.
They started on 2015. That was their first year. After Jan 2016 they entered their second year of development.
2023 is almost over, this would be their ninth year, with the anniversary marking the end of said year on Jan 2024. And then 2024 would be their tenth year of development, with Jan 2025 marking the end of said year after which they would have been at it for 10 full years.
Is that better? Do you understand now mate?
 

NDgier

New Member
Aug 7, 2018
1
0
Wow, I subbed a few years ago to have a name on the fire stage and was actually happy to see it. That, and what I thought would just be a databank entry is some side quest involving this game's version of my first book's primordial goddess? Or maybe something else? Whispering Scorpion was certainly an interesting title for her.
 

ArsenicManson

New Member
Aug 22, 2023
3
8
but you're also explicitly inviting people to play the game for the smut. What other reason could you possibly conceive there to be that this wasn't just made to be a hentai game, and has done a poor job at it?
Why a poor job? Aren't there sex scenes? Animated sex scenes? Sex cutscenes? Or that doesn't count? And by what standard are they bad ? The other game that I can remember that does something similar was Kincaid.
 

dragonsix6969

Active Member
Apr 26, 2019
753
496
well nothing new in this demo, only they remove boss now and put some levels in different place, all the same. Oh and of course alot of texts. Even no reward for 100% complete level (like at least new sex scene? maybe?)
 
  • Like
Reactions: kasdiddd

Dinglederper

Member
Dec 19, 2020
221
625
Why a poor job? Aren't there sex scenes? Animated sex scenes? Sex cutscenes? Or that doesn't count? And by what standard are they bad ? The other game that I can remember that does something similar was Kincaid.
I worded that part poorly: I meant in terms of focusing on the hentai content and leaving dialogue and environments as something that gets built over time. The point is that hentai games can be good games, but usually insofar as they contribute to making the sexual element "flow" in a way that enhances it (e.g. that it's practically a genre-wide trope for game overs/defeat to be how you get sex scenes, making defeat a reward), yet there are countless devs with projects spanning numerous years that have IMMENSE bloat in their updates via dialogue updates, background colors/art being changed, touch-ups on lighting, basically just things that don't matter when one asks the question "what's the h-content in the game?"
 

Dee1414

Newbie
Aug 1, 2019
55
320
HW wants to make a great game, and he wants to release it finished, which means sacrificing time for quality. I don't know for sure about Triangulate and FrougeDev but HW does full time develop the game.


It's not because of a sale right at the beginning or whatever, not sure where you got that idea. Steam does not allow people to sell a game for cheaper than its Steam store price on any other storefronts. This includes Patreon, so if HW honored the $10 backer reward they could not release the game on Steam.


Do you need to retake second grade? Do you know how to count?

Jan 2016 One year anniversary of development
Jan 2017 Two year anniversary of development
Jan 2018 Third year anniversary
Jan 2019 Fourth year
Jan 2020 Fifth year
Jan 2021 Sixth year
Jan 2022 Seventh year
Jan 2023 Eighth year
Jan 2024 Ninth year

So sure, in three months we'll hit the ninth anniversary of game development, but ideally the game will be finished by then.


You're so close to understanding it. But you're wrong on the last mark. Rather than being used to deflect flaws, one of the reasons HW is making this game is to show to a wider, normie audience that porn games can be high quality works of art. So the proper reaction would ideally be a normie or average game journalist realizing "Wow, I thought all porn games were low-quality garbage, but this has some real value to it."

And again, if you think this time should have been better spent just adding nothing but sex animations at the expense of any real story you ought to look for a different developer's games.


Nobody is forcing you to read the databanks, my guy. lmao. HW expects that a lot of players would simply skip them and that's alright.


This demo is the first level of the full game, nearly 1:1 with what you'd experience at release.


Having the game be fully voice acted was, as far as I know, a part of the plan from the very beginning. Nothing you could have said could have changed his mind on it, and if you don't like it tough luck I guess.
Yes, we KNOW the game was fully voice acted from the start. That's actually a good thing that is a welcomed piece of production value which is what accrued the game's following. It's the imbalance between gameplay vs lore thats the problem, and if you're not picking that up by now than I dont know what to tell you. I'm assuming you're responding to my last line about hiring the voice actors vs the amount of voice acting time which is what I mean (and not trying to be rude but it really seems like you cherry picked this interpretation). Again just like our boi Omni who makes it his job to intentionally misinterpret everything. Almost like you two are in discussion with one another before posting

TO BE CLEAR:
-Voice acting is good
-Story in H games is good
-Having easter eggs of findable lore IS GOOD

It is not good when:
-There is 15 seconds of gameplay to 15 minutes of (albeit skippable) voice acting lore. Consumers WANT the lore, but not when it's significantly impacting the gameplay. Write a book instead.
-That this voice acted lore is the core reason why the game was in development for almost a decade. In terms of nobody is FORCING anyone to read the databanks, nobody is FORCING anyone to do anything. I can cater a wedding and leave a bunch of turds on the buffet table and tell people "nobody is forcing you to eat them". The person paying for it should still have questions

My issue is that back a zillion years ago HW was addressed with these things and he didnt care. Not saying he should listen to every moron on the internet, but at least consulted someone who might have some gameplay narrative experience. It's clear he didnt, and that's his critical failure.
 
Last edited:

robdelobe

Newbie
Jul 6, 2017
46
66
The game hasn't changed much since the last time I've tried it, generally speaking. It's decent, not something I'd write home about. I do agree with the criticisms in this thread so I don't have much to add to that except that I really don't like HW's writing.

Was never a big fan of the quirky self awareness that has seeped into everything these days. What I really hope he doesn't do is that meta "Acknowledge the Player as a character in the story" crap. It's the thing that keeps me from playing Magic Matchup again. Since whenever I think about the game the thing that comes to mind was how much I hated the ending despite how cute the character design is.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

leugim

Member
Dec 30, 2017
116
179
I think this whole discussion is a very clear reminder to me, of where game dev came from and where it is now...
there is actually discussion on a single person's earnings.. wow.. that come from a game that isnt even a product yet... and in this case, has been a non product for 8 yeaaaars?!
There is actually people, who not only bother, but seem genuinely "invested in justifying" their earnings and try to pitch how hard their financial situation is or how hard their life is, why?

A product is being advertised, a product is not being delivered and yet being paid for, that is all that matters and that is what is wrong with current day game dev
I dont care about his health or financial issues, cuz he does not care about mine, he does not give me money because I do not give him a product, I do not get a product from him so I dont give him money, seems pretty simple.

Don't get me wrong, I am 100% supportive of things like patreon and kickstarter, I think its fine to have "faith" and support devs that show promise, emphasis on promise, but if you support someone who does not deliver, however, I think you shouldn't try to "rationalize" hopes and dreams, you should stop supporting, cuz there sure is too many money milking "devs" who sell hopes and dreams to impressionable minds, and I do hope actual laws are created against it.

I remember being paid to beta test games... man... I dont feel like I'm that old, but if I'm not, how am I witnessing, not only people PAYING for beta testing games, but also simp for devs of "non-games"?!
 

Opinade

Member
Apr 3, 2019
106
76
It's not because of a sale right at the beginning or whatever, not sure where you got that idea. Steam does not allow people to sell a game for cheaper than its Steam store price on any other storefronts. This includes Patreon, so if HW honored the $10 backer reward they could not release the game on Steam.
Yeah, I phrased it badly, but that was what I was getting at. Steam would require them to put the game on sale for $10 instead of 20$ if they stuck to that idea.
 

derakino999

Well-Known Member
Sep 30, 2017
1,138
557
ye they do, and pixel art is always great
anyway
tried out the demo and so far it's great as expected
i already made some suggestions to HW on discord and some of the things i said were already being considered anyway, like for example having an auto-read option where the dialogue automatically advances when the voice stops like typical vn stuff, some button remapping issues as well since i play on controller, and so on
point is everything is great
you don't get punished by not reading databanks too, so maybe people here who think it breaks the pace to go reading them can skip them? some guy before said that basically the point WAS to read them, so skipping them would make no sense, but i think it just affect interactions with NPCs, however, it's not punishing per se, and the only databanks that really matter are the gold ones
sure, if you wanna get the most of it and squeeze the lore it's better to read them, though, and even of that i'm not sure since in interactions it just shows Talia knowing or not knowing the backstory of things
but the point of the game is that each and every one of us should have a different experience with the game, and the fact that you're not punished for skipping them is proof
 

HonedZone

New Member
Jul 29, 2023
8
1
Demo is very good and more than one is online. I feel like already a full game is here compared to sale on other sites. Looking forward to more is exciting, I think it's okay to wait if it is for a good story. They will translate the game it's good to know.
 
3.70 star(s) 84 Votes