To put it bluntly pretty much everything you said is right and wrong.
1.) Agreed.
2.) First part true, second part debatable. First part because they game the like (hint hint it's in the title, is taken over and infested by a totally different game, not in the title)
3.) Ifffy. BB had less than 1200 reaction score (i.e. likes, to the op), this has just over 1100 and BB only beats this by like 70 likes. Compared to something like Being a dick which has over 8k likes. Granted BB does have shit ton of views at over 14mill but again that pales to the aforementioned dick at 30 million. Hell a game like Karryns Prison which I'd never heard of till looking at the rankings, received more likes than BB and only a million less views. Of course you can't say that the likes or views are the decider but it shows that BB clearly was not the top in either of those. So the idea it was the most popular game on this site by FAR is a stretch. I would actually love to see the download ratio, or max unique dl's as that would show what is popular. Edit: I don't deny BB is more popular than Glamour. That's not up for debate. The issue is really that Glamour is no longer Glamour but now BB v X
4.) Funny how Kates story ran fine for over 2 years before needing Max's "rescue". Also strange how he dropped the "
most popular game on this site by far" to make Glamour. (Sorry I couldn't resist)
5.) No completely wrong. It's the Game A we like and support being infested by Game B. If BB was being infested by Kate, i.e. the thread was BB 2.0 the story of Max and Kate and her glamour story was being forced in the way Max is, (Did you miss the part about them mentioning they had to fix the whole college thing that was hard coded for Kate?) This was never about Max or BB, I can assure you the Max fans would be just as pissed.
6.) Ditto
7.) Ditto, expect it's Max that gets ignored.