- May 29, 2019
- 2,291
- 1,802
I don't know about anybody else, but the alphabetical order wouldn't make any meaningful difference for me. Actually, it would just make it more confusing to change their order around for no reason. I think the real reason it's so much slower to find the right one is because of the difference between lining them up horizontally instead of vertically. Compare the following:Also, while I disagree that the separate dropdown list is easier to navigate than going directly to arrow buttons next to the onscreen desire bars, I do agree that the alphabetical ORDER of the list made it easier to find what you're looking for. With that in mind, you could sacrifice the organic order of the desire bars for an alphabetical order. It perhaps doesn't look as pleasing but it would remove a thin layer of learning/memorising where things are.
Versus:Thing ____ Another Thing ____ Something Else ____ Yet Another Thing
It's a lot easier to scan through the latter to find what you're looking for. Of course, as far as *viewing* the stats go, the current horizontal system works perfectly and I'd hate to lose it, which is why I think the old system worked well by having a separate list in the "do stuff" part of the menu.Thing
Another Thing
Something Else
Yet Another Thing
But in any case, I'd say leaving it in its current state is still preferable to swapping their order around arbitrarily. And changing around the bottom part into something else entirely is... undesirable.