- Sep 30, 2017
- 2,370
- 4,948
I do see a possible bad ending, but not in the normal expected route.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
My take on this.
Last edited:
- Thread starter Charolastra
- Start date
My take on this.
yes now that I think about it. Don't have many that have real bad endings but that can happen. Not everything ends in a Fairy Tale ending in real life either.
- Dec 27, 2017
- 6,097
- 20,563
I am pretty sure that there will be an unhappy ending. There have been a lot of places where we could build up points with Haley, and many other choices that could have an effect on the outcome. Why do all that, if they have no effect on the outcome?
Not to mention that there are people playing this game who, for their own reasons, don't like Haley, and would prefer that she and the MC do NOT wind up as sexual partners.
Will they split completely? That seems unlikely given their mutual commitments to and love for each other. But it's not impossible. It wouldn't be the first time that two people, madly in love, fell out for one reason or another.
I can see an ending, though, where they remain close, but the sex stops, and they both wind up with someone else. I'll try my best to avoid that one.
Not to mention that there are people playing this game who, for their own reasons, don't like Haley, and would prefer that she and the MC do NOT wind up as sexual partners.
Will they split completely? That seems unlikely given their mutual commitments to and love for each other. But it's not impossible. It wouldn't be the first time that two people, madly in love, fell out for one reason or another.
I can see an ending, though, where they remain close, but the sex stops, and they both wind up with someone else. I'll try my best to avoid that one.
- May 19, 2019
- 381
- 571
ideal situation is a haley sandra diane 4 some. not the ending, but just something i wanna see. also a haley diane 3some
- Aug 30, 2017
- 1,803
- 3,215
Diane as currently characterized would have absolutely no interest in being a beard unless she was completely free to have sex with other people, which sorta defeats the purpose. She could cover for the occasional parental visit, but that's about it. An occasional threesome partner? Maybe, but we don't know how she feels about women.
Alana's just too casual an acquaintance (thus far) to be elevated to narrative importance, plus she's interested in someone else.
Lisa remains an unpredictable wildcard.
Adriana is married. She's of no use in this regard.
Which leaves Sandra as (so far) the only reasonable Haley+1 option that Ptolemy mentioned. I'll admit that Sandra being okay with Haley feeling her up was, at least to me, a more jarring surprise than the one that everyone's complaining about.
If there's going to be a "bad" end (which I'd define as a break in the relationship between Haley and the MC, whatever that relationship is) it'll almost certainly be based on there being an insufficient number of "Haley points" to survive the confrontation and/or trauma over Klaus. If the devs were really good about allocating points then the threshold number would be exactly the number wherein the MC expressed care for his sister but not require him to have made sexual advances, even though that happens anyway. That allows one to play the game by accepting that the situation turns sexual due to Haley's pursuit but to leave them as twins who love and care for each other even if their sexual relationship ends, which I think would be a logical alternative ending.
I think these are the only endings justified (thus far) by the text:
If that's how it's going to go, people should get used to short updates. Adding or removing either Haley or Sandra from the story is a serious branch, especially because the twins would be unlikely to keep living together if things went to hell. Although, now that I think about it, if Haley moves out or orders the MC to move out there's no real necessity to continue the story beyond that point, given the title.
As usual, this is mostly speculation and there may yet be some twists.
Alana's just too casual an acquaintance (thus far) to be elevated to narrative importance, plus she's interested in someone else.
Lisa remains an unpredictable wildcard.
Adriana is married. She's of no use in this regard.
Which leaves Sandra as (so far) the only reasonable Haley+1 option that Ptolemy mentioned. I'll admit that Sandra being okay with Haley feeling her up was, at least to me, a more jarring surprise than the one that everyone's complaining about.
If there's going to be a "bad" end (which I'd define as a break in the relationship between Haley and the MC, whatever that relationship is) it'll almost certainly be based on there being an insufficient number of "Haley points" to survive the confrontation and/or trauma over Klaus. If the devs were really good about allocating points then the threshold number would be exactly the number wherein the MC expressed care for his sister but not require him to have made sexual advances, even though that happens anyway. That allows one to play the game by accepting that the situation turns sexual due to Haley's pursuit but to leave them as twins who love and care for each other even if their sexual relationship ends, which I think would be a logical alternative ending.
I think these are the only endings justified (thus far) by the text:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
If that's how it's going to go, people should get used to short updates. Adding or removing either Haley or Sandra from the story is a serious branch, especially because the twins would be unlikely to keep living together if things went to hell. Although, now that I think about it, if Haley moves out or orders the MC to move out there's no real necessity to continue the story beyond that point, given the title.
As usual, this is mostly speculation and there may yet be some twists.
Last edited:
- Dec 27, 2017
- 6,097
- 20,563
Which infers that the next release might involve one of the 'bad endings', which would seriously UNcomplicate future scripts.
I seriously believe that the next release [When Haley's Collide] will contain a critical juncture. The MC is going to blindside both girls, and his relationship with Haley could be in danger of being completely ruptured. Even the MC is foreshadowing that Haley might not be coming to his room after this.
- Dec 27, 2017
- 6,097
- 20,563
- Apr 14, 2019
- 1,131
- 4,473
- Apr 19, 2019
- 2,027
- 7,232
Spot on with everything you said but with regards to MC and Haley not living together due to Haley getting upset at MC. I do think it's possible but only for a brief period time before things start to cool over between them.
- Apr 14, 2019
- 1,131
- 4,473
You're forgetting that MC and Haley work right across from each other in the same room, alone, so they would still see each other most days, which could hamper the cooling down process, potentially.
- Apr 19, 2019
- 2,027
- 7,232
Victor and Adriana (If I spelled her name right) both know about Haley's situation so they'll probably give one of them time off. I think Adriana only knows if you're banging her.
- Apr 14, 2019
- 1,131
- 4,473
Fair point, but which would be the one taking the time off? MC or Haley?
Also, the real issue is where would Haley stay, or MC? I think this may be where the importance of MC being in a relationship with Sandra comes into play. MC may end up staying with Sandra if/when things go sideways with Haley. Maybe he would stay with Victor, otherwise? But, if MC and Sandra have broken up, that may cause issues between MC and Victor. It's an interesting dilemma.
- May 1, 2018
- 2,389
- 6,818
Not really, unless Sandra hates you as well for some reason. Gotta assume you can stay with her after things go bad with Haley which adds at least one more branch.
- Apr 14, 2019
- 1,131
- 4,473
Well, that is a potential issue on the Haley-only path, since Sandra asks MC not to call her again. Well, Haley-only for now, anyway.
- Apr 19, 2019
- 2,027
- 7,232
Interesting point... Diane it is!Fair point, but which would be the one taking the time off? MC or Haley?
Also, the real issue is where would Haley stay, or MC? I think this may be where the importance of MC being in a relationship with Sandra comes into play. MC may end up staying with Sandra if/when things go sideways with Haley. Maybe he would stay with Victor, otherwise? But, if MC and Sandra have broken up, that may cause issues between MC and Victor. It's an interesting dilemma.
Joking aside I have no idea. We'll see what Viit decides to do and handle that situation when it comes to it.
- Aug 30, 2017
- 1,803
- 3,215
There's no way they'd live and/or work together if the worst happened. That's a 100% breakup, whether or not sex is involved. Someone's leaving the entire scenario, no matter what the far future brings.
Any "here's how I'd write it" speculation is always fraught, but...here's how I'd write it.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
I say this because writing most of those branches is unnecessary. They're not Haley's Story. I know certain fans will be disappointed, but non-Haley characters can get their own story.
- May 19, 2019
- 381
- 571
ya i have a sneaking suspicion that she might not even return home if the worst happens
- Apr 14, 2019
- 1,131
- 4,473
Actually, just had a thought. Even if MC and Sandra have broken up, he may end up staying at Sandra's place if things go sideways with Haley, because Sandra is away most of the time and there's still Lisa. Lisa would probably let MC hole up with her at Sandra's place while Sandra is away and keep quiet about it. Lots of interesting story potential. XD
- Aug 30, 2017
- 1,803
- 3,215
If there's not enough "gameplay" support to get them through this crisis then they're certainly done as a sexual couple, as loving twins, and as coworkers. To me, that has to be a game over, no matter who or what the MC does after that. There can be an epilogue, and I'm not suggesting that there can't ever be the possibility of reconnection, but it'd have to be far in the future and shouldn't be the subject of gameplay.